Very Low Frequency
Very Low Frequency
Very Low Frequency
com
Abstract
To assess the feasibility of the very-low-frequency electromagnetic (VLF-EM) method in the Schirmacheroasen area of East
Antarctica, and to investigate its response, VLF-EM measurements were performed along four traverses. The preliminary results
reveal the locations of geological boundaries and shear zones/faults, which may indicate that VLF anomalies are due to shear zones
or alteration zones located along contacts between different rock types. The strength of the VLF anomaly decreases over the polar
ice cap. The inphase component of the VLF anomaly, when processed and interpreted with an analytic signal approach, yields
a depth range of 15e30 m, whereas Fraser and Hjelt filter analyses yield a depth range of 25e60 m. The VLF-EM responses along
all four traverses, along with their interpretations, are presented here as a case study.
Ó 2010 Elsevier B.V. and NIPR. All rights reserved.
1873-9652/$ - see front matter Ó 2010 Elsevier B.V. and NIPR. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.polar.2010.09.001
12 P. Gnaneshwar et al. / Polar Science 5 (2011) 11e19
subsurface structure (Behrendt and Wold, 1963; Bormann largest area of granulite facies rocks in the world, sit-
et al., 1986). Although many factors may hamper the uated approximately half way between the main
propagation of a very low frequency (VLF) signal mountain range and the present coastline. The rocks of
(including the presence of highly resistive ice sheets, the Schirmacher Range have undergone multiple epi-
wind-induced electrostatic noise, magnetic storms, and sodes of metamorphism, magmatisation, and deforma-
disturbed ionosphere activity), Wannamaker et al. (2004) tion (Sengupta, 1986). Banded gneiss is the dominant
provided a new view of the geology and geophysics below rock type in the Schirmacher Range; compositional
the South Pole region, based on high-quality magneto- variation in the gneisses reflects the non-uniformity of
telluric (MT) data acquired using specialized hardware. the metamorphic rocks. The rock sequences, intrusives,
In addition, Pfaffling et al. (2007) developed an algorithm and tectonites of the Schirmacher Range have been
that enables sea-ice thickness inversion of helicopter- classified into banded gneiss (thin and thick bands),
borne EM data; the accuracy and applicability of this augen gneiss, biotite gneiss, pyroxene granulites,
algorithm were validated by synthetic data and drillhole amphibolites, calcsilicates, dolorites, basalts, vein
data from East Antarctica. quartz, and pegmatites (Sundararajan and Rao, 2005),
The Indian scientific expeditions to Antarctica in as shown in a geological map of the Schirmacher Oasis
the early 1980s focused on the utility of magnetic area (Fig. 1).
anomalies in delineating structural features across
areas such as the Princess Astrid Coast (Arora et al., 3. VLF-EM measurements
1985). Magnetic mapping over the Schirmacheroasen
(Shirmacher Oasis) region revealed low-amplitude The theory that underlies the VLF-EM technique is
fluctuations, indicating weak magnetization and little well described in the literature (Paterson and Ronka,
spatial variation in the elevation of bedrock 1971; Phillips and Richards, 1975). The VLF-EM
(Bhattacharya and Majumdar, 1987; Gupta and Verma, technique is a passive method that uses radiation from
1986; Mittal and Mishra, 1985; Shikhar et al., 1988). ground-based military radio transmitters (used for
Although the VLF-EM method has been primarily navigation, of which there are about 42 worldwide)
used to map conductive ore deposits (Paal, 1965) it is operating in the VLF band (15e30 kHz) as the primary
useful in investigating the nature of shallow geological EM field. These transmitters generate plane EM waves
features at high resolution (e.g., Aina and Emofurieta, that can induce secondary eddy currents, particularly in
1991). Hence, the 13th and 15th Indian expeditions to electrically conductive elongate 2-D targets. Although
Antarctica performed VLF-EM measurements in the this range is very low for radio transmission, it is
Schirmacher Oasis region with the aim of establishing higher than that used in standard low-frequency EM
the utility (and understanding the response) of the VLF methods (1e3 kHz). Paal (1965) observed that radio
signal in this region, which is known to experience waves at VLFs could be used to prospect for conduc-
frequent magnetic storms. Accordingly, these expedi- tive mineral deposits. Subsequently, VLF transmitters
tions performed VLF-EM measurements (inphase and situated at several locations worldwide have been
quadrature components) along four traverses around the widely used as EM sources for near-surface geological
permanent Maitri research station (India) in East mapping (Ramesh Babu et al., 2007).
Antarctica. These data are analyzed in the present study. The VLF method generally yields considerable EM
anomalies, even over poor conductors such as sheared
2. Geology of the Schirmacher Range contacts, fracture zones, and faults. Hence, this method
has been the most popular tool for the rapid mapping of
The Precambrian basement of the East Antarctic near-surface geological structures (Parker, 1980; Phillips
shield is largely covered by ice, although limited and Richards, 1975; Saydam, 1981; Sundararajan et al.,
outcrops occur along the coastline. The Schirmacher 2006). The VLF-EM unit is a sensitive receiver,
Range is a rock oasis between the continental ice sheet covering the frequency band of the VLF-transmitting
and the coastal ice shelf, occupying an area of app- stations and capable of measuring the vertical compo-
roximately 35 km2 (70 440 3000 Se70 460 3000 S latitude, nents of the secondary field generated by lateral changes
11 240 400 Ee11 540 E longitude). The major mountains in conductivity in earth materials. Herein, that part of the
of Dronning Maud Land run for about 1000 km vertical field which is inphase with the horizontal field is
approximately parallel to the coast. The Schirmacher called the ‘inphase component’; that part which is out-of-
Range, which trends roughly eastewest, belongs to the phase with the horizontal magnetic field is called the
East Antarctic Charnockite Province, which is the ‘out-of-phase (quadrature) component’.
P. Gnaneshwar et al. / Polar Science 5 (2011) 11e19 13
Fig. 1. Geological map of the Schirmacheroasen area, East Antarctica, showing the locations of VLF-EM traverses.
The equipment used for our survey was a VLF-R quadrature components are shown in Fig. 2(a). The data
Meter (Geonics Ltd, Canada). The device was tested in show two main cross-overs in the inphase and quadrature
terms of reception of a clear VLF response when operated profiles. The cross-over towards the southern end of the
in the Antarctic environment, which is known for traverse (peak-to-peak amplitude of 40% of the inphase
frequent magnetic storms that may hinder the trans- component) falls in a depression zone, possibly indi-
mission of VLF signals. To minimize contamination of cating a fault, as fault-related depression zones are
the VLF band by natural high-frequency radio noise from sometimes recognized as shear bands (Bormann et al.,
the ionosphere or aurora, measurements were repeated 1986). The other cross-over occurs near the middle of
twice. Use of the VLF-EM unit revealed that the the profile (240e280 m), corresponding to the southern
Australian broadcasting signal (NWC, frequency margin of the norite body. At the northern end of the
22.3 kHz) was clear enough to conduct a VLF-EM profile, the inphase signature and quadrature component
survey in the Schirmacher Oasis region. We performed show a large negative amplitude over an area of banded
measurements of inphase and quadrature components of gneisses.
the VLF-EM response along four profiles (Fig. 1). During
the survey, frequent repetitions of the measurements 3.2. Traverse-II
were made to assess the repeatability of the observations.
In the following sections, we briefly describe and inter- Traverse-II trends NEeSW across a narrow shear
pret the measured inphase and quadrature components of zone located adjacent to a lake at a site 1 km west of
VLF anomalies along the four traverses. Maitri station (M in Fig. 1). The shear zone, 1.5 m wide,
is mylonitized. The inphase signature shows a cross-over
3.1. Traverse-I at approximately 130 m along the traverse, coincident
with the shear zone (as indicated by the arrow in Fig. 2
Traverse-I crosses a hill of olivine-bearing norite (b)). The imaginary signature (quadrature component),
located adjacent to Taatvanett Lake (TL) (the Indian on the other hand, shows an inverse relationship with
name for this lake is Priyadarshini Lake) (Fig. 1). The topography, probably reflecting the terrain effect.
width of the norite body [dyke like body dominated by
orthopyroxene (hypersthene), calcic plagioclase and 3.3. Traverses-III and -IV
small grains of ilmenite (Simpson and Aslund, 1996).
Norite is medium-coarse grained and is characterised by Traverse-III (Fig. 3(a)) trends approximately NEe
a subhedral granular texture.] along the traverse is about SW and crosses a fault located near Trishul Hill (TH in
35 m. The traverse trends approximately NeS and is Fig. 1, 4 km west of Maitri). The fault has displaced
400 m long. The raw data profiles of the inphase and a 2-m-wide pegmatite vein that occurs within the banded
14 P. Gnaneshwar et al. / Polar Science 5 (2011) 11e19
arising from a subsurface 2-D current distribution values. Negative parts on both sides of the conductor can
assumed to be located in a thin horizontal sheet of be caused either by the length of the filter or by a decrease
varying current density situated everywhere at a depth in current density due to current gathering, which is not
equal to the distance between measurement stations. This present in 2-D structures (Nabighian, 1982).
approach involves filtering the same dataset for various In its simplest form, the Fraser filter can be
depths and indicates the change in current density with expressed as
depth. The areas with high current density correspond to ðDz=2pÞIxðDx=2Þ ¼ 0:205H2 þ 0:323H1
good conductors. In the absence of numerical modeling,
this filtering technique has found wide popularity 1:446H0 þ 1:446H1 0:323H2
because it provides a simple, readily implemented sch- þ 0:205H3 Ia ðDx=2Þ ð1Þ
eme for semi-quantitative analysis and target visualiza-
tion (Ramesh Babu et al., 2007; Sundararajan et al., where Δz is the assumed thickness of the current sheet,
2006). The apparent current density pseudo-section Ia is the current density, and Dx is the distance between
should provide a pictorial indication of the depths of data points (and also the depth to the current sheet). The
various current concentrations and hence the spatial values of H2 through H3 are the normalized vertical
distribution of subsurface geological features (Ogilvy magnetic field anomaly at each of the six data points.
and Lee, 1991). Over conductors, the inphase part of The location of the calculated current density is beneath
the equivalent current distribution has only positive the center of the six data points.
Fig. 4. (a) Analytic signal analysis of the VLF-EM inphase component (Traverse-I). (b) Analytic signal analysis of the VLF-EM inphase
component (Traverse-II).
16 P. Gnaneshwar et al. / Polar Science 5 (2011) 11e19
Fig. 6. (a) Fraser-filtered inphase component (in %; Traverse-I). (b) Fig. 7. (a) Fraser-filtered inphase component (in %; Traverse-II). (b)
Hjelt-filtered inphase component (in %; Traverse-I). Hjelt-filtered inphase component (in %; Traverse-II).
filters, the section should approximately resemble the useful for obtaining a qualitative view of the structure,
current pattern in the ground. However, it must be particularly after filtering the data and analyzing the
emphasized that this is only an approximation of the current density across the section. For a more reliable
section (Wright, 1988). Thus, construction of the interpretation, VLF data alone are not sufficient;
pseudo-section consists of a number of steps, like
processing profiles with as many as number of levels
(approximately 5 or 6); at each level, in terms of
integer multiples of the station spacing (nDx; where n
is the number of levels and Dx is the station spacing).
Finally, the results separated by nDx at each level are
plotted one below the other, thereby forming a section.
The inphase components of all the traverses are
subjected to both Fraser filtering and Hjelt filtering,
using interactive MATLAB-based software (Ramesh
Babu et al., 2007; Sundararajan et al., 2006). The
corresponding pseudo-sections (plots of station interval
vs. depth) are shown in Figs. 6e9. The inferred depth
from the pseudo-sections ranges from 25 to 60 m,
thereby partially correlating with depths obtained from
analytic signal analysis, as discussed earlier.
Although it is known theoretically that the
conductor lies at the maximum of the negative gradient
(inflexion) of the VLF inphase component, we prefer
the cross-over of the inphase and quadrature compo-
nents as an indicator of a conductor (Sundararajan
et al., 2006), based on our earlier VLF-EM study of
groundwater (Sundararajan et al., 2007). The inter-
pretation of VLF data may be difficult because the
transmitted frequency may give rise to secondary fields Fig. 8. (a) Fraser-filtered inphase component (in %; Traverse-III). (b)
from many geological features. However, VLF data are Hjelt-filtered inphase component (in %; Traverse-III).
18 P. Gnaneshwar et al. / Polar Science 5 (2011) 11e19
Acknowledgments
Gupta, H.K., Verma, A.K., 1986. Magnetic characteristics in from the Schirmacher Oasis, East Antarctica. J. Geol. 14,
Antarctica over geological contact in Schirmacher hill region and 615e625.
the ice shelf near Dakshin Gangotri. Tech. Pub. No. 3, DOD, New Reading, A.M., 2006. The seismic structure of Precambrian and early
Delhi, pp. 31e239. Palaeozoic terranes in the Lambert Glacier region, East
Kaikkonen, P., 1979. Numerical VLF modeling. Geophys. Prosp. 27, Antarctica. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 244, 44e57.
815e834. Santosh, M., Maruyama, S., Yamamoto, S., 2009. The making and
Karous, M., Hjelt, S.E., 1977. Determination of apparent current density breaking of supercontinents: some speculations based on super-
from VLF measurements: report. Department of Geophysics, plumes, super downwelling and the role of tectosphere. Gond-
University of Oulu, Finland, Contribution No. 89, p. 19. wana Res. 15, 324e341.
Karous, M., Hjelt, S.E., 1983. Linear filtering of VLF dip-angle Saydam, A.S., 1981. Very low frequency electromagnetic interpre-
measurements. Geophys. Prosp. 31, 782e794. tation using tilt angle and ellipticity measurements. Geophysics
McLean, M.A., Wilson, C.J.L., Boger, S.D., Betts, P.G., 46, 1594e1606.
Rawling, T.J., Damaske, D., 2009. Basement interpretations from Sengupta, S., 1986. Geology of Schirmacher Range (Dakshin Gangotri),
airborne magnetic and gravity data over the Lambert Rift region East Antarctica. Tech. Pub. No. 3, DOD, New Delhi, pp. 187e217.
of East Antarctica. J. Geophys. Res. 114, B06101. Shikhar, C.J., Dhar, R., Reddy, K.N.S., 1988. Geophysical investi-
Mittal, G.S., Mishra, D.C., 1985. Magnetic characteristics of Princess gations in Schirmacher land mass. Tech. Pub. No. 5, DOD, New
Astrid Coast of Antarctica, 70 S, 12 E north of Dakshin Gang- Delhi, pp. 145e150.
otri. Tech. Pub. No. 2, DOD, New Delhi, pp. 47e51. Simpson, G., Aslund, T., 1996. Diorite and gabbro of the Dromedary
Nabighian, M.N., 1972. The analytical signal of 2-D magnetic bodies mafic complex, South Victoria Land, Antarctica. N.Z. J. Geol.
with polygonal cross section, its properties and use for automated Geophys. 39, 403e414.
anomaly interpretation. Geophysics 37, 507e512. Sundararajan, N., 1983. Interpretation Techniques in Geophysical
Nabighian, M.N., 1982. Electromagnetic methods in applied Exploration Using Hilbert Transform. Ph.D. Thesis, Osmania
geophysics. Soc. Explor. Geophys. 2, 521e640. University, Hyderabad, India, pp. 191.
Ogilvy, R.D., Lee, A.C., 1991. Interpretation of VLF-EM in phase data Sundararajan, N., Chary, M.N., Nandakumar, G., Srinivas, Y., 2007.
using current density pseudosections. Geophys. Prosp. 39, 567e580. VLF and VESdan application to groundwater exploration,
Paal, G., 1965. Ore prospecting based on VLF radio signals. Geo- Khammam, India. The The Leading Edge 26, 708e716.
exploration 3, 139e147. Sundararajan, N., Ramesh Babu, V., Shiva Prasad, N., Srinivas, Y.,
Parker, M.E., 1980. VLF electromagnetic mapping for strata-bound 2006. VLFPROSda Matlab code for processing of VLF-EM
mineralization near Aberfeldy, Scondland. Trans. Inst. Min. data. Comput. Geosci. 32, 1806e1813.
Metall. Sect. B 89, B123eB133. Sundararajan, N., Rao, B.M., 2005. A note on the petrophysical
Paterson, N.R., Ronka, V., 1971. Five years of surveying with the very properties and geological interpretation in Schirmacher Oasis,
low frequency electromagnetic method. Geoexploration 9, 7e26. East Antarctica. J. Geol. Soc. India 65, 497e503.
Pfaffling, A., Haas, C., Reid, J.E., 2007. Direct helicopter EMdsea- Sundararajan, N., Srinivas, Y., 1996. A modified Hilbert transform
ice thickness inversion assessed synthetic and field data. and its application to self potential interpretation. J. Appl. Geo-
Geophysics 72, F127eF137. phys. 36, 137e143.
Phillips, W.J., Richards, W.E., 1975. A study of the effectiveness of Sundararajan, N., Srinivas, Y., Rao, T.L., 2000. Sundararajan trans-
the VLF method for the location of narrow mineralized zones. formda tool to interpret potential field anomalies. Explor.
Geoexploration 13, 215e226. Geophys. 31, 621e628.
Ramesh Babu, V., Ram, S., Sundararajan, N., 2007. Modeling of magnetic Wannamaker, P.E., Stodt, J.A., Pellerin, L., Olsen, S.L., Hall, D.B.,
and VLF-EM with an application to basement fracturesda case study 2004. Structure and thermal regime beneath the South Pole
from Raigad, India. Geophysics 71, 133e140. region, East Antarctica, from magnetotelluric measurements.
Ravikant, V., 2006. SmeNd isotopic evidence for Late Meso- Geophys. J. Int. 157, 36e54.
proterozoic metamorphic relics in the East African Orogen Wright, J.L., 1988. VLF Interpretation Manual. Scintrex, Toronto.