Education and Gender Equality Series

3. Gender Equality
and Adult Basic
Education

Women's basic education in Pakistan, Khoj

This paper highlights the fact that the Millennium Development

Goals (MDGs) do not directly address the issue of adult basic
education and literacy, in spite of these being essential for
achieving the Millennium targets. It explores the potential of adult
basic education with gender equality to be transformatory for
individuals, and for groups working to address key issues, such as
gender-based violence, and HIV/AIDS. The role of governments and
other key agencies in relation to gender equality and adult basic
education is also explored. The paper concludes with a discussion
of how to develop longer-term approaches to gender equality, adult
basic education, and literacy.
Adult basic education and the Millennium
Development Goals
There are almost 800 million illiterate adults worldwide, of whom 64
per cent are women.1 There is widespread agreement that adult basic
education and literacy enhance human and social development and
underpin the achievement of all Millennium Development Goals
(MDGs). Yet the MDGs do not emphasise or address the eradication
of adult illiteracy or the provision of basic education for adults and
out of school youth. The education Goal (MDG2) focuses on universal
primary education. The gender Goal (MDG3) has targets for gender
parity in the formal primary, secondary, and tertiary education
system, but leaves out adult basic education. There is an urgent need
to expand the vision of both these MDGs to take on board basic
education for adults.

Literacy and womens empowerment

Societies have become increasingly dependent on the printed word,
and non-literate people are among the poorest and least powerful in
the world. Marginalised groups and individuals receive little or no
education. This particularly affects poor women and girls who
experience forms of discrimination and injustice.
There is a close relationship between literacy, power, and
empowerment. The objectives of adult basic education and literacy
have been expressed by a wide-ranging global consensus to enable
people and communities to take control of their destiny and
society.2

National Literacy Programme, Uganda

An evaluation of the National Literacy Programme in Uganda showed that,
among positive outcomes, the empowerment or increased self-confidence
of learners were perhaps the most salient. One woman expressed this by
saying that, before becoming a literacy learner, I talked with my hands in
front of my mouth without looking up, but now I feel strong and free to
speak up. 3

There are many providers of literacy teaching, with funding from

numerous sources. They use a wide range of approaches, from
teaching specific skills and knowledge for limited purposes (e.g.
literacy linked to income-generation schemes), through to facilitating
learning to achieve more far-reaching empowerment and social
change. In other words, adult basic education and literacy teaching
does not have to be restricted to teaching people to read and write.
While not all literacy learning is empowering in this way, and women
sometimes report literacy classes that fall far short of this, it does
have the potential to transform poor peoples lives. This
transformation can powerfully challenge gender inequality:

1 3. Gender Equality and Adult Basic Education,Education and

Gender Equality Series, Programme Insights, Oxfam GB. December
2005
 Through the teaching process itself, which can promote dialogue,
supporting and encouraging learners to discuss and reflect on
their condition and its causes.
By equipping learners with the skills to gain information and to
advocate for their own rights.
Although adult basic education and literacy programmes have the
potential to be empowering for women and girls, a wide-ranging
assessment of literacy programmes show that few have explicitly
gendered aims or gender policies. Of those that do, the aims related
to gender range from the achievement of equal access to
programmes, to the transformation of the lives of women outside the
classroom.
Research in a number of settings indicates that, for poor womens
lives to be transformed through gender-equitable adult basic
education and literacy teaching, the content and processes used must
be guided by the experiences and aspirations of the learners, so that
they feel relevant to them. Pertinent and continuing training of
teachers to this end is necessary.

Total Literacy Campaign, India

From the late 1980s, the NGO Bharat Gyan Vigyan Samiti (BGVS), worked
in partnership with the Government of India on the Total Literacy
Campaign, the aim of which was to mobilise women for literacy. The
campaign, which used messages that linked literacy to basic livelihood
problems, and questions of exploitation and discrimination against women,
provided new hope and optimism for millions of women from all classes. It
gave women a social sanction to come out of their houses and participate
in activities organised in their villages. Today the BGVS is in the process of
building institutional support at the village level for women working with
self-help groups. The objectives of these groups include providing a focus
for activities for womens empowerment, helping women to upgrade their
literacy skills and, through micro-credit enterprises, enhancing their status
in the family and in the community.4

The realities of womens lives

Illiterate women are a very diverse constituency. What individuals
wish to achieve and change through becoming educated and literate
will vary according to their circumstances and the environments in
which they live. Case studies show that participatory methods for
programme design can ensure that these wishes are a central part of
literacy programmes.
Changes in the wider external environment for example,
macroeconomic policy that involves a reduction in government
spending on the social sector because of external debt, or a reduction
in the prices paid for crops that women produce can directly affect
womens lives. Rapid change, e.g. due to a government adopting
policies on gender equality or due to widespread unemployment, can

3. Gender Equality and Adult Basic Education, Education and Gender 2

Equality Series, Programme Insights, Oxfam GB. December 2005
result in confused perceptions of the divisions of work between
women and men. This can lead to backlashes against womens
independence if, for example, it creates new or different demands for
literacy and organised learning.
Increasingly, for many women, living with HIV/AIDS is a reality.
Levels of education have been found to be a strong predictor of levels
of knowledge about safe behaviour and ways of reducing infection.
Education programmes for young people worldwide are addressing
HIV/AIDS prevention with increasing coherence. However, in adult
basic education the learning and knowledge is fragmented and
dispersed. Adult basic education needs to provide support to learners
to help them consider HIV/AIDS from both personal and local
perspectives, and women need to be supported to negotiate safe sex.
The vulnerability of women and girls to gender-based violence also
makes them more vulnerable to HIV/AIDS. Women and girls report
violence through enforced sex in the domestic sphere, and as a result
of conflict and war. These experiences can have profound effects on
their confidence and outlook and therefore on their ability to learn.
Adult basic education and literacy programmes need to consider how
to support their learning, by enabling them to reflect on their
experiences.

HIV/AIDS, gender, and adult basic education in Thailand

The AIDS Education Programme of Chiangmai University has been
collaborating with the Asian-South Pacific Bureau of Adult Basic Education
(ASPBAE) in developing a set of participatory tools to promote HIV/AIDS
and gender awareness in the community. The tools are designed to help
women and men analyse the linkages between gender (gender
inequalities), development (issues of poverty and migration), and
HIV/AIDS. They include techniques for analysing gender values and
selecting marriage partners; womens work and mens work; risk
behaviours and connections among groups in the community; gender roles
and values in HIV/AIDS prevention and care; and gender differences in the
control of, and access to, resources in HIV/AIDS prevention and care.
The research and application of the tools emphasises the need for adult
basic education and awareness-raising about HIV/AIDS to be closely
linked to other spheres of education, social action, and structural change. It
also suggests the need for gender-sensitivity training for young men and
women as well as for service providers, community leaders, and faith-
based leaders all gatekeepers to womens equality.5

What is needed?
For adult basic education programmes to be gender-equitable and to
recognise the local impacts of poverty, discrimination against
women, and HIV/AIDS, they need to be closely linked to social
action and structural change focusing on poverty alleviation
measures, side by side with their engagement with the whole range
of education provision.

3 3. Gender Equality and Adult Basic Education,Education and

Gender Equality Series, Programme Insights, Oxfam GB. December
2005
Support and training for literacy workers in exploring these issues,
and links with other support services, need to be established.
Training and awareness-raising among trainers, youth leaders, and
students of how prevailing gender biases and relationships increase
the vulnerability of women, especially to HIV/AIDS, is necessary. In
addition, literacy workers need to be able to help both women and
men to discuss forms of gender inequality.
If adult basic education is to play a role in transforming the lives of
learners, staff need to be trained in participatory practices that
include women and men, so that they can support learners by
developing locally appropriate materials, available in languages
appropriate for a range of learners.
The short-termism that is often in evidence in adult basic education
and literacy programmes also needs to be addressed. In many cases,
short-term instruction is given (e.g. for six months), without the
follow-up needed to consolidate learning and promote reading. This
can have a negative impact on women who may be constrained in
their mobility to find another class or who have little spare income to
buy follow-up materials.
The current lack of training for teachers and facilitators, and the
shortage of institutions providing training in empowering methods
for the delivery of adult basic education, both need to be addressed.
There are few staff development opportunities or incentives.
Volunteers, often women, are poorly remunerated, despite their
potential and their commitment.

The Bolsa Escola Programme in Brazil: empowering mothers and

women
The Bolsa Escola programme is best known for its objective of providing
families with income subsidies, conditional on maintaining their children in
school. However, a second objective of the programme, currently being
implemented by Oxfam GB and the NGO Missao Crianca with EU funding,
is to empower women within the family. A mothers level of education, her
race, and her level of income, are all factors that correlate strongly with the
educational achievement of children in Brazil.
The programme, entitled Education to Confront Poverty, provides adult
education for mothers and other members of their families, and creates
incentives for mothers to participate directly in school meetings and local
education councils. The potential for womens participation already exists
in some contexts, but there are no real incentives for them to get involved.
So, by putting women in charge of receiving and allocating the benefits of
the programme, their self-esteem is boosted and their decision-making
influence within the family is promoted. Merely putting them in charge of
Bolsa Escola funds is not enough: instead, the programme is helping them
to become agents of change in their families and communities and to
develop skills that can transform their lives.6

3. Gender Equality and Adult Basic Education, Education and Gender 4

Equality Series, Programme Insights, Oxfam GB. December 2005
Neglect of the sector by governments
Governments state that they are committed to adult basic education
and literacy but in reality they are a low priority for most. Adult
basic education has remained under-funded and marginalised within
ministries, resulting in poor cohesion and co-ordination in adult basic
education programmes. Current government neglect of the sector
needs to be reversed.
Where they exist, large-scale government-funded adult basic
education and literacy programmes are usually weakened by short-
termism they are one-offs with no budget or plan for follow-up.
Adult education has been addressed through patchy and unco-
ordinated programmes and work by NGOs and community-based
organisations (CBOs). These often rely on short-term funding.
This is not a promising backdrop for the development of more
sophisticated gender-equitable policies and practices. In order to
deliver gender-equitable adult basic education and literacy
programmes, governments need to ensure that, rather than being
rigid and prescriptive, programmes are sensitive to variations in
context, respectful of differences, innovative, and responsive to a
range of challenges for building gender equality. Literacy
programmes must operate at a local level. Decentralised support
services appear to be the most successful means of enabling this, but
these need adequate resourcing. Where it exists, good practice should
be documented and shared.
Governments must be held accountable for the commitments they
have articulated. A policy framework for adult basic education and
literacy, based on democratic rights, is needed in most countries to
clarify the commitment and role of the state. Where this exists on
paper, there needs to be a push to ensure delivery and support
stronger forums and networks among the range of education
providers, for gender equality.

The role of civil society

The key challenge for civil society is to lobby governments through
advocacy, campaigning, and provision for an overall gender equity
approach to all education, by linking the focus on girls formal
education contained in the Millennium Development Goals to adult
basic education and literacy for women.
NGOs need to highlight for governments the potential of
participatory approaches in adult basic education and literacy to
achieve gender equality and social change. While willing to promote
literacy through partnerships with NGOs, governments may become
unsupportive or even hostile when mobilisation for literacy leads to a
wider social mobilisation of women advocating for their rights.

5 3. Gender Equality and Adult Basic Education,Education and

Gender Equality Series, Programme Insights, Oxfam GB. December
2005
Movements need to advocate for governments to establish a rights-
based policy framework, and governments need to ensure that a
process exists to achieve this. This means building dialogue with
governments.
There is a huge role for civil society to play in raising the profile of
adult basic education and literacy and ensuring that it is gender
equitable. NGOs have developed collaborations, such as the Global
Campaign for Education, to advocate for governments to honour
commitments they have made. More resources are needed to
strengthen advocacy for change to public policies, so that these
confront gender exclusion in the lack of education for adults and
promote education with gender justice.
Adult basic education and literacy are important in themselves, and
also for key areas such as health, leadership, and the broad issues of
womens empowerment. Through greater advocacy, adult basic
education needs to be moved higher up the agenda of the womens
movement and higher among the concerns of civil society.

Advocacy for gender justice in education

In 1990 REPEM (Womens Popular Education Network ) launched a
campaign in Latin America to change the image of women in education
programmes and in the media. With little financial support or political will
and in a context of sexism at all levels of education, the campaign worked
to influence:
the availability of adult basic education;
UN summits and conferences, particularly the Fifth International
Conference on Adult Education (CONFINTEA V);
social movements (e.g. the World Social Forum) and womens
movements where education was not a priority.
Since then, REPEM has developed into a strong network able to participate
in the preparatory process of each UN conference at local, regional, and
global levels. It prepares documents, reviews ongoing activities, and
monitors the implementation of agreements made by governments and by
previous conferences. The campaign fights not only for the physical
inclusion of women in adult basic education, but also to overcome the
exclusion of women based on other areas of difference: age, social class,
race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.7

Recommendations
Governments need to prioritise adult basic education and
gender equality by:
Developing a policy framework for adult basic education and
literacy that is part of an integrated education policy;
Working closely with civil society organisations to design and
develop this framework and subsequent policies;

3. Gender Equality and Adult Basic Education, Education and Gender 6

Equality Series, Programme Insights, Oxfam GB. December 2005
 Prioritising financial and human resources to support the
implementation of good quality adult basic education and literacy
that transforms gender relations;
Forming relationships and programmes with donors who
prioritise adult basic education (e.g. SIDA, the Swedish
International Development Cooperation Agency); and
Developing human resources and capacity, together with
adequate funding, at local levels of government (i.e. training,
curriculum development, research, and documentation).
Civil society actors need to raise the profile of adult basic education
and literacy and increase government commitment by:
Lobbying for investment in adult basic education as a necessity
for achieving all the MDGs;
Lobbying governments and funding agencies to develop
strategies to achieve commitments related to adult basic
education in the Dakar Framework of Action for Education for
All;
Lobbying to achieve the Beijing Framework for Action;
Developing strong links with womens movements and
organisations campaigning on HIV/AIDS and aspects of poverty.

Adult educators and civil society organisations together need to

develop gender transformatory practices by broadening the concept
of literacy, from simply learning to read and write, to learning and
developing skills for social action and womens empowerment. They
need to campaign for more creative and participatory training of
trainers, with action research linked to local gender needs and the
diversity of learners, and to document good practice to improve
understanding of how literacy is developed in different social
contexts and actions.

7 3. Gender Equality and Adult Basic Education,Education and

Gender Equality Series, Programme Insights, Oxfam GB. December
2005
Notes

(For all Beyond Access seminar papers and Equals newsletter see
www.ioe.ac.uk/efps/beyondaccess )
1
UNESCO (2005) Education for All Literacy for Life EFA Global
Monitoring Report 2006. Paris: UNESCO.
2
Fifth International Conference on Adult Education (CONFINTEA V),
Declaration 5, www.unesco.org/education/uie/confintea/documents.
3
A. Lind (2004) Reflections on Gender Equality and National Adult Basic
Education, Beyond Access Seminar 4.
4
K. Srivastava (2004) Community Mobilisation, Gender Equality, and
Resource Mobilisation in Adult Basic Education, Beyond Access Seminar 4.
5
U. Duongsaa (2004) Development, Gender, HIV/AIDS, and Adult
Education, Beyond Access Seminar 4.
6
L. Palazzo (2005) Bolsa Escola, Brazil: Enabling Enrolment and
Empowerment. Equals newsletter 11.
7
C. Eccher (2004) Gender and Education: History of Some Struggles,
Beyond Access Seminar 4.

Cover photograph: Annie Bungeroth

3. Gender Equality and Adult Basic Education, Education and Gender 8

Equality Series, Programme Insights, Oxfam GB. December 2005
 Oxfam GB, December 2005
This paper was produced by the Beyond Access Project. It is part of a series of
papers written to inform public debate on development and humanitarian policy
issues. The text may be used free of charge for the purposes of advocacy,
campaigning, education, and research, provided that the source is acknowledged in
full. The copyright holder requests that all such use be registered with them for
impact assessment purposes. For copying in any other circumstances, or for re-use
in other publications, or for translation or adaptation, permission must be secured
and a fee may be charged. E-mail [email protected].
For further information about the Beyond Access Project, see:
www.ioe.ac.uk/efps/beyondaccess
For comments on issues raised in this paper, please e-mail:
[email protected]
Other papers in this series can be found at:
www.oxfam.org.uk/what_we_do/issues/education/gender_education.htm

Oxfam GB
Oxfam GB is a development, relief, and campaigning organisation that
works with others to find lasting solutions to poverty and suffering around the
world. Oxfam GB is a member of Oxfam International.
Oxfam House
John Smith Drive
Cowley
Oxford
OX4 2JY

Tel: +44.(0)1865.473727
E-mail: [email protected]
www.oxfam.org.uk

9 3. Gender Equality and Adult Basic Education,Education and

Gender Equality Series, Programme Insights, Oxfam GB. December
2005