Polymer Outdoor Insulators: Article
Polymer Outdoor Insulators: Article
Polymer Outdoor Insulators: Article
net/publication/266095712
Article
CITATIONS READS
3 156
1 author:
Michael Danikas
Democritus University of Thrace
153 PUBLICATIONS 1,280 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Small partial discharges, charging phenomena and detection techniques View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Michael Danikas on 03 March 2015.
Abstract: Although polymeric insulators seem to be an alternative to more traditional materials such as
porcelain or glass, their long term electrical and mechanical performance cannot be predicted accurately
and there are not as yet tests predicting their long term behavior. A basic reason for this is that the aging
process, which affects the long-term performance, is not fully understood.
provide results consistent with field end fittings (or caps) provides the mechanical
experience. This can only be achieved if the strength to the insulator. The surrounding
failure mechanisms in the test are similar to polymer weathershed consisting of the sheath
those experienced in service. and skirts provides the electrical strength
It is the purpose of this paper to look at under all conditions (dry, wet, contaminated).
the problem areas of polymeric insulators, to The fibber glass rod is made up of electrical
review the work done on polymeric insulator grade glass fibbers bonded with either epoxy
aging and to comment on proposed or polyester resin. Of the two resins, epoxy
laboratory aging methods, to try to see if resin bonded fibber glass rods have higher
there is a relation between laboratory results mechanical strength, although there are
and service data, and to indicate areas insulators with the polyester resin bonded
needing more work and further clarification. rods that are operating successfully. The rods
can be cast or pultruded. The rod is attached
2. Problem Areas of Polymeric Insulators to the aluminium or malleable iron end
fittings by means of a crimp, wedge or glue.
Figure 1 shows a typical polymeric The crimped fitting seems to provide the best
insulator with its constituent parts. The method of attachment. The fibber glass rod
central fibber glass rod attached to two metal has to be protected from moisture under all
conditions. This is due to the fact that the
organic resin easily carbonizes in the
combined presence of electric stress and
moisture, rendering thus the insulator useless.
The protection is provided by the
weathershed material. Many groups of
polymers have been tried as weathershed
materials but only a few were found to
perform satisfactorily. These are silicone
rubbers and ethylene propylene rubbers.
Cycloaliphatic epoxies have been used
successfully in the past under certain
conditions. Ethyl vinyl acetate is being used
on certain types of cable terminations.
As problem areas can be regarded the
following: (a) poor bonding between the
fibber reinforced (FRP) rod and the housing
material, (b) the weathershed material itself,
which, because of improper selection of
ingredients and/or manufacturing, may be
prone to erosion and tracking, and (c) an
inadequate attachment of the FRP rod to the
end fitting(s). Case (c) causes the mechanical
failure of the insulator whereas (a) and (b) are
causes of electrical failure. Mechanical aging
or loss of mechanical strength occurs due to
the fact that the fibber glass rod of the
insulator is carrying a load (conductor) for
the entire life. The glass fibbers elongate and
bonding between fibbers may deteriorate
under the load. Mechanical failure results in
Fig. 1. Typical polymeric insulator with its
constituent parts (after [50]).
the loss of ability to hold the conductor,
Volume 40, Number 1, 1999 5
which is the primary function of an insulator. polymer [6]. The assumption that acids
Electrical aging of the weathershed material originate from internal partial discharges [10]
occurs due to leakage current dry band arcing seems to be contradicted by later results [11].
in the presence of moisture and Brittle fracture occurs because of stress
contamination. Uncontrolled dry band arcing corrosion of the glass fibbers. This entails
leads to tracking (carbonization) and/or loss of mechanical strength with time,
erosion. Tracking results in the formation of a sometimes gradual and sometimes
conducting path on the surface leading to a catastrophic [3].
flashover. Erosion, on the other hand, is a Brittle fractures as well as the
loss of material but is not as serious as mechanical behavior of polymeric insulators
tracking. It can, however, under uncontrolled have been studied in the laboratory. In [5] the
conditions, lead to exposure of the fibber authors proposed a brittle fracture test by
glass rod to the environment and therefore simultaneously stressing a FRP rod
failure in a short time interval thereafter. mechanically and chemically, the latter being
an attack by an aqueous nitric acid. This 96-
3. Mechanical Aging hour test is a discriminatory test and not
necessarily a test predicting the long-term
The mechanical performance of a performance of a polymeric insulator. The
polymeric insulator depends on the authors of [5] reported good reproducibility
characteristics of its FRP rod and its metal of results and moreover, a similarity between
fittings. The FRP rod is the component, the failures encountered in the laboratory and
which will withstand the mechanical loads. those happening in practice.
The characteristics of the FRP rod and its The mechanical behavior of a polymeric
mechanical quality are closely related to the insulator depends also on the fittings. The
intrinsic properties of its basic constituent fitting has to design in a way as to avoid local
materials (types of glass fibber and matrix stresses and to ensure uniform distribution of
resin) [3]. The fitting, which is the element the mechanical load between the fiber [3].
transmitting the mechanical stress to the FRP Reactive metals have to be avoided since
rod, is the other crucial component contamination can spread over the critical
determining the mechanical behaviour of the region of the contact between the fitting and
polymeric insulator. the FRP rod.
Early service data indicated that there Another approach to mechanical aging
were several mechanical failures of was formulated in [12,13]. Rupture tests were
polymeric insulators after only a short time. It performed with various insulators and their
was thought that these failures were due to time-to-failure was recorded. A dependence
localized damage, electrical or chemical in of the rupture load on temperature was
nature, or to severe conditions of dynamic noticed. No single load value could describe
mechanical loading [3,4]. Subsequent the characteristics of a polymeric insulator,
research [5,6] has established that these the mechanical behaviour being dependent
failures, known as "brittle fractures", are not only on the quality of the FRP rod but
characterized by a transverse fracture to the also on the type of the end fittings (it was
axis of the rod and occur near the fittings. noted that the compression fittings were the
This fracture pattern could be simulated with best suited for a reliable long term
a mechanical stressing of the rod together performance). Furthermore, it was also noted
with an attack by a corrosive medium [7 - 9]. that a polymeric insulator should be selected
As to the origin of such a corrosive on both the average daily load and the
medium, it is more likely that it comes from extraordinary load. In yet another work [14],
the outside either through the polymeric the response of polymeric insulators to
weathershed or through imperfections in the dynamic mechanical loads was investigated.
adhesion between the metal fitting and the Reference [14] constitutes an important
6 ACTA ELECTROTEHNICA NAPOCENSIS
contaminated, had led many to believe that insulators is lower than that of EPDM
the material would not age much during the insulators subjected to the same natural
expected life of the insulator. But this was aging, (f) a reduction of the contact angle in
proven not to be true. By determining the silicone rubber insulators seems to be due to
permanent changes that are not time an increase of the surface roughness and to an
dependent like hydrophobicity, it was shown increase of the surface polarization due to
that the silicone rubber ages, and that surface hydroxyl presence, which in turn decreases
hydrophobicity is not a good indicator of the surface hydrophobicity, and (g) the
aging. development of leakage currents and of
Service experience accumulated through surface degradation is different for various
several years in different countries [3,4] polymers, showing clearly the importance of
showed that polymeric materials (teflon, the manufacturing process for the housing
EPM, EPDM, silicone rubber, cycloaliphatic materials and at the same time that the
resin) were prone to surface erosion when presently used accelerated aging tests are not
thick pollution layers were formed. Silicone suitable since they tend to show that the
rubber showed a certain advantage because of degradation of polymers is more a function of
its water repellency in comparison to the their inorganic filler. The above briefly
other housing materials, it proved, however, described work by the Chalmers University
to be sensitive to thick pollution layer of Technology group is remarkable in that it
exposure [4]. uses a variety of presently available
EPM and EPDM weathersheds suffered techniques in order to monitor the behaviour
from chalking and crazing and in some cases of polymeric insulators under service
from a loss of bonding at the junction of two conditions. The period of testing extends over
consecutive shed [13]. Such phenomena were 10 years, which is unique among the research
not observed in silicone rubber insulators, groups studying the subject of polymeric
deformation of the RTV silicone rubber insulators. As criticism, one may argue that
weathersheds was observed instead, together mechanical stressing is not included in their
with a reduction of its hardness. testing arrangement, an important parameter
Detailed natural aging research was in service aging.
reported by the high voltage group of
Chalmers University of Technology, where 4. 2 Laboratory Aging
the aging of polymeric insulators is not only
investigated by post-mortem sophisticated Service experience and long term
surface analysis techniques [20 - 24] but also experiments were reported and commented
by on-line leakage current measurements [25 upon in the previous section. It was seen that
- 27]. The above mentioned group reached environmental stresses together with
some important conclusions : (a) EPDM and electrical and mechanical stresses affect the
silicone rubber perform better than glass or behaviour of polymeric outdoor insulation.
porcelain, (b) the aging of silicone rubber Modes of failure include oxidation,
results in the formation of a low molecular hydrolytic attack, dry-band arcing, erosion
silicone layer on the insulator surface which and tracking among others. Attempts have
preserves the good electrical insulating been made to try to simulate real aging
properties of the aged silicone rubber conditions in the laboratory and then to relate
insulator, (c) the EPDM insulators tend to the laboratory results to the service data.
lose their hydrophobicity by weathering after Since laboratory testing is concerned with
some years of exposure, (d) for the RTV both investigating components and materials,
silicone elastomer coating the contact angle it was thought fitting to present a review of
was lower than that measured on the RTV the work done in those fields in two separate
silicone rubber housing, (e) the leakage sections.
current activity for the aged silicone rubber
8 ACTA ELECTROTEHNICA NAPOCENSIS
L`Energia Elettrica. LIX (1983) no. 1, pp. 1-11. [31] Danikas,M.G.; On the breakdown strength of
[20] Vlastos,A.E.; Sherif,E.; Natural aging of silicone rubber. IEEE Trans. Diel. and Elec.
EPDM composite insulators. Paper 89 121-5 Insul. 1 (1994) no. 6, pp. 1196-1200.
PWRD. [32] Danikas,M.G.; Gorur,R.S.; Orbeck,T.;
[21] Vlastos,A.E.; Diagnosis of the shed surface Discussion on: Surface dielectric behavior of
degradation on composite polymeric insulators polymeric insulation under HV outdoor
long-term exposed to outdoor environment. conditions. IEEE Trans. Elec. Insul. EI-27
CIGRE (1990), Paper 15/33-05. (1992) no. 3, pp. 675-676.
[22] Vlastos,A.E.; Gubanski,S.M.; Surface [33] Danikas,M. G.; Gubanski,S. M.;
structural changes of naturally aged silicone and Wankowicz,J. G.; Loss and recovery of
EPDM composite insulators. IEEE Trans. hydrophobicity on RTV coating surfaces. Loss
Power Deliv. PD- 6 (1991) no. 2, pp. 888-900. of hydrophobicity. IEEE Trans. Diel. and Elec.
[23] Vlastos,A.E.; Sherif,E.; Experience from Insul. DEI-2 (1995) no. 3, pp. 506-507.
insulators with RTV silicone rubber sheds and [34] Danikas,M.G.; Gubanski,S.M.;
shed coatings", Paper 89 120-7 PWRD. Vulcanization influence on TSD currents and
[24] Gubanski,S.M.; Vlastos,A.E.; Wettability of wettability of room temperature vulcanized
naturally aged silicone and EPDM tansmission silicone rubber HV insulator coatings. Eur.
line polymeric insulators. Paper 90 WM 025-7 Trans. on Elec. Power Eng. ETEP-4 (1994) no.
PWRD. 4, pp. 317-319.
[25] Sherif,E.M.; Vlastos,A.E.; Influence of aging [35] Soerqvist,T.; Vlastos,A.; Outdoor aging of
on the electrical properties of composite silicone rubber based polymeric materials. 1998
insulators", 5th ISH, Braunschweig/Germany, IEEE Int. Conf. on Cond. a. Breakd. in Solid
Paper 51.01,1987. Diel., Vasteras/Sweden, pp. 401-405, 1998.
[26] Vlastos,A.E.; Basic leak currents of generic [36] Danikas,M.G.; Online leakage current
silicone and EPDM transmission line polymeric monitoring of 400 kV insulator strings in
insulators. Proc. 3rd ICPADM, Beijing/China, polluted areas. IEE Proc.-Gener. Transm.
pp. 977-980, 1991. Distrib., GTD-144 (1997) no. 5, p. 515.
[27] Vlastos,A.E.; Peak leak currents of silicone [37] Danikas,M.G.; Petrusch,W.; Weck,K.-H.;
and EPDM transmission line polymeric Accelerated aging tests on composite hollow
insulator families. 7th ISH, Dresden/Germany, insulators under DC voltages. Eur. Trans. Elec.
pp. 279-282, 1991. Power ETEP-7 (1997) no. 5, pp. 361-362.
[28] Starr,W.T.; Polymeric outdoor insulation. [38] Danikas,M.G.; Aging properties of silicone
IEEE Trans. Elec. Insul. EI-25 (1990) no. 1, pp. rubber materials used in high voltage composite
125-136. insulators. J. Elec. and Electron. Eng.,
[29] Danikas,M.G.; Gubanski,S.M.; Discussion Australia, JEEE-15 (1995) no. 2, pp. 193-202.
on : Experience with the Merry-go-round test. [39] Gutman,I.; Hartings,R.; Matsuoka,R.;
IEEE Trans. Elec. Insul. EI-27 (1992) no. 4, pp. Kondo,K.; The IEC 1109, 1000 h salt fog test:
1058-1060. Experience and suggestions for improvement.
[30] Onodi,T.; Danikas,M.G.; Bruning,A.M.; A Proc. Nord. Insul. Symp., Bergen/Norway, pp.
study of factors affecting the breakdown 389-397, 1996.
strength of silicone rubber. 1992 Ann. Rep.
Conf. Elec. Insul. Diel. Phen., pp. 811-816.