The Ten Unanswered Questions

The Ten Unanswered Questions
There are two main texts in the Pali scriptures, Sutras 63 and 72 of the Majjhima
Nikaya, each with the same list of ten propositions or 'views' (ditthi):
1. The world is eternal.

2. The world is not eternal.
3. The world is (spatially) infinite.
4. The world is not (spatially) infinite.
5. The soul (jiva) is identical with the body.
6. The soul is not identical with the body.
7. The Tathagata (a perfectly enlightened being) exists after death.
8. The Tathagata does not exist after death.
9. The Tathagata both exists and does not exist after death.
10. The Tathagata neither exists nor does not exist after death.
The Buddha refused to give any teaching about these issues, although the monk
Malunkyaputta challenged him:
If the Lord knows that the world is eternal, let the Lord explain to
me that the world is eternal. If the Lord knows that the world is not
eternal, let the Lord explain to me that the world is not eternal. If
the Lord does not know whether the world is eternal or whether
the world is not eternal, then, not knowing, not seeing, this would
be honest, namely to say, 'I do not know, I do not see'. And
likewise with the other questions (Majjhima Nikaya, 63:427).
The monk Vacchagotta inquired about the state of the Tathagata after death. In
response the Buddha rejects as inapplicable the entire range of possible answers in
terms of which the question was posed:
'Arise', Vaccha, does not apply.

Well, then, good Gotama, does he not arise?
'Does not arise', Vaccha, does not apply.
Well then, good Gotama, does he both arise and not arise?
'Both arises and does not arise', Vaccha, does not apply.
Well then, good Gotama, does he neither arise nor not arise?
'Neither arises nor does not arise', Vaccha, does not apply.
(Majjhima Nikaya, 72:486)
Vaccha then expresses his bewilderment and disappointment, and the Buddha
responds:
You ought to be at a loss, Vaccha, you ought to be bewildered. For

Vaccha, this dharma is deep, difficult to see, difficult to
understand, peaceful, excellent, beyond dialectics, subtle,
intelligible to the wise. (Majjhima Nikaya, 72:487)
He is referring all the time to the mystery of parinirvana, nirvana beyond this life. It
is misleading to say that after death the Tathagata - that is, the fully enlightened
individual that we know in this life - exists, or does not exist, or both exists and does
not exist, or neither exists nor non-exists beyond this life. The Buddha then
illustrates the idea of a question that is so put that it has no answer by speaking of a
flame that has been quenched. In which direction has the flame gone - east, west,
north or south? None of the permitted answers applies. Likewise what happens after
the bodily death of a Tathagata cannot be expressed in our available categories of
thought.
The Buddha's fundamental point was that to know the answers to these questions is
not necessary for liberation. To treat them as though they were will only hinder our
advance toward liberation. To make his point he told the parable of the man pierced
by a poisoned arrow. If he insists, before receiving medical treatment, on knowing
who shot the arrow, and of what clan he is, what kind of bow he was using, what the
bow string and the shaft of the arrow were made of, from what kind of bird the
feathers on the arrow came, and so on, he will die before his thirst for knowledge is
satisfied. Likewise, if we distract ourselves from the path to enlightenment by trying
to settle these disputed cosmological and metaphysical issues we may well fail to be
healed from birth, ageing, dying, grief, sorrow, suffering, lamentation and despair.
These matters are set aside by the Buddha because such knowledge 'is not
connected with the goal, is not fundamental to the Brahma-faring, and does not
conduce to turning away from, nor to dispassion, stopping, calming, super-
knowledge, awakening nor to nirvana' (Majjhima Nikaya, 63:431).
The above is excerpted from “The Buddha’s Undetermined Questions” by John Hick in Disputed Questions in Theology and the
Philosophy of Religion, Yale University Press New Haven, CT, 1993.

The Ten Unanswered Questions

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

The Ten Unanswered Questions

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

The Ten Unanswered Questions

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

The Ten Unanswered Questions

1. The world is eternal.

'Arise', Vaccha, does not apply.

You ought to be at a loss, Vaccha, you ought to be bewildered. For

You might also like