Hiv Live 2
Hiv Live 2
Hiv Live 2
Results Thirty-six patients were invited to participate in the So I went to a Chinese clinic ...that is where I was buying
study, of whom 30 agreed to a home visit for the purpose of that drug from which was very expensive but it didn’t help
undertaking an interview. Those who participated were very me.....I experienced skin problems that were not
seriously or terminally ill. Many were bedridden and eight of disappearing and I went to Dr. X’s clinic (a private
patients died before being able to participate in an interview. oncologist). I also went to the Infectious Disease Institute to
Thus, 22 patients (10 female and 12 male) were interviewed. get HAART which has helped me to live and now [the]
Participants’ age ranged from 18 to 60 years. Twenty family hospice doctor. (Participant E)
caregivers were nominated by patients to participate in the
study and took part in joint interviews with the patient who I have gone to a witchdoctor ...it was my daughters who
nominated them. Socio-demographic and clinical profile of took me there and the witchdoctor would give us a pounded
participants are described in Table 1. form of herbal medicines...with instructions to boil then and
What prompted patients to seek help? give me plenty to drink of it. (Participant D)
Physical needs Patients described persistent and troublesome Others resorted to drastic ‘self-help’ measures before
symptoms as the main impetus behind their decision to seek seeking medical help. For example, participant C with Kaposi’s
sarcoma reported how he had begun to try to cut the ‘blister’ badly, and I said ‘ Oh God, why am I breathing so badly’ ?
from his arm when his neighbours and friends started to avoid (Participant B)
him:
Just weakness and pain... the weakness is worrying her
People began fearing me when the wound opened up and more because there are some things she would like to do on
the flesh started coming out...I did not know what to do with her own, naturally she is very hard working. (Daughter,
it, so I began to chop off the blistering growth in my arm. caring for participant A).
(Participant C)
Psychosocial and emotional distress As well as urgent
Patients were often almost completely incapacitated physical needs, distress caused by the psychosocial and
before any formal health care was sought. Overwhelm- ingly emotional consequences of living with HIV/AIDS frequently
severe pain, fatigue, cough and dyspnea were com- mon lay behind patients’ and carers’ decisions to seek help and to
experiences: eventually accept referral to hospice care. The strains of family
care- giving and the intersection of emotional distress with
The wounds in the feet are disturbing me. By the time I got poverty were particularly important. While poverty sometimes
off the bed I had some little strength but I was breathing acted as a brake on help seeking behavior
Too et al. BMC Palliative Care (2015) 14:67 Page 3 of 7
they would disclose their status to lever access this support,
which sometimes in turn enabled help to be sought from formal
health care channels. In contrast, where participants felt that
either there was no possibility of support or that disclosure
would damage their relation- ships with others and undermine
any help that they may already be receiving, they kept their
diagnosis a secret. For example participant H, describes her
selective disclosure to one relative but not to others, for fear of
being discrimi- nated against:
Semi-urban 6 27.4
Rural 8 36.3
Stage IV 17 77.3
Opportunistic
infections
Gender Male 12 54.5 forms of help out of sheer necessity and because of
Female 10 45.5 abandonment:
You see I am like this: she has diarrhoea, sometimes her When people at home discovered that participant F has
clothes are soaking wet and I need to clean, I need gloves. ..I HIV/AIDS and cancer they left us and abandoned us, so we
don’t even know if I have contracted [it], you see I don’t learnt to be on our own....Now [our] money is over and we
know my status. (Daughter-in-law of participant D) are now walking in the Kampala Street, hoping to get
Carer’s gender Male 3 13.6 someone to help us. If we get a ‘ g ood Samaritan’ we will
Female 19 86.4 thank God (Wife of Participant F)
Carer’s relationship Spouse 8 36.8
I did not want people to see me...Even people at home
Family member
started to isolate me. .. you find they say don’t use our basin,
(sibling or relative)
4 63.6 don’t use our cup... use your own cup... get your own plate
4 63.6 ....I used to work in an hotel and she (boss) feared that I
would stick to her in the final stages of my disease so she
kicked me off the hotel (Participant I)
What barriers were there to help seeking? We have
already alluded above to the dual role that poverty played in In one case included in this study a comparatively young
hindering and facilitating help seeking behaviour. Stigma was widow aged 39, had been abandoned by her husband’s family
another key factor that played an important but complex role in because of fears of contagion and had to return to her parental
relation to help seeking behaviour, acting both as a prompt and home. However, on her return, her immedi- ate family
struggled to care for her and she was put into an old, abandoned
building where the only person in at- tendance was a young no longer smelling (Participant L)
child. The child looked depressed and tired and was unable to
attend school because of the duties thrust upon her. Participant I used to have . .. what I can I say it makes your face ...
B eventually accessed help from the hospice but died seven depressed ... like fear ... but now I’ m feeling better. You see,
weeks after her re- ferral, having been admitted to hospital like now in the morning, I woke up and I had nothing to do
from home for emergency intervention for dyspnoea. ... then I was trying to make a table in the workshop [place
of employment] ... Even when I go back to Kabale ... I can
Experiences of services from Hospice Africa dig ... as you have found me working in the workshop and
Uganda All the patients who were interviewed described even go back to school. (Participant M)
some form of positive impact from accessing hospice services.
Immediate benefits included control of severe pain and other In some situations, participants reported that they had
symptoms, with subsidiary benefits reported as re- lief ofreceived support prior to their referral to HAU from several
loneliness and a sense of being cared for. A con- trast betweenAIDS agencies that offered specialised services, but often at a
hospice care and hospital care was sometimes drawn bycost. Patients were therefore particularly grateful for the free
patients: services they were offered at HAU. For instance, Participant N
described how he was able to access morphine at no cost to
The wound [a fungating Kaposi’s sarcoma] was so painful, himself when he was re- ferred to HAU:
but now it is only ‘ paralysed’ but not [so] painful. I used to
experience lots of pain and did not have specialised care, I will tell you the situation I am in because before I was in a
but now I get visited like now you have come [to my] home. very bad situation but now I see a difference....In this
I am always lonely since my daughter is married and I am illness, without telling lies, from the time I started going to
alone here (Participant J) the Infectious Disease Institute, I have not bought any
medication [HAART].. I like hospice also for giving me the
Even with all these drugs (showing them to the researcher) morphine for which I also don’t pay (Participant N)
they have been giving me . ..the symptoms were not going.
But since I came here and was given some treatment there is While most of the patients reported improvement in
some improvement and I don’t have diarrhoea so their physical condition when they enrolled for hospice care
much. ..you, the hospice, when I come to you, you take care services, some perceived that in addition, HAU had helped
of me and you give me some assistance. Because some them address their needs for subsistence. How- ever, the
hospitals you go to, no- hospice was limited in what it could provide meaning that
one takes care of you and your illness gets worse (Par-
patients’ expectations could not always be met:Last time you
ticipant K)
came you gave me some sugar and now it
is finished and you
Longer term rehabilitative impacts were also reported; know now I am not working and I am not leaving the house. I
these involved reactivation of social interaction or in some have backache and I have nowhere to get it. (Participant O)
cases resumption of employment or schooling.
Some lived in hopes that the hospice would address all
There has been a big improvement, even people notice ... I their needs, including provision of school fees for their
am able to interact with people now and move around. I children:
can wear shoes. ..I feel good about myself now, since I am
Too et al. BMC Palliative Care (2015) 14:67 Page 5 of 7
have money to take him to school (Participant P)
‘Though I may want to work, I don’t have help. Any work I
can do, for instance, before I was dealing in buying and Discussion This study explored the experiences of patients
selling of bananas but now there is no money. I want the living with AIDS who were newly referred Hospice Africa
hospice to assist my child, especially with school fees, Uganda and their caregivers. Qualitative interviews re- vealed
because the father died and the child has no help. I don’t the extent of suffering patients endured and the strain that
family caregivers experienced before help was sought or and perceived effectively manage problems such as pain and
accessed, and how poverty and stigma were, depending on the other symptoms and to provide rehabilitation. How- ever,
patient and family situation, both mo- tivators and barriers to
poverty and a sense of stigma were widespread. Further
help seeking behaviour. research is needed to understand how poverty and stigma can
There are a number of limitations to the study conclu-be effectively managed in hospice care for patients for
sions. Our study involved a small sample of participants whoadvanced AIDS and their families.
were either self-referred or were referred by others to HAU.
Competing interests The authors declare that they have no
Caution should therefore be taken when con- sidering thecompeting interests.
transferability of the findings. We relied on the HAU outreach
team to identify and access patients’ homes and, as such, theAuthors’ contributions WT had the major input into the design, analysis
and interpretation of the data. WT carried out the data collection. MW, RH
researcher was looked upon by patients and their families asand JS contributed as PhD supervisors to the design, analysis and
part of the home-visiting team. This may have introduced biasnterpretation. All authors read and approved the final manuscript
in the manner that participants spoke about their situation and
may have deterred them from making any critical comments.Acknowledgement We are very grateful for the participation of patients
and their family members. We also wish to thank Hospice Africa
An alternative approach may have been to return to inter- viewUganda for their support towards data collection. The University of
participants without the hospice outreach team but this wasNottingham provided research funds which supported this study.
impractical for reasons of travel costs and trans- lator
availability. Author details 1Kabarak University, School of Medicine and Health
Our findings on the role of stigma in the lives of patientsSciences, P O Private Bag-20157
Kabarak, Nakuru, Kenya. 2 School of
with AIDS resonate with a range of research undertaken inHealth Sciences, University of Nottingham, Queen’s Medical Centre,
3
Uganda and other African countries [3, 13, 15], and particularlyDerby Road, Nottingham NG7 2UH, UK. The Cicely Saunders Institute,
Bessemer Road, Kings College, London SE5 9PJ, UK.
draw attention to the need for further research which examines
the relationships between stigma, pa- tients’ and familiesReceived:
’ 16 January 2015 Accepted: 25 November 2015
degree of emotional distress and their perceptions of, and
access to, services. One study in South Africa [15] suggestsReferences 1. UNAIDS/WHO. Overview of the global AIDS epidemic.
that hospice care itself was experi- enced by AIDS patients andGeneva: UNAIDS; 2006. 2. Cox S, Gazzard B. Models for palliative care in
their families as stigmatising. This was not apparently the casesub-Saharan Africa. Int Health.
in our study, possibly be- cause of how well known and 2010;2(2):77–8. 3. Lowther K, Harding R, Selman L,
Higginson IJ. Experience of persistent
respected HAU was in the Kampala district where the study
psychological symptoms and perceived stigma among people with HIV on
was conducted. Antiretroviral therapy (ART)? A systematic review. Int J Nurs Studies. 2014,
Our findings on the profound poverty of people withn press. 4. Grant E, Murray SA, Grant A, Brown J. A good death in rural
Kenya?
AIDS and their families lend further support to the need for
Listening to Meru patients and their families talk about care needs at the
palliative care in low income countries to be concep- tualisedend of life. J Palliat Care. 2003;19(3):159–67. 5. Sepulveda C,
more broadly than in high income countries [10], while theHabiyambere V, Amandua J, Borok M, Kikule E, Mudanga B, et al. Quality
manner in which HAU was perceived to embrace the patientcare at the end of life in Africa. Br Med J. 2003;327(7408):209–13. 6.
Ministry H. Health sector strategic plan III 2010/11-2014/15. Edited by
and their family as the unit of care arguably has lessons for
Health. Kampala: Ministry of Health; 2010. 7. UNAIDS/WHO.
how the provision of palliative care can be improved in highUNAIDS report on global epidemic. In Global Report. 2010:
income countries. Geneva; 2010. 8. Kikule E. A good death in Uganda: survey of
Participants perceived that hospice care not only re- needs for palliative care for terminally ill people in urban areas. Br Med J.
2003;327(7408):192–4. 9. Whitehead M, Dahlgren G, Evans T. Equity and
lieved their most urgent physical pain and symptoms health sector reforms: can low-income countries escape the medical
(with some patients receiving morphine for the first time) but poverty trap? Lancet. 2001;358: 833–6. 10. Clark D, Wright M, Hunt J,
also in many cases enabled their participation in social life Lynch T. Hospice and palliative care development
once more, thus supporting family care in the community. n Africa: a multi-method review of services and experiences. J Pain
Symptom Manag. 2007;33(6):698–710. 11. Uren SA, Graham TM.
Subjective experiences of coping among caregivers in
Conclusion This research is the first study focused on palliative care. Online J Issues Nurs. 2013,
patients’ and families’ experiences living with AIDS following 18(2):1-24.
referral to hospice in Uganda. Hospice care was highly valued
Too et al. BMC Palliative Care (2015) 14:67 Page 6 of 7
Too et al. BMC Palliative Care (2015) 14:67 Page 7 of 7
• Our selector tool helps you to find the most relevant journal