Exploring The Current Practices of Post Consumer PET Bottles and The Innovative Applications As A Sustainable Building Material - A Way Ahead
Exploring The Current Practices of Post Consumer PET Bottles and The Innovative Applications As A Sustainable Building Material - A Way Ahead
Exploring The Current Practices of Post Consumer PET Bottles and The Innovative Applications As A Sustainable Building Material - A Way Ahead
ABSTR ACT
PET stands for polyethylene terephthalate and PET bottles are occupying an indispensable position
in common man’s life. Food processing industries across the world are using PET bottles as effective
containers for storing juice, beer, carbonated and non carbonated drinks. The different parameters
which determine the form of PET bottles during designing, manufacturing and production phases are
cost per unit, need, volume, color, intrinsic velocity, size, shape etc. Irrespective of a wide range of
applications, initiatives in recycling post consumer PET is sporadic. The disposal of PET bottles in the
environment, significantly contributes to ecological imbalance. Interpreting the negative impacts and
adopting the principles of Reuse B and C by Romans, pioneers are searching for rational and technical
solutions to check this issue. In construction industry, hybrid actors are using PET bottles as moulds for
developing alternative blocks. Technocrats are recycling PET products physically in to fibers, pellets
and flakes for partial replacement of fine and coarse aggregates in conventional building materials. This
paper intends to consolidate such initiatives addressing building systems, materials and artifacts. It
discusses an overview of such applications and other intuitive trends which are emerging in Indian
context.
INTRODUCTION
The technology of storing liquid products for transportation, distribution and use is defined as
packaging. Our ancestors used baskets and storage units made of natural fibers and indigenous materials
like stone, earth etc. Use of paper and metal plated containers for such applications dates back to the 10th
century (Packing, 2012). Glass bottles, plastic containers and polyethylene are used predominantly in
today‟s context. Polyethylene terephthalate, a versatile material is playing a primary role in packaging
industry in today‟s context, simultaneously increasing the production process. The drawbacks during the
disposal phase is raising a question, whether the invention is a boon or a bane, revolving around the
societal benefits (Andrady & Neal, 2009) and the negative impacts in the environment (Webb, Arnott,
Crawford, and Ivanova, 2012).
HISTORY
According to the archaeologists, a novel concept, “Post consumer packing material as a resource,
specifically in construction”, is traced from the Hellenistic age. Interpreting the problems posed by
disposal of „amphorae‟, Romans came up with an innovative idea to reuse them in architecture (Will,
Arulmalar Ramaraj is a Research Scholar in the Department of Architecture, Sathyabama University, Chennai, Tamilnadu. Jothilakshmy
Nagammal is a Professor and Head, Department of Architecture, Sathyabama University, Chennai, Tamilnadu.
AN INSIGHT TO PET
Plastic is a commonly preferred packing material for various goods in today‟s fast moving
contemporary world. They are classified in to seven categories based on recyclability (Society of
plastics, 2013) and polyethylene terephthalate denoted as PET, PETE or PETP ranking number one. The
credit of inventing PET goes to chemists Whitefield and Dickson, the employees of Calico Printer‟s
Association in 1941 and was patented only in 1973 by Wyeth. Semi crystalline thermoplastic polyester,
durable, low gas permeability, chemically and thermally stable, easily processed and handled,
transparent, wear and tear resistant and non biodegradable are the general characteristics of PET. Based
on its versatility, it is primarily used in textiles, films, utility ware, sportswear etc. Food processing
industries prefer PET as it is hygienic, strong, lightweight (Petresin, 2013) and devoid of phthalates,
dioxins, bisphenol A, cadmium, lead and other endocrine disruptors (NAPCOR, 2013). As PET is used
predominantly in the form of bottles for storing carbonated and non carbonated drinks, this paper
addresses to reuse the PET bottles in construction industry.
PET BOTTLE
Cap, neck, shoulder, body, hip and feet are the basic parts of a PET bottle (bottle biology, 2013).
Containers for storing carbonated and non carbonated drinks have different intrinsic velocity, wall
thickness, color and level of copolymer. With respect to the physical form, PET bottles used for storing
carbonated drinks are designed with an additional twist in the neck, thicker wall, higher intrinsic value,
lower copolymer level and a petaloid base (Bristogianni, 2012).
According to the Environmental Protection Agency, recycling, incineration and landfill are the
general ways of disposing plastics are disposed in today‟s context. Each method has its own
disadvantages and drawbacks (Webb et.al, 2013). Its disposal is disturbing the ecological balance,
directly or indirectly affecting the health of all living creatures (Rustagi, Pradhan & Singh, 2011).
Original purpose
, break water
Reuse C (Will, 1977)
Tertiary treatment
Innovators and researchers are adopting different strategies to reuse and recycle PET bottles. Up
cycling and down cycling are the processes involved in the manufacturing of new products with the
treated PET bottles. While applying such concepts, the consumption of energy and the negative impacts
generated during the production phase need to be kept to the minimum. Investigations on effective
reusing or recycling of such used bottles in the construction sector, marks the beginning of the next
industrial revolution. A holistic, pragmatic approach rich in aesthetic values (Pramar, 1973), as the focal
point, the vision of the architects and environmentalists, technocrats, product designers and artists are
interpreted in Table 1.
Table 1: Unique perceptions
Post consumer PET Hybrid actors - Technocrats- Product designers- Artists-Aesthetic
bottles Holistic Rational approach Innovations expressions
Unmodified / Reuse B Partly objective Objective, Subjective, Partly Subjective,
Modified / Reuse C and subjective, Economical, functional and Aesthetic,
(secondary and tertiary) Aesthetic values Utilitarian Emotional Emotional
Approach Ecocentric Problem solving Transforming the Promoting
overlooked Awareness
Examples Bottle bricks with Partial Screens, lamp Murals, sculpture
different fillers, replacement in shades, planter
PET bottle as a building materials boxes, chandeliers,
filler furniture etc
„Ecocentric‟ approach is one among the six competing logics of sustainable architectural practices
- built forms are parasitic in nature and revolve around the post consumer waste (Guy &Farmer, 2001).
With self sufficiency and incorporating the principles of a living organism, Reynolds designed
„earthships‟ in 1970s. With his attitude towards post consumer waste as a resource, he developed
building systems by using tires, glass bottles and aluminium cans. Creating the base for a man made
floating island (Mader, 2011) with PET bottles is an exceptional eco centric idea.
Following Reynolds‟ strategies, Froese initiated to construct small structures with PET bottles
firmly held in position with nylon ropes in 2001 (Pachecho, 2013). PET bottle buildings are bio climatic,
cost effective, non brittle, easy maintenance, resistant to abrupt shock loads; strong, durable, versatile,
easy handling and reusable are the characteristics of such built structures (eco tec, 2002). Habitable
spaces, activity centers, learning centers and latrines are constructed using PET bottle bricks at
Honduras, Nigeria, Central America, Philippines and India. Architects and technocrats are searching for
a variety of solutions to reuse post consumer PET bottles in building envelopes for permanently built
forms, temporary structures and interiors as in Figure 2.
With a holistic approach, PET bottle bricks are being made with a variety of filling materials such as
adobe or sand (eco tec, 2002, May 4), liquefied adobe, inorganic waste (Saraswat, 2013), sand and cork
(Shoubi et al, 2013). PET bottles are stacked one on top of the other to build green houses (Alvarado,
Load bearing structure Reuse B (Will, 1977) - cradle to Non load bearing structure
cradle approach
Roof
Sandwich panel (Bristogianni, 2012)
Monolithically casted with
Wall concrete (Radu & Christiana, Thermal insulation mattresses (Intini &
2011) Kuhtz, 2011)
As fillers in vault (The Hindu, Filler in space frames (design boom, 2011)
2013)
PET bottle itself as filler Interior partitions with and without visual
(Mehta & Ellis, 2007) continuity (Webecoist, 2011)
Fillers in bottle bricks – adobe or sand or rubble (eco tec, 2002), inorganic waste (Saraswat,
2013), sand and cork (Shoubi et al, 2013), liquefied adobe and fly ash (Pandya, 2012)
In a country like India the development is uncontrolled, unorganized, use of virgin construction
materials increasing day by day increasing the proportion of the shelterless. Architects and others are
adopting the ideals of ecocentric practices, zoning on the experimentation (Chan,2007) with post
consumer waste. According to Antonoides (1992), materials are the flesh, bones and skin of the built
forms and are categorized based on their influence on the structure and function. Initiators like Yatin
Pandya, Prashant Lingam and Patrick San Francesco are the eye openers to experiment with post
consumer PET bottles in constructing small scale buildings like activity centers, learning and habitable
spaces for social causes in different Indian contexts.
Soil blocks (Prasad, Nambiar &Abraham, 2012), Fired clay bricks (Kadir & Sarani, 2012), Fly ash based
composite (Vytlacilova, 2011)
Mortar (Rahman, Mahi & Chowdhury , 2013) & Reinforcement of cement mortar (Fraternali, Farina,
Polzone, Pagliusa & Feo, 2013)
Light weight concrete (S.Akcaozoglu, Atis & K.Akcaozoglu 2012), (Angel & Ruiz, 2012); Concrete
(Saikia & Brito, 2013; Siddique, Khatib &Kaur,2008; Irwan, Faisal, Othman & Ibrahim. 2013); Yesilata,
Isiker & Turgut, 2008); (Ramadevi & Manju, 2013), Waste plastic fibre reinforced concrete (Nibudey,
Nagarnaik, Parbat & Pandey, 2013)
Investigations on polymer concrete (Tawfik & Eskander, 2006), polymer mortar (Reis et al, 2011) or
polyester composite tiles (Icduygu et al, 2013) are emerging, where the chemical composition of the
PET is modified through chemical treatment as in figure 8. Applications in the construction of habitable
spaces need to be addressed and impacts created during the treatment and production phase is to be
investigated.
CONCLUSION
The initial perception on the use of PET bottles in construction is changing day by day. A paradigm
which emerged as PET bottle bricks in the construction of load bearing walls with steel trusses and
prefabricated metal sheet is at present witnessing flat roofs with nylon 6 replacing steel reinforcement
and intuitive vault construction. Apart from this ingenious bonds and columns using PET bottles gives a
new direction to think about beams, foundation and simple trusses. With a holistic approach, designing
phase of PET bottles with interlocking property is innovative. Even though research on the effective use
PET in developing new material as an option, solutions exploring the application of PET bottles as
structural members, foundation, retaining walls and secondary elements like street furniture, kerbs, road
dividers, pavements and other landscape elements is to be looked in to. Strategies, approaches and
practices integrating the relationship incorporating a total rethinking on junk as a resourceful building
material integrating waste need to be nurtured and shall be enhanced. The Governing bodies shall
REFERENCES
Akcaozoglu,S. , Atis.C.D and Akcaozoglu,K. (2010), An investigation on the use of shredded waste PET
bottles as aggregates in lightweight concrete, Waste Management, 30, 285-290,
doi:10.1016/j.wasman.2009.09.033
Alvarado,P. (2010, February 3) ,amazing house made entirely of plastic bottles from argentina,
http://www.treehugger.com/sustainable-product-design/amazing-house-made-entirely-of-plastic-
bottles-from-argentina-photos.html, Retrieved, January 18, 2014
Andrady,A.L, Neal,M.A (2009), Applications and societal benefits of plastics,
doi:10.1098/rstb.2008.0304
Andreas Froese, http://www.eco-tecnologia.com/portal/projects, Retrieved May 4, 2014
Angel, f.c. and Ruiz,j.l.v (2012), Manufacturing light weight concrete with pet aggregate, ISRN civil
engineering, 2012, doi:10.5402/2012/287323
Anthony C.Antonoides (1990), Poetics of Architecture: Theory of Design, Van Nostrand Reinhold
Bristogianni,T. Composite structural module out of srPP facings & PET bottle core, (Master thesis),
Available from Tu Delft repository http:/www.repository.tudelft.nl/assets/uuid.../
Bottle biology, www.bottle biology.org/basics, Retrieved December 10, 2013
Can steel be made obsolete in construction?, sustainability, habitat, The Hindu, 28th decemeber 2013,8
Chan, Yanna (2007), Sustainable environment, Rockport publishers Inc
Fraternali,F.,Farina,I., Polzone,C., Pagliuca,E. AND Feo,L. (2013), On the use of r-pet strips for the
reinforcement of cement mortars, Composites:Part B, 46, 207-210,
doi:10.1016/j.compositesb.2012.09.070
Guy,S & Farmer, G (2001), Reinterpreting sustainable architecture: The place of technology, Journal of
Architectural Education, 54/3, ACSA Inc
Hagenwald,J., Ackermann,R., Neugebauer,S., Finkbeiner,M (2013), Innovative product design and
recycling: comparative sustainability assessment of the building material polli-brick , Life Cycle
Management
How to construct houses with plastic bottles, http:/ www.instructables.com/.../New-Innovation-in
Construction-using-Waste-.plastic bottles., Retrieved June 6, 2013
Icduygu,M.G. , Aktas, L. and Altan,M.C (2013), Fabrication of composite tiles from Poly(ethylene
terephthalate) (PET) and Micro-Marble particles reinforced with glass fiber mats: comparison of
recycled and commercial resin, Polymers & Polymer Composites, 21(3),
http://connection.ebscohost.com/
Intini,F.,Kuhtz,S.(2011), Recycling in buildings:an LCA case study of a thermal insulation panel made
of polyester fibre, recycled from post-consumer PET bottles, LCA for Plastics, 306-315,
doi:10.1007/s 11367-011-0267-9
Irwan,J.M., Faisal,S.K., Othman,N., Ibrahim,M.H.W, Asyraf,R.M. & Annas,M.M.K (2013), Advanced
Materials Research, 795, 352-355, doi:10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.795.352
Jankauskaite.v, Macijauskas.G, Lygaitis.R (2008), Polyethylene terephthalate waste recycling and
application possibilities: a review, 14 (2), Material Science,http:/
http://www.ktu.lt/lt/mokslas/zurnalai/medz/medz0-93/06%20Polymers
Jongert,J. (2012, December 17) www.superuse.org/story/plastic-bottle-house-nigeria/, retrieved October
10, 2013
Kadir,A.A. and Sarani,N.A. (2012), an overview of wastes recycling in fired clay bricks, Integrated
Journal of Integrated Engineering, 4(2), 53-69, http:/
penerbit.uthm.edu.my/ojs/index.php/ijie/article/view/224/352
Mader,S, Grand launch of recycled plastic bottle eco art island, www.
https://www.kickstarter.com/.../scottmader/grand-launch-of-recycled-plastic bottles, retrieved May
18, 2014
Mehta,R. and Ellis,M. PET brick developed sand, cement and plastic bottles (2007), Clay Tech
magazine, http:/ www.iom3.org/news/, Retrieved Decemeber 11,2013
Miniwiz (2013), Polli- Brick, Your trash our building material, www.miniwiz.com
National Association for PET Container Resources (2014), http:/ www.napcor.com, Retrieved March 27,
2014