Bode 100 Application Note

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement

Strongly supported by

By Stephan Synkule, Lukas Heinzle & Florian Hmmerle

2013 by OMICRON Lab V2.0
Visit www.omicron-lab.com for more information.
Contact [email protected] for technical support.

Smart Measurement Solutions

Table of Contents
1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................3
2 Measurement Setup ...................................................................................................................4
2.1 The Circuit under Test ...........................................................................................................4
2.2 Selecting the Injection Point ..................................................................................................5
2.3 Connecting the Bode 100 ......................................................................................................6
2.4 Phase Margin and Gain Margin .............................................................................................8
3 Device Configuration .................................................................................................................9
4 Measurement & Results ...........................................................................................................10
4.1 Calibration ...........................................................................................................................10
4.2 Shaped Level ......................................................................................................................12
4.3 Injection Level .....................................................................................................................14
4.4 Supply Voltage Influence .....................................................................................................15
4.5 Load Current Influence ........................................................................................................15
5 Conclusion ...............................................................................................................................16

Note: Basic procedures such as setting-up, adjusting and calibrating the Bode 100 are described
in the Bode 100 user manual. You can download the Bode 100 user manual at
www.omicron-lab.com/bode-100/downloads#3

Note: All measurements in this application note have been performed with the Bode Analyzer
Suite V2.41 SR1. Use this version or a higher version to perform the measurements shown
in this document. You can download the latest version at
www.omicron-lab.com/bode-100/downloads

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 2 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

1 Introduction
In this application note we show how to analyze the stability respectively the control loop behavior of a
step-down DC/DC converter.
To minimize the influence of supply voltage variations and load changes on the output voltage of a
DC/DC converter, a compensating controller is necessary. The quality of this control circuit
determines the stability and dynamic response of the entire DC/DC converter system. The following
pages show you how you can measure the loop response of such control systems using the Bode 100
vector network analyzer in combination with the B-WIT 100 wideband injection transformer.

For the characterization of the loop we measure the open loop gain by using the voltage injection
method. This method is commonly used to analyze the stability of voltage regulators such as switched
mode power supplies.

The following points are discussed in this document:

How to choose the correct injection point to measure the loop gain
Determining gain margin and phase margin from the frequency response
How do supply voltage and load current influence the systems dynamics
Using the shaped level feature of the Bode 100 to improve the measurement results

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 3 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

2 Measurement Setup

2.1 The Circuit under Test

The demo board 481A is a step-down converter featuring the LT1976. The output is optimized for
at a load current of . The following figure shows the schematics of the demo board 481A.
Detailed information on the demo circuit can be found at http://www.linear.com.

Figure 1: LT 481A demo board schematics

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 4 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

2.2 Selecting the Injection Point
In order to measure the loop gain of a voltage feedback loop we need to break the loop at a suitable
point and inject a disturbance signal at this point. The disturbance signal will be distributed around the
loop and depending on the loop gain the signal will be amplified or attenuated and shifted in phase.
The Bode 100 output will provide the disturbance signal whereas the inputs will measure the transfer
function of the loop.

To ensure that the measured loop gain equals the real loop gain we need to find a point where the
loop is restricted to one single path and where the impedance looking in the direction of the loop is
much bigger than the impedance looking backwards.

The following figure shows the feedback loop of the circuit and indicates the suitable injection point.
The impedance looking backwards equals the output impedance of the converter which is very low (in
the range of several ). The impedance looking in direction of the loop is formed by the
compensator and the voltage divider and is in the range of several .

Figure 2: Feedback loop and injection point

More details on the selection of the injection point and the theory of the voltage injection method can
be found in the article Loop Gain Measurement which is available for download at:
http://www.omicron-lab.com/bode-100/application-notes-know-how/articles-use-cases.html#3

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 5 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

2.3 Connecting the Bode 100
We have selected the injection point and now need to break the loop at this point. To ensure that the
measurement does not change our system behavior we place a small resistor at the injection point
that does not significantly change the feedback divider. In this case we use a resistor.

The disturbance voltage is applied in parallel to the injection resistor using the B-WIT 100 injection
transformer. The transformer is necessary to isolate the output of the Bode 100 from the DC operating
point of the feedback loop. The following figure shows how the Bode 100 is connected to the circuit.

Figure 3: Connecting the Bode 100 to measure the loop response of the regulator

The inputs of the Bode 100 are connected to either side of the injection transformer. CH1 measures
the disturbance signal that is applied to the feedback divider and CH2 measures the signal that
appears at the output of the converter. By dividing the voltage at CH2 by the voltage at CH1 we get
the transfer function from the feedback input to the output of the power supply. This transfer function
we call the loop gain .

In this case we use 10:1 probes to pick up the signals but any standard oscilloscope probe can be
used for this measurement.

Attention: If hazardous voltages are present, make sure that suitable probes are used to protect
operator and device from any dangerous voltage !

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 6 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

To ensure good measurement results it is strongly recommended to place the injection resistor, the
injection transformer and the probes close to the circuit to keep leads short.

Furthermore, it is very important to avoid mechanical stress at soldering pads to prevent damage to
the test object. The following figures show how we have realized the modification on the demo board
and how the probes and the injection transformer are connected to the circuit.

Figure 4: Demo board prepared for connecting the measurement equipment

Figure 5: The probes and the injection transformer connected to the circuit

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 7 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

Figure 6: Measurement setup with power supply, resistive load, Ampere meter and Bode 100

2.4 Phase Margin and Gain Margin

According to Nyquist, the stability of a feedback system can be verified by checking two critical points.
These are the Gain crossover point where the Phase Margin is measured and the Phase crossover
point where the Gain Margin is determined.

Note: When analyzing the open loop gain for stability as it is done in text-books, positive
feedback occurs at -180 phase. Therefore the phase margin is measured by determining
the phase difference to -180.
In this measurement we measure the open loop gain in a closed loop system. The
phase margin must therefore be measured relatively to the 0 line!
This is somehow confusing but gets clearer if you imagine a signal that is injected at the
feedback input and appears at the output without any phase shift. Such a signal that
passed the loop with 0 phase will again be injected at the feedback and sum up with the
previous one. This is exactly the point where positive feedback and therefore instability
will occur in a negative feedback system.

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 8 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

3 Device Configuration
In order to measure the transfer function of the loop we need to set up the Bode 100 correctly. The
measurement of the loop gain is performed in the Frequency Sweep mode of the Bode Analyzer
Suite:

Open the device configuration window and apply the following settings:
The external reference is switched on and both inputs are set to high impedance.

The following settings are applied:

Start Frequency: 100 Hz

Stop Frequency: 200 kHz
Sweep Mode: Logarithmic
Number of Points: 201 or more
Level: -20 dBm
Attenuator CH1&CH2: 0 dB
Receiver Bandwidth: 30 Hz

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 9 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

Trace 1 & 2 are set up as shown below to display a Bode-plot:

4 Measurement & Results

4.1 Calibration
We first check if a calibration is necessary for this measurement. Calibration would be necessary if
the two probes used to connect the Bode 100 to the circuit have a different frequency response. This
would introduce phase shift and attenuation errors in the measurements.

In order to check if our probes have the same frequency response, we connect both probes to the
same side of the injection resistor as shown in the picture below.

Figure 7: Connection during calibration

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 10 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

After connecting the probes we start a measurement by pressing the single sweep button.

The measurement shows a flat line at 0dB and 0 which indicates that both probes have the same
frequency response and calibration is not necessary in this case.

60 150

40 100

20 50
TR1/dB

TR2/
0 0

-20 -50

-40 -100

-60 -150

102 103 104 105

f/Hz
TR1: Mag(Gain) TR2: Phase(Gain)

Figure 8: THRU Measurement result

Note: If this measurement shows a gain or phase curve deviating from and calibration is
necessary. Phase and amplitude difference can be compensated by performing a THRU
calibration in the Bode Analyzer Suite. Details on how to perform a THRU calibration can
be found in the Bode 100 User Manual.

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 11 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

4.2 Shaped Level
We perform the first stability measurement with a supply voltage of and a load current of .
Please do not use electronic loads for frequency response measurements as the control circuit of the
electronic load could interfere with the circuit under test.

Starting a frequency sweep leads to the following bode-plot.

Figure 9: Screenshot of the Bode Analyzer Suite showing the loop gain curve

The red line shows the gain magnitude and the blue curve the gain phase. Above the result
does not show much noise whereas in the lower frequencies the curve is very noisy. The reason is
the very small injection level and the high gain of . In order to reduce the noise in the low
frequency range we use the shaped level feature of the Bode 100.

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 12 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

On the left hand side in the Bode Analyzer Suite, click on the arrow right to the Level and select
Shaped Level. A Shaped Level button will appear. By clicking this button the shaped level can be
entered in the Shaped Level window.

We set the reference level to and increase the output level from to from -
to by entering a delta level of .

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 13 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

Restarting the measurement leads to the following gain / phase curve.
1 2
60 150

40 100

20 50
TR1/dB

TR2/
0 0

-20 -50

-40 f/Hz TR1/dB TR2/

-100
Cursor 1 20,496k 0,000 83,007
Cursor 2 92,060k -9,499 0,000 -150
-60 C2-C1 71,563k -9,499 -83,007

102 103 104 105

f/Hz
TR1: Mag(Gain) TR2: Phase(Gain)

Figure 10: loop gain measurement ( Input voltage and load current)

By using the cursors we can read the Gain Margin and Phase Margin of the system. The
measurement indicates a Phase Margin of and a Gain Margin of .

4.3 Injection Level

You may have noticed that we use a very low output level of for this measurement. The
reason is that we want to analyze the small signal behavior of the regulator. Some regulators are very
sensitive to the injected level and show nonlinearities or big-signal effects if the injected level is too
high. If we i.e. set the load to and use an output level of for the measurement, the
result will be erroneous as shown below:
60 150

40 100

20 50
TR1/dB

TR2/

0 0

-20 -50

-40 -100

-60 -150

102 103 104 105

f/Hz
TR1: Mag(Gain) TR2: Phase(Gain)

Figure 11: big signal effects (nonlinearities) due to excessive injection signal

Such erroneous measurements can be avoided by reducing the injection signal level. The shaped
level feature provides the possibility to reduce the output level exactly at the frequencies where it is
necessary.

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 14 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

4.4 Supply Voltage Influence
With our next measurement we will check how supply voltage changes influence the characteristic of
the LT1976 control circuit. To do so, we change the supply voltage to . Restarting the sweep and
placing the cursors again at the and points leads to the following graph.
1 2
60 150

40 100

20 50
TR1/dB

TR2/
0 0

-20 -50

-40 f/Hz TR1/dB TR2/

-100
Cursor 1 10,521k 0,000 36,992
Cursor 2 81,025k -25,385 0,000 -150
-60 C2-C1 70,504k -25,385 -36,992

102 103 104 105

f/Hz
TR1: Mag(Gain) TR2: Phase(Gain)

Figure 12: loop gain measurement ( Input voltage and load current)

The phase margin did decrease to whereas the gain margin did increase to .

4.5 Load Current Influence

By varying the load current and keeping the supply voltage of the regulator constant we can check the
sensitivity of the system to different load currents. The following graph shows the loop gain
measurement at different load currents. All measurements were performed with a supply voltage of
.
80 200

60 150

100
40
50
TR1/dB

TR2/

20
0
0
-50
-20
-100
-40 -150

-60 -200
102 103 104 105
f/Hz
100mA : Mag(Gain) 500mA : Mag(Gain)
1000mA : Mag(Gain) 100mA : Phase(Gain)
500mA : Phase(Gain) 1000mA : Phase(Gain)

Figure 13: loop gain depending on load current

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 15 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

5 Conclusion
The Bode 100 in combination with the B-WIT 100 wideband injection transformer offers a perfect
toolkit for the quick and easy stability analysis of control systems. It enables to measure the gain
margin and phase margin of control systems such as switched mode power supplies or linear
regulators. Gain margin and phase margin are widely accepted indicators for the stability of a control
loop.
Furthermore, the Bode Analyzer Suite provides great functionality to display the system response on
changing operating conditions such as supply voltage changes or load current changes. To ensure
stability of a power supply in the field the combination of all acceptable load and environmental
conditions have to be tested. This provides detailed information on the dynamic behavior of a
DC/DC converter in various operating conditions.

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 16 of 17

Smart Measurement Solutions

 OMICRON Lab is a division of OMICRON electronics specialized in
providing Smart Measurement Solutions to professionals such as
scientists, engineers and teachers engaged in the field of electronics.
It simplifies measurement tasks and provides its customers with more
time to focus on their real business.

OMICRON Lab was established in 2006 and is meanwhile serving

customers in more than 40 countries. Offices in America, Europe, East
Asia and an international network of distributors enable a fast and
extraordinary customer support.

OMICRON Lab products stand for high quality offered at the best
price/value ratio on the market. The products' reliability and ease of use
guarantee trouble-free operation. Close customer relationship and more
than 25 years in-house experience enable the development of
innovative products close to the field.

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 17 of 17

Europe, Middle East, Africa Asia Pacific Americas

OMICRON electronics GmbH OMICRON electronics Asia Limited OMICRON electronics Corp. USA
Phone: +43 5523 507-0 Phone:+852 3767 5500 Phone:+1 713 830-4660
Fax: +43 5523 507-999 Fax: +852 3767 5400 Fax: +1 713 830-4661

DC/DC Converter Stability Measurement Page 17 of 17

[email protected] www.omicron-lab.com
Smart Measurement Solutions