A Comparative Overview of Energy - Jan Van Staveren
A Comparative Overview of Energy - Jan Van Staveren
A Comparative Overview of Energy - Jan Van Staveren
A comparative overview of
Contents
Some definitions and fundamental laws
- Power
- Energy
- Law of Conservation of Energy
- Law of Conservation of Mass - Efficiency - Production factor - Actual energy yield
- Some efficiencies
- Units and conversion factors for power
- Units and conversion factors for energy
- Primary energy - Energy content of some fuels - Mechanical equivalent of heat - Efficiencies at the conversion of energy
- Carnot's formula - Newton's laws of motion
Energy consumption of a household Solar energy
Wind energy
Storage of solar and wind energy
Hydropower
Geothermal energy
Tidal energy Biomass
Energy storage in the batteries of electric cars
Smart grid Combined Heat and Power
Heat pump Batteries
Atomic battery
Walking and cycling
Electric bicycle
Electric trains
Vessels
Aircraft
The petrol car
The electric car
The hybrid car
The fuel cell car The Hydrogen Economy Nuclear fusion
Nuclear energy
-
ENERGY
page
6
6
6
7
7
7
8
8
9
9
9
9
10
10
11
11
11
12
13
20
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
32
37
38
40
41
43
44
45
46
51
53
55
58
60
65
65
65
66
67
71
73
74
75
76
77
78
80
82
83
86
90
91
91
92
92
93
95
98
99
101
101
101
102
103
104
105
106
108
113
115
121
125
126
131
133
135
138
140
141
142
143
144
146
Introduction
The most effective environmental measure
The energy consumption and the coherent environmental pollution is
proportional to the number of people on Earth. So the most effective
environmental measure will be: restricting the world population
That will be achieved (in the long run) when the reproduction rate
is not greater than 1. So not more than 2 children per couple.
After us the flood
In the book "Na ons de zondvloed" ("After us the flood") the author
P. Gerbrands, writes: "Within reasonable margins, growth of the number
of people and economic expansion will be possible, as long as we know
to limit ourselves to the consumption of the interest the Earth us offers.
But if also the capital named Earth itself is eaten, we as human species
will be entering a dead-end street"
Quote from The Greens Party program 2002
The uncontrolled growing population is a violent threat to life on Earth. Yet
there is an explosive growth of the world's population. Just like China India
will soon be a country with more than one billion inhabitants. (in 2010, India
already had 1,2 billion inhabitants). There is a direct relationship between
pollution of the environment and the population rate. More people produce
more waste, have more need for food, consume more raw materials, have
more hassle, have less living space, get less attention and need more
money. The conclusion is clear: birth control is a necessity. If not, we all
end up like bacteria on a limited breeding ground. After unbridled growth
unprecedented mortality follows.
The population explosion
From 1990 to 2000 each year the world's population has increased with an
average of 1,5% Suppose that this increase had occurred always from the
beginning of our era until today. How large would the world's population be
now, based on 2 people in the year zero?
~ after 2000 years the increase would be: 1,015 2000 = 8,55 1012
~ the Earths surface is 4 r2 = 4 40 106 square kilometres
(r = the radius of Earth = 6400 kilometres)
~ the total of earthlings would be: (2 8,55 10 12 ) / (4 40 106)
= 34000 per square kilometre, oceans and the poles included
In reality there live on Earth only 51 people per square kilometre. (in 2010,
on land). In the Netherlands the population density is 504 inhabitants per
square kilometre. That means a living place of 45 45 metres per person
2000
2050
the Netherlands
11 million
16 million
17 million
World population
3 billion
6 billion
9 billion
world population
increase in 10 years
2010
6 909 million
---
---
2020
7 675 million
766 million
210 000
2030
8 309 million
634 million
174 000
2040
8 801 million
492 million
135 000
2050
9 150 million
349 million
96 000
The average increase of the world population in the period 2010 2050
amounts to 153 000 people per day. So 1 million per week
in 2011 the 7 billionth earthling was born
in 2023 the 8 billionth is expected
A comparative overview of
ENERGY
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
1%
5%
15%
15%
25%
25%
29%
33%
34%
34%
35%
40%
41%
45%
50%
50%
58%
65%
75%
80%
80%
90%
90%
95%
97%
= 1 joule
= 3600 kilojoules
= 1 newton-metre
= 3600 000 newton-metres
Primary energy
Primary energy is the energy content of fuels in their natural
form, before any technical conversion has taken place
5,3 kilowatt-hours
8,1 kilowatt-hours
8,8 kilowatt-hours
9,1 kilowatt-hours
10,0 kilowatt-hours
33,6 kilowatt-hours
In the following the energy consumption or energy yield is converted into litres
petrol-equivalent (if possible). That appeals a bit more to imagination and it
makes a good comparison possible
Thermal energy in 1 litre of petrol
1 litre of petrol = 7800 kilocalories
At an efficiency of 100% it is possible to increase the temperature of 7800 litres
of water with 1 degree celsius (or to heat 78 litres with 100 degrees)
Mechanical energy in 1 litre of petrol
1 litre of petrol = 9,1 kilowatt-hours
This would keep a motor of 91 kilowatts running during 0,1 hours (= 6 minutes)
on full power. The efficiency of a petrol engine is approximately 25% Therefore
such a motor runs only 1,5 minute on 1 litre of petrol.
75% of the supplied energy is converted into useless heat
1 litre of petrol = 3 340 000 kilogram-metres
With 1 litre of petrol one can theoretically lift up a Jumbo of 334 000 kilogram
10 metres. Bringing up such aircraft 10 kilometres, costs (apart from the
forward speed, air resistance, efficiency etc.) 1000 litres of fuel
Mechanical equivalent of heat
This indicates the relationship between mechanical energy
(= labour) and thermal energy (= heat)
1 kilocalorie equals 427 kilogram-metres
An example:
~ to raise the temperature of 1 litre of water with 1 degree celsius,
1 kilocalorie is needed (by definition)
~ if one put one's hand in 1 litre of cold water during 1 minute then
the temperature of the water has risen approximately with
1 degree celsius.
~ this corresponds with a quantity of mechanical energy
of 427 kilogram-metres.
~ that will be sufficient energy to lift a cow (or 2 pianos) for 1 metre
Heat is the most compact form of energy
10
11
primary energy
(kilowatt-hours)
lighting
1,4
3,6
8,3
20,8
39,2
39,2
the car
36,0
36,0
total
84,9
99,6
Per day a car consumes one and a half times as much primary energy,
as an average Dutch household for lighting, refrigerator, TV, washing,
ironing, vacuuming etc.
It makes little sense to save on lighting as it is only 4% of the total energy
consumption. But it does help lowering the heating. All energy fed to lighting
and devices is fully converted into heat. A living room is not noticeably
warmer when the TV or the lights are switched on. Apparently the energy
consumption of the lighting and the TV is negligible compared to the energy
needed for heating. Many people think: all tiny bits will help". The "tiny bits"
will contribute very little and give the misleading sense, that one does quite a
lot for the environment and that therefore one can further go one's own way.
(with the heating and the car)
If everyone does a little, well achieve only a little
If comfort is at stake, one is no longer "at home".
12
Solar energy
Almost all the energy on Earth comes from the Sun
~ The power of solar radiation outside the atmosphere is
1,36 kilowatts per square metre. (that is the solar constant)
~ At the height of the Earth's surface and at a completely
unclouded sky, the solar radiation has a power of 1 kilowatt
per square metre. (at perpendicular irradiation)
~ So the theoretical irradiation per square metre per year
will be 1 kilowatt x 8760 hours = 8760 kilowatt-hours
(1 year = 8760 hours)
~ The actual irradiation per square metre per year in the
Netherlands = 1000 kilowatt-hours on a horizontal plane
(seasons, cloudy sky, day and night included)
~ So the production factor adds up to
(1000 / 8760) 100% = 11,4%
~ To maximise the yield of sunlight in the Netherlands, a fixed
solar panel should be mounted under an angle of 36 degrees
and focussed on the South.
~ At perpendicular radiation of sunlight on a solar water heater,
a solar panel, a parabolic mirror or a solar trough, the amount
of irradiated energy per square metre and during the same time
is (of course) always the same
~ At a heliostat the radiation is never perpendicular. There, the
angle of radiation is determined by the distance from the
heliostat to the solar tower and the position of the Sun
~ In the Netherlands the amount of irradiated solar energy on a
horizontal plane, in summer (June, July, August) is 6 times
as much as in winter (December, January, February)
Of course that will not be the same every year, see Leopoldhove
~ In the Netherlands the energy captured by a solar panel consists
of 40% direct sunlight and 60% indirect sunlight.
~ In the Sahara the amount of irradiated solar energy on a
horizontal plane is only 3 times as much as in the Netherlands
(during a year and on the same surface)
~ The annual amount of solar energy irradiated on the whole Earth
is 7000 times as much as the annual world consumption of
primary energy
13
kilowatt-hours
energy type
bio fuel
< 1%
chemical
15%
150
electric
65%
650
heat
14
15
Solar troughs
16
17
18
annual production
(megawatt-hours)
production
factor
52
52 000
11,4%
Seville (heliostats)
20
48 000
27,4%
150
495 000
37,6%
19
Wind energy
In 2000 at Zoetermeer, the then largest windmill in the Netherlands was put
into service. The mill was demolished in 2014 because its end of lifespan
had been reached. (?)
The power was 1,5 megawatts (= 1500 kilowatts). That equals the power
of 20 cars. (the Opel Astra has an engine of 74 kilowatts)
~ the hub height of this mill was 85 metres and the diameter of
the blades was 70 metres
~ so the highest point reached by the blades was 120 metres
~ the power was 1,5 megawatts
~ so the theoretical annual yield was 1,5 8760 hours =
13140 megawatt-hours (1 year = 8760 hours)
~ the actual annual yield was 3000 megawatt-hours
~ so the production factor was (3000 / 131400) 100% = 23%
~ the yield in 14 years was 14 x 3000 = 42 000 megawatt-hours
~ at an electrical energy price of 20 eurocents per kilowatt-hour
the total revenue will be 42 000 000 x 0,2 = 8,4 million euro
The generated energy by a wind mill is proportional to the 3rd power
of the wind speed. If the wind blows "half" force, the energy yield is
only 1/8 compared with "full" force.
~ the production factor of a windmill on land is 25%
~ the production factor of a windmill at open sea is 40%
The production factor increases as the windmill is higher and larger
Wind energy in the Netherlands
~ n 2009 the yield of wind energy was 4,6 billion kilowatt-hours
~ then the electricity consumption was 113,5 billion kilowatt-hours
~ so the share of wind energy was 4,1%
Some Dutch wind farms
number of
windmills
power per
windmill
total
power
annual yield
(megawatt-hours)
36
3 megawatts
108 megawatts
378 000
IJmuiden
23 km off the coast
60
2 megawatts
120 megawatts
422 000
Westereems
Eemshaven, on land
52
3 megawatts
156 megawatts
470 000
In 1 year a 600 megawatts power plant produces about 10 times as much energy
as 1 wind farm
20
21
22
Hydro power
Hydro power is of limited significance even in Switzerland, because the
energy consumption increased in recent years.
~ nowadays in Switzerland 40,5% of electrical
energy is generated by nuclear power plants
~ only in Norway virtually all electrical energy
is generated by hydro power
~ worldwide 16,5% of all electrical energy is
generated by hydro power.
The largest hydroelectric power plants in the world
A very large hydroelectric power plant, the Itaipu Dam is located at the
border between Brazil and Paraguay. Its reservoir is 170 kilometres long.
~ the capacity of this power plant is 12 600 megawatts
~ the energy yield is 75 billion kilowatt-hours per year
In China an even greater hydroelectric power plant has been built, the
Three Gorges Dam
~ the energy yield is 84 billion kilowatt-hours per year
~ that is 3% of the electricity consumption in China
For comparison:
Annually the Three Gorges Dam will produce 20 times as much energy
as a 600 megawatts power plant.
Dutch Teletext 19 May 2011
China admits, that there are problems at the three Gorges Dam in the
Yangtze River. Agricultural land drying out, the River is less navigable
and many people have lost their work. For the construction of the dam
one and a half million people had to leave their homes
23
Geothermal energy
Geothermal energy is extracted from the heat in the Earth.
~ from the Earths surface the temperature rises with increasing
depth with roughly 30 degrees celsius per 1000 metres
~ this can vary (strongly) depending on local circumstances
~ in volcanic areas temperatures are considerably higher
~ at a depth of 5000 metres the average temperature is about
150 degrees celsius.
Geothermal energy may play a (modest) role in future energy supply. It is now
possible to exploit geothermal energy on a commercial scale thanks to the
improved drilling techniques developed for the extraction of oil at great depth
Geothermal energy is:
~ clean, durable and inexhaustible
~ not depending on weather conditions
seasons and time of the day
~ the production factor is 100%
~ there is no CO2 emission
~ the energy is constantly available, so
there is no storage problem
Geothermal energy in a few countries
power
(megawatts)
annual yield
(megawatt-hours)
China
1440
12 600 000
3,00
Sweden
1140
10 000 000
2,38
USA
990
8 680 000
2,07
Iceland
760
6 610 000
1,57
New Zealand
220
1 970 000
0,47
Japan
160
1 430 000
0,34
24
Tidal energy
The energy generated by a tidal power plant is indirectly derived from the moon.
The largest tidal power plant in the world is in France in the mouth of the Rance
river. (since 1966)
~ the difference in height between ebb and flood tide is
very large, up to 13 metres.
~ the capacity of the tidal power plant is 240 megawatts
~ the production factor is approximately 26%
~ the annual energy generated is 540 000 megawatt-hours
~ a 600 megawatts power plant produces 8 times
as much energy in 1 year
At high tide the lock gates of the power plant are open and then sea water can
flow behind a dam. The water behind the dam has a maximum area of 22 square
kilometres. If the highest point of the flood is reached, the lock gates are then
closed and the water behind the dam is being held in the mouth of the river Rance.
At low tide, the water flows through 24 turbines back to sea. The turbines drive
generators, each with a capacity of 10 megawatts. If there is no difference in water
height behind and in front of the dam anymore, the production of electricity ceases.
The cycle is repeated when it becomes high tide again.
25
Biomass
Biomass is the collective name for organic materials, which can be used for the
generation of "sustainable energy". Examples of such organic materials are: fruit
vegetable and garden waste, wood and manure. Special "energy crops" can be
grown, such as oilseed rape, maize and sugar cane, which may be used as fuel
for vehicles, possibly after digestion, fermentation or gasification.
During the growth of trees for example, oxygen is produced and carbon dioxide
(CO2) is absorbed from the atmosphere. When combustion takes place the
opposite occurs. Net, this so-called "short cycle" does not pollute the environment
(CO2 neutral"). The advantage of using biomass: there is no storage problem.
The biomass can be incorporated in the fuel of coal-fired power plants. (those
coal-fired power plants which are so maligned by environmentalists). The extra
CO2 released is "green" and is deducted from the emissions according to "Kyoto".
Biomass in the Netherlands
~ in 2009 the energy generated by the burning of biomass in
the Netherlands was 7,8 billion kilowatt-hours.
~ then the electricity consumption was 113,5 billion kilowatt-hours.
~ so the share of biomass was 6,9%
This can not be much more in the near future, because the amount of biomass
is limited. One can therefore have legitimate doubts about energy suppliers who
are going to sell huge quantities of "green" energy to the consumer suddenly.
26
27
Smart grid
Smart grid is an energy management system, which controls the
distribution between the energy generated by renewable energy
sources (wind and solar energy) and conventional power plants.
The aim is:
~ the maximum flattening of the peaks and off-peaks
in the generation of energy. ("peak shaving")
~ compensation for the varying energy yield of
renewable energy sources
A primitive form of energy management already exists in the system of "off-peak
hours", which is often applied by suppliers of electricity. Electric boilers are
remotely enabled when the demand for electricity is low. (usually at night and in
weekends)
An intelligent energy management system may offer the following options:
~ thermostats of devices (for example, boilers and air conditioning) can
be remotely and automatically disabled or enabled according to the
instantaneous load of the grid.
~ batteries of electric cars can be loaded for one moment and the loading
can be stopped or the energy from the batteries can be (partially) fed
back to the grid, when an energy deficit is likely to occur.
~ as the wind varies, the energy of wind farms will be proportionally
supplemented by energy from (rapid starting) gas-fired power plants.
28
29
Heat pump
A heat pump transfers heat from a low temperature level to a higher level. For
example, the lower level is the ground heat which is approximately 12 degrees
during the whole year at any depth. The heat pump works according to the same
principle as a refrigerator, but the goal is different. In a refrigerator the interior is
chilled and the temperature outside is of no importance. In a heat pump, the heat
is important. A room can be heated with it. The heat that arises is the total of the
pump-energy and the heat from the ground. The efficiency seems to be more
than 100%. With a heat pump one uses the concept of COP (= coefficient of
performance). For example, the COP = 4. Then 3 times as much (free) heat,
from the ground is tapped compared with the pump energy. The total amount of
heat produced is then 4 times the pump-energy. The COP of a heat pump is
greater when the temperature difference between inlet and exhaust is smaller.
Therefore, a heat pump is often used in combination with floor heating.
The operation of a heat pump
compressor
ground
heat
evaporator
useful
heat
expansion
valve
condenser
30
electricity
100%
generating of electricity
40%
60%
40%
60%
(40%)
60%
160%
heat pump
31
Batteries
Alkaline battery (AA-cell):
~ contains 1,5 ampere-hour at 1,5 volt, that is 2,25 watt-hours
~ such a battery costs approximately 0,80
~ so 1 kilowatt-hour from an alkaline battery costs 356,00
Rechargeable nickel-metal hydride battery (AA-cell)
~ contains 2,7 ampere-hour at 1,2 volt, that is 3,24 watt-hours
~ the use of rechargeable batteries is much cheaper and more
environmentally friendly than ordinary batteries.
The rechargeable nickel-metal hydride batteries of GP PowerBank meet up to
the electrical specifications for 100%, which may be called noteworthy. I haven't
tested other brands, but there is a lot of chaff among the wheat", especially in
quickly rechargeable batteries. Unfortunately, the dimensions of AA-cells have
not been normalized apparently, or the manufacturers are not always keeping up
to the standard. This may cause (mechanical) problems at some applications
when alkaline batteries are replaced by rechargeable nickel-metal hydride
batteries. Sometimes they are a bit longer and thicker than the alkaline batteries.
Also the lower clamp voltage (1,2 volt) may be a disadvantage.
Some of the features of rechargeable batteries
watt-hours
per kilogram
cell voltage
efficiency
self discharge
volt
charging cycle
per month
lead-acid battery
40
2,1
92%
3%
nickel-cadmium battery
60
1,2
90%
10%
80
1,2
66%
30%
lithium-ion battery
160
3,6
90%
5%
200
3,7
99%
5%
zinc-air battery
470
1,6
---
---
20
1,2
80%
---
32
During loading a redox reaction takes place in the battery. The ionisation degree
of the atoms changes. In one half the electrolyte is reduced and in the other half
oxidized. This will create opposite charges. At discharging, the reverse reactions
will take place. Both halves are connected with their own storage tank with
electrolyte. The amount of electrolyte (and thus the energy content of the battery)
can be made very large. The electrolyte from the storage tank is pumped along
the corresponding electrode. When the battery delivers energy, positive ions flow
trough the membrane, and electrons trough the external circuit. While discharging
the battery, the charges on both sides of the membrane are settled. When the
electrolytes are developed, they should be replaced by fresh electrolytes with a
new load. The battery can also be recharged by an electric current.
Some of the features:
~ the battery is especially suited for stationary applications and can be
used to level off the fluctuating yield of solar panels and windmills
~ the energy density is low, approximately 20 watt-hours per kilogram
~ the lifespan is very large, more than 10,000 load cycles
~ the power is determined by the dimensions of the membrane
~ the energy content is virtually unlimited and is determined by the size
of the storage tanks with the electrolytes
~ already a vanadium redox battery has been made with an energy
content of 12 megawatt-hours.
~ an electric train could run 2000 kilometres on this energy content
(a 4-wagons Double Decker consumes 6 kilowatt-hours per kilometre)
~ loading may be done (very quickly) by replacing the electrolytes,
but the battery can also be recharged by an electric current
~ perhaps the redox battery is interesting for application in an electric car,
because loading can be done very quickly by replacing the electrolytes
The principle of the vanadium redox battery resembles Blue Energy. There
also a membrane is applied that separates 2 electrolytes, salt and fresh water
which have different charges
33
lifetime
(discharge cycles)
100%
500
50%
1500
25%
2500
10%
4700
34
This story is too good to be true and therefore it is probably not true. Would
it be true, then the problem of electric cars would have been resolved.
With a battery-weight, equal to a full petrol tank, (and with half the volume),
the action radius of an electric car would then be about 2000 kilometres. If
the batteries are always charged, when the car doesn't drive, the average
energy-stock would be more than enough for everyday use. The question
remains: how to heat the car in winter. If the energy is derived from the
battery then it will be at the expense of the action radius
Toshiba announces a breakthrough in rechargeable lithium-ion batteries
Early 2008 Toshiba launched an improved lithium-ion battery, the SCiB
(Super Charge ion Battery)
The main features of the standard module, which contains 10 cells, are:
~ the voltage is 24 volt at 4,2 ampere-hours
(so the energy content is 100 watt-hours)
~ the battery is very safe (no explosion or fire hazard)
~ the charging time is 10 minutes
~ the energy density is bad in comparison with an ordinary
lithium-ion battery (100 watt-hours at a weight of 2 kilograms
and a volume of 1,35 cubic decimetre)
~ the lifespan is very large, 10 years or 6000 charging cycles
(after 3000 charging cycles the capacity loss will be only 10%)
~ the battery can be used within a wide temperature range
(-30 to + 45 degrees celsius)
~ the properties of the battery highly agree with those of a
super capacitor (high charge and discharge currents and very
short charge and discharge times)
Using this new type of lithium-ion battery, the electric car, the hybrid car and
also the electric bicycle could become a great success. The rapid charging
is especially interesting for recovery of electrical energy during braking and
speed reduction.
Sony also has developed a new lithium-ion battery
The new Sony battery stands out for the large discharge current, which is
possible. Some of the features:
~ a cell, type 18650 will deliver 1,1 ampere-hours at
3,2 volts, so the energy content will be 3,5 watt-hours
~ the energy density is 95 watt-hours per kilogram
~ the maximum discharge current is 20 amperes
~ the battery can be recharged in 30 minutes up
to 99% of the capacity
~ the lifetime is 2000 charge cycles
35
36
Atomic battery
In an atomic battery energy is released by the decay of radioactive isotopes
and not by a chain reaction. There are 2 techniques to generate electricity:
Some examples:
thermal conversion
~ a thermocouple produces a small electrical current
if heat is applied.
~ a hot-air engine starts running if heat is applied
non-thermal conversion
~ a capacitor is loaded if radiation, coming from a
radioactive source, is beaming on one of the plates.
~ radioactive radiation can be converted into infrared light,
a photocell can convert this into electricity.
~ an electromechanical nuclear battery consists of a fixed
metal plate and a bendable plate.
~ both are isolated from each other.
~ radioactive radiation creates opposite charges and as
a result the bendable plate will move towards the fixed
plate until they touch.
~ then the plates are discharged and the bendable plate
moves back again.
~ this process repeats itself 35 times per second.
~ the movement of the bendable plate is converted into
electricity by a piezoelectric material
Some of the features of the nuclear battery
~ very expensive
~ small size
~ low efficiency, up to 8%
~ extremely long life, many decades
~ very high energy content
~ small power
~ can work by heat generation or beta radiation
as a result of radioactive decay
~ applications in the medical sector (pacemakers)
~ as an energy source for space vehicles and
communications equipment
~ in underwater systems and in computerized
scientific systems on hard to reach places
37
38
39
Electric bicycle
~ on an electric bicycle the cyclist is supported by an
electric motor
~ this motor gets its energy from a rechargeable battery
~ the degree of support is automatically controlled by
a pedal sensor
~ the pedal sensor measures the force that is being
exercised on the pedals
~ the motor gets energy proportional to that force
~ the result is, that on a slope or with headwind,
support will increase
Ideally, climbing a slope or cycling against wind will be as easy as cycling on
a flat road without wind. But of course that will cost a lot of energy. Therefore
it is possible at most electric bicycles, to adjust the extent of support more
or less progressively by using a switch on the bicycle handlebar. One can for
example, choose between the modes "normal" or "power". The action radius
of the support is determined by the energy content of the battery and the
energy consumption of the motor.
The legal maximum power of the motor is 250 watts.
Electric bicycles are so constructed that the electric motor can only be enabled,
when one is pedalling. A bicycle with an auxiliary engine in the literal sense of
the word.
The energy consumption of an electric bicycle
The energy consumption of an electric bicycle is strongly depending on the
circumstances under which the bicycle will be used. For example:
~ 50% support
~ an upright seated cyclist
~ a speed of 20 kilometres per hour
~ a headwind of 4 metres per second
~ hard inflated tyres
Under these circumstances, the energy delivered by the battery will be
5 watt-hours per kilometre
~ the total efficiency of the charging cycle of the
battery and the electricity generation is 30%
~ so the primary energy consumption is
5 / 0,30 = 16,7 watt-hours per kilometre
~ converted to petrol-equivalent this is
1 litre per 545 km
40
Electric trains
The Double Decker
The Double Decker is the most modern and efficient train of the Dutch Railways.
~ the basic implementation of the train is 4 wagons
with 372 seats
~ the total length of 4 wagons is 108 metres.
~ the weight, including the travellers is 254 tonnes.
~ the power is 1608 kilowatts.
The weight and number of passengers in this train is similar to that of a Jumbo.
In the following, global calculation we will assume an 85% efficiency of the train,
a trajectory of 14 kilometres and a speed of 140 kilometres per hour
(= 39 metres per second).
~ the maximum power of 1608 kilowatts will be used during
acceleration
~ the speed of 140 kilometres per hour will be reached
in 2,4 minutes
~ at that time 3000 metres have been travelled and
54 kilowatt-hours consumed
~ during the following 9360 metres 1/3 of the power is used
~ in the next 4 minutes, at a constant speed, 30 kilowatthours are consumed (overcoming the rolling resistance
frictional losses and air resistance)
~ the remaining 1640 metres will be used for speed reduction
and braking
~ so the net amount of energy consumed will be 54 + 30 =
84 kilowatt-hours (that is some more than the energy the
Greenpeace solar panel of 0,75 square metres will generate
in a year).
~ the total efficiency of the electricity generation and the train
together will be 33% 85% = 28%.
~ for a trajectory of 14 kilometres gross consumption will be
84 / 0,28 = 300 kilowatt-hours which is equivalent to
33 litres of petrol
~ this will allow 372 persons to be transported over a distance
of 14 kilometres
~ which is a consumption of 1 litre per 158 km per traveller
~ during the braking of the train, energy can be fed back into
the overhead line.
~ much extra energy is needed for heating in winter
~ that energy should also be supplied via the overhead line
The results of this calculation come out well in line with the data I got from a
train driver. In a car the heating is provided by waste-heat. At a train energy
for heating is generated with an efficiency of approximately 33%
41
The Thalys
The Thalys, which runs on the High Speed Line, consumes much more
energy than an ordinary train. The 1500 volt direct current, as applied in
the Netherlands, will no longer be sufficient.
The Thalys on the line Amsterdam-Paris is suitable for 3 different voltages:
~ 25000 volts alternating current (on all High Speed Lines,
for this the train has been designed)
~ 3000 volt direct current (in Belgium on existing rail)
~ 1500 volt direct current (in the Netherlands on existing rail)
The switching happens automatically. In the Netherlands, the Thalys partially
runs on tracks that already exist. There the speed will be limited to about
160 kilometres per hour especially near Rotterdam and Amsterdam. The train
is equipped with 6 different signalling systems, including the Dutch, Belgian,
German and French system
~ the Thalys has a fixed composition of 8 wagons
and 2 motor cars with 377 seats.
~ its length is 200 metres.
~ its weight, including the travellers is 414 tonnes
~ its power is 8850 kilowatts.
In the following global calculation will be assumed that the train will have an
efficiency of 85%. The trajectory will be 100 kilometres and the speed will
be 300 kilometres per hour. (= 83 metres per second)
~ during acceleration the maximum power of 8850 kilowatts
is used
~ the speed of 300 kilometres per hour will be reached after
3,5 minutes
~ at that time then 8 kilometres have been travelled and
396 kilowatt-hours consumed
~ during the following 92 kilometres 2/3 of the power is used
~ then in 18,4 minutes, at a constant speed, 1538 kilowatt-hours
will be consumed (for overcoming the rolling resistance,
frictional losses and air resistance)
~ so the net amount of energy consumed is 396 + 1538 =
1934 kilowatt-hours
~ the total efficiency of the electricity generation and train
together will be 33% 85% = 28%
~ for the entire route of 100 kilometres the gross consumption
will be 1934 / 0,28 = 6907 kilowatt-hours
~ this is the equivalent to 759 litres of petrol
~ this allows 377 persons to be transported over a distance
of 100 kilometres
~ per traveller this is a consumption of 1 litre per 50 km
42
Vessels
Electric boat (seen on an exhibition of boats)
~ a battery of 420 ampere-hours and 24 volts, so 10 kilowatt-hours.
~ this amount of energy is sufficient to sail a boat of 800 kilograms for
8 hours at a speed of 6 kilometres per hour.
~ the energy costs about 2,- and for that price 8 persons could be
transported over a distance of 50 kilometres.
~ converted to petrol-equivalent, that is 1 litre per 91 km per person.
The fast ferry between Harwich and Hook of Holland
~ this boat, a Catamaran, with a speed of 75 kilometres
per hour is the fastest ferry in the world.
~ the boat is powered by 4 gas turbines with a total
capacity (power) of 69 000 kilowatts.
~ the boat is 124 metres long and 40 metres wide.
~ the transport capacity is 1500 passengers and 350 cars
~ so the amount of energy consumed is
69 000 / 75 = 920 kilowatt-hours per kilometre.
~ the consumption is 337 litres of petrol-equivalent per
kilometre at an efficiency of 30% of the gas turbines.
~ a car weighs on average as much as 12 passengers.
~ altogether that is the weight of
350 12 + 1500 = 5700 passengers.
~ this is 1 litre per 17 km per "passenger".
This ferry has been taken out of service, because there was too little interest
43
Aircraft
The Boeing 747
Jumbo"
44
45
Already 5000 electric cars had been manufactured in America by Baker Electric
between 1899 and 1915. The top speed was 23 kilometres per hour, with an
action radius of 80 kilometres. Another well-known brand in the initial phase was
Detroit Electric. This company produced electric cars that reached a top speed
of 32 kilometres per hour, at a 130 kilometres action radius.
A car battery of 12 volt, 36 ampere-hours can provide 12 36 = 432 watt-hours
energy. The contents of a normal petrol tank is 48 litres. This corresponds to
437 kilowatt-hours. which is approximately equal to the energy content of
1000 car batteries.
Nowadays electric cars can cover reasonable distances. That is due to:
~ a better kind of battery (nickel-metal hydride or lithium-ion
instead of lead batteries)
~ the higher efficiency of the electric motor (90%) compared
with a petrol engine (25%)
~ a lower speed (the air resistance is proportional to the 2nd
power of the speed)
~ a low rolling resistance, low weight and a streamline
~ regenerating of energy during braking, speed reduction and
descending a slope
Some characteristics of the electric car are:
~ the electric car is virtually silent
~ the electric car produces no exhaust gases
(but the power plant does all the more)
~ there are only a few moving parts, so there is less maintenance
~ it is relatively easy to drive the individual wheels separately,
so there is no need for a differential
~ at the same amount of propulsion energy the primary energy
consumption is higher than for a hybrid or diesel car, equal
for a petrol car and less than for a hydrogen car
~ at the same amount of propulsion energy the (indirect)
CO2-emissions is the same for a hybrid or diesel car but
lower than for a petrol or hydrogen car
~ the electric motor can deliver maximum torque at all speeds,
this enables a quick acceleration
~ the efficiency of the electric motor is high at all revolutions
~ the electric motor is never running idle
~ there is no need for a gearbox
~ the action radius is (very) limited
~ the battery is heavy, very expensive and takes a lot of space
~ charging the battery lasts very long (minimum 4 hours)
~ heating an electric car comes at the expense of the range
46
The General Motors EV1 (electric vehicle) has been produced between 1996
and 1999. It was an electric 2-seater car 1117 pieces have been produced.
They were not for sale, as they were meant to be for leasing purposes only.
In 2003 all cars were seized and destroyed by General Motors except for a
few units, that were donated to museums and schools. At first they were made
unusable. This may have happened under pressure of the oil industry. The first
draft was created on the occasion of the "World Solar Challenge" in Australia
in 1987. The first type, the "Impact" reached a top speed of 295 kilometres per
hour. Everyone was excited, except General Motors. They started developing
the EV-1, to show that time was not yet ripe for a successful electric car.
However, the developers were so excited, that it was difficult to curb them.
The battery of this car could be charged via an induction coil. This was safe
during rainy periods. Slow charging via a plug was also possible. For the user
the EV-1 was a great success. For General Motors the profit margin was too
low and there was fear that the sale of ordinary cars, which created much profit,
would decrease. This happened anyway, because Japan imported many
modern cars. The EV-1 was the best electric car ever made. It was far ahead
of its time.
Some data:
~ low weight because of an aluminium frame and plastic components
~ a very low air resistance
~ heating by means of a heat pump
~ keyless entry and ignition
~ the power of the 3-phase induction motor was 102 kilowatts
~ the car accelerated in 8 seconds from 0 to 100 kilometres per hour
~ its top speed was 130 kilometres per hour
~ the energy content of the nickel-metal hydride battery was
26 kilowatt-hours
~ the action radius was 200 kilometres
~ the average energy consumption was 130 watt-hours per kilometre
~ the load time of the battery was 8 hours
A film has been made about this car in 2006: "Who killed the electric car?"
47
48
49
50
The Prius
In 1997 Toyota has launched the "Prius". This is a hybrid car. In 2004 an
improved version appeared. Worldwide there are now (2013) more than
3 million cars of this type. It is a car which is propelled by an electric motor
(60 kilowatts), a petrol engine (73 kilowatts) or a combination of both,
depending on the situation. Its goal is to achieve an as high as possible
(vehicle) efficiency.
~ the efficiency of the (Atkinson) petrol engine is high, but strongly
depending on the load and the speed
~ the electric motor always has a high efficiency
~ the electric motor is working when the efficiency of the petrol
engine is low
~ the energy for the electric motor is supplied by a rechargeable
nickel-metal hydride battery of 1,3 kilowatt-hours
(= 0,14 litres of petrol-equivalent)
~ at (regenerative) braking and speed reduction the electric motor
works as a dynamo and delivers energy back to the battery
~ in addition, the battery is recharged by a generator, which is
linked to the petrol engine
~ the charging happens, when the petrol engine works with a high
efficiency
~ the generator can also provide energy directly to the electric
motor
~ the petrol engine, generator and electric motor are linked
together by means of a mechanical energy distributor, which is
controlled by a microprocessor
~ this energy distributor also functions as a continuously variable
automatic transmission
~ the efficiency of this automatic gearbox is much higher than an
ordinary manual gearbox.
51
The hybrid system can of course never be more energy efficient than
the petrol engine which is part of it
All energy is derived from this engine and all energy conversions are
accompanied with (small) losses. The profit of the hybrid system is extracted
from the following properties
~ the electric motor works during starting from
standstill and at low speeds
~ the petrol engine is designed for the average
power and therefore it will be extra economical.
~ the electric motor assists the petrol engine during
acceleration and short-term at high speeds.
~ energy is returned to the battery when speed is
reduced and while braking.
~ the petrol engine stops once the car is stationary
and so never idles.
~ the petrol engine works as much as possible
under circumstances when the efficiency is high.
~ at low efficiency of the petrol engine the electric
motor assists.
In braking-stopping-acceleration situations the highest effect of the hybrid system
is achieved. For instance in traffic jams and in cities with many traffic lights. Over
long distances and at high speed the hybrid system is not working. Then only the
economical (Atkinson) petrol engine works. The efficiency of this engine is 34%.
A normal petrol engine has an efficiency of 25%. The Prius (a luxury 5-seater car),
with an "energy monitor" on the dashboard, invites you to practise an economical
driving style. The consumption then will approach the 1 litre per 25 km
provided by Toyota.
The Prius 4
In 2016 the Prius 4 was launched.
Some data:
~ the efficiency of the Atkinson engine is 40%
~ the petrol consumption is 1 litre per 30 km
52
53
Toyota
It is striking, that especially Toyota is very active with the development of
"green" cars on all fronts. All are full cars without any compromise in the
area of safety and luxury. For years they have been tested and applied in
practice on a large scale
~ the electric car
~ the hybrid car (Prius)
~ the fuel cell car
The production of the electric car has been discontinued, because of low
interest. Toyota now produces an assortment of 4 hybrid cars and 1 plug-in
hybrid car.
In 2015 Toyota launches the first fuel cell car
The Mirai
54
55
56
There are quite a few misunderstandings about water, hydro power, hydrogen
and nuclear fusion of hydrogen-isotopes. Therefore the following overview:
Water
Water is the combustion product of hydrogen and oxygen. So it contains
no energy
Hydro power
When fast running water or water under high pressure drives a turbine, hydro
power is released. This happens in a hydroelectric power plant. Hydro power
is an energy source
Hydrogen gas
Water can be decomposed into hydrogen and oxygen by electrolysis. The energy
in hydrogen is released again at the "burning" in a fuel cell. The energy for the
decomposition of water initially has to be provided by fossil fuels, nuclear energy,
nuclear fusion, wind energy, hydropower, geothermal energy or solar energy. (so
by energy sources). Therefore hydrogen is not an energy source but an energy
carrier.
Nuclear fusion of hydrogen isotopes
Trough nuclear fusion hydrogen isotopes can fuse into helium. A huge amount of
energy is then released. This technique is still in its infancy and it will be at least
50 years before there may be practical applications. (if ever)
Nuclear fusion is an energy source.
Some quotes from letters in NRC-Handelsblad
The promise that in future hydrogen will be the solution for the energy supply for
mankind, is based on pure fantasy. Not technically. It works: the hydrogen engine,
the fuel cell and also the windmills or the solar cells that might deliver the energy
needed for the electrolysis of water to produce hydrogen.
Without any quantification, about the potential of the said technique, this kind
of stories fits into the popular magazines of the car lobby, not in the NRC.
The biggest objection against the use of hydrogen as a fuel in cars is that it is very
unsafe. Both at the distribution trough pipelines and when driving a car safety is
bad. At application of electrolysis using electricity produced in a natural gas-fired
power plant, the chain is:
natural gas > electricity > hydrogen > electricity > propulsion energy
One would really come up with the idea to drive cars on natural gas and to forget
hydrogen
57
Nuclear fusion
There are 2 types of nuclear reactions, suitable for the generation of energy.
~ fission of uranium nuclei. This is called nuclear energy
~ fusion of hydrogen nuclei. This is called nuclear fusion
Mass loss happens in both processes. In nuclear fission, this is about 0,10% and in
nuclear fusion 0,35%. The "disappeared" mass is converted into energy according
to the formula of Einstein
The energy that the Sun radiates comes from nuclear fusion of hydrogen atoms.
This nuclear fusion is formed at an extremely high pressure and a temperature of
15 million degrees celsius. In nuclear fusion on Earth the pressure is negligible in
comparison with the Sun and therefore the temperature here should be very much
higher, around 150 million degrees celsius.
If matter is very strongly heated, it forms a plasma. In a plasma the atomic nuclei
and electrons move separately. Atomic nuclei are positively charged and repel. The
repellent force is overcome at 150 million degrees by the speed of the movement
of the atomic nuclei. As a result nuclear fusion occurs
The fusion reaction which can best be established on Earth is the merging of the
hydrogen isotopes Deuterium and Tritium. This produces Helium atoms, neutrons
and very much energy. Fusion of a Deuterium-Tritium mixture with a mass of 250
kilogram generates as much energy as the incineration of 2,7 million tonnes of coal
That is sufficient to keep a power plant of 1000 megawatts running at full power
for one year.
The main problem with fusion is the extremely high temperature, which is needed
in the plasma. No material is resistant to this extreme temperature. In a so-called
"Tokamak" the hot plasma is trapped in a strong magnetic field and there is no
contact with the wall. A Tokamak is a ring-shaped reactor where the plasma is
heated up to the temperature at which fusion occurs.
To deliver more energy than necessary for the merging process a Tokamak must
have a minimum size. This will be realized for the first time in ITER (International
Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor), the first (experimental) fusion power plant.
The outer dimensions are: 24 metres high and 34 metres in diameter. ITER is a
project, which Reagan and Gorbachev have taken the initiative for at the end of the
cold war. ITER must demonstrate the possibility of long-term energy generation
with nuclear fusion.
It is expected that during 10 minutes 500 megawatts can be generated. This is ten
times more than the amount of energy that is used for maintaining the hot fusion
plasma. ITER is the biggest international scientific research project since the
construction of the International Space Station. (ISS)
58
After ITER a larger power plant DEMO will be built. That should demonstrate
the technical feasibility, reliability and economic attractiveness of fusion energy
Around 2050 the first prototype of a commercial fusion reactor PROTO should
be ready. Nuclear fusion is inherently safe. There is no chain reaction. If something
goes wrong, the reaction will stop. Because there is no chain reaction, nuclear
fusion is inherently safe. In nuclear fusion little radioactive waste arises. This waste
has a short half-life time.
Source: Kernfusie, een zon op aarde (Nuclear fusion, a Sun on Earth)
Author: Dr. Ir. M.T. Westra FOM-Institute for plasma physics Rijnhuizen".
Press release on 21 November 2006:
"The European Union, the USA, Russia, China, India, Japan and South Korea
have reached an agreement on the construction of the first fusion power plant.
The construction (of ITER) begins in 2008 in the South-French Cadarache and
it will take 10 years."
59
Nuclear energy
The relationship between mass and energy can be calculated with
the formula of Einstein.
E = mc2
E = energy m = mass c = the speed of light
1 kilogram-mass is equivalent to 25 billion kilowatt-hours
The fuel for the nuclear power plant in Borssele consists of 4,5% fissile
Uranium 235. Approximately 1 per thousand of the mass will be converted
into energy during the fission process. The energy per kilogram of nuclear
fuel as heat released will be "only" 1,125 million kilowatt-hours.
In 2013 the electricity consumption in the Netherlands was 115 billion
kilowatt-hours
This would require: (rounded)
either
300 tonnes enriched Uranium (efficiency 33%)
or
36 000 000 tonnes coal
(efficiency 40%)
The difference in efficiencies is the result of the fact that a nuclear power plant
works with lower temperatures (by application of heat exchangers), than a gas,
oil or coal-fired power plant. (Carnot).
Imagine a train with 50 tonnes goods wagons and a length of 10 metres each,
then the following image will appear:
~ for the carriage of enriched Uranium 6 goods wagons =
60 metres
~ for the carriage of coal
720 000 goods wagons = 7 200 kilometres
From the combustion of all that coal 94 million tonnes of CO2 will be released.
So that is only in the Netherlands and only for the benefit of electricity generation.
In 2013 the total primary energy consumption in the Netherlands
was 911 billion kilowatt-hours
The equivalent of this is approximately 100 billion litres of petrol, a cube with
an edge of 460 metres. Obviously sustainable energy is not an option for the
time being.
~ the stock of fossil fuels is large, but finite. (in about 75 years all
economically extractable fossil fuels except coal will be exhausted)
~ renewable energy will never be sufficient, because there are more
and more people, with still more energy needs
From 1973 to 2013 the increase of world population has been 84%
From 1973 to 2013 the increase of world energy consumption has been 222%
Summary:
~ the worlds population and the energy consumption are increasing rapidly
~ natural gas and oil resources will be exhausted at the end of this century
~ sustainable energy will never meet the requirements of 9 billion earthlings
~ nuclear fusion will take 60 to 80 years or maybe it will never come
Conclusion:
~ coal-fired power plants and nuclear energy seem inevitable
60
61
62
Concerning nuclear energy: each solution has its advantages and disadvantages
("the law of conservation of misery") The question is: which is preferably?
~ irreversible climate change
~ sea level rising and flooding of the land
~ continued increase in air pollution (CO2)
~ exhaustion of all fossil fuels
~ environmental disasters involving oil tankers,
oil rigs and oil drilling at sea, such as: oil spill in
Alaska, the Gulf of Mexico and in the Niger delta
~ wars to secure the supply of oil or natural gas
~ earthquakes and subsidence by gas extraction
or
~ a limited (radioactive) waste problem, which can be
solved in principle
~ accidents with nuclear plants
(Harrisburg 1979, Chernobyl 1986, Fukushima, 2011)
This dilemma exists, because before the year 2050 it seems to be necessary, that
an extra 2 billion people still have to come. On average this means 1 million
extra per week, while already there are 7 billion earthlings. Often it is said, that
radioactive waste from nuclear power plants remains active for 240 000 years.
This argument is not very interesting. I dare to the theorem, that within this period
humanity will have died out. Perhaps by nuclear weapons. It is curious that one
is excited about nuclear energy and not about nuclear weapons
Message in NRC-Handelsblad of 17 September 2010
The American president Obama is an important step closer to ratification of a
Treaty with Russia on reducing strategic nuclear weapons. Whether the Senate
will ratify that Treaty is by no means certain. Under the Treaty, the USA and
Russia will shrink their strategic nuclear warheads to 1550 pieces each in
seven years. Around 30 percent less than now is permitted
Dutch Teletext 23 December 2010
In the U.S. Senate a majority has approved the new START Treaty. The Treaty
should lead to less strategic nuclear weapons in the USA and Russia. The Russian
Duma has yet to accept. The approval in the Senate is a victory for Obama. Last
year he received the Nobel Peace Prize for his pursuit of a world without nuclear
weapons
Dutch Teletext 16 February 2012
The American government considers a drastic reduction of the number of nuclear
weapons, perhaps with 80%. That is much more than was agreed in the new StartTreaty with Russia. Then only 300 nuclear weapons would remain.
63
64
65
66
The Sun
Almost all energy on Earth comes from the Sun
Almost all energy resources on Earth (oil, natural gas, coal, biomass, wind
and hydro power) find their origin in solar energy.
Exceptions are: geothermal energy, nuclear energy and energy from the
Moon. (tidal energy). The most direct source of energy is the light and heat
radiation from the Sun. This energy source is clean and inexhaustible and
in the distant future we will be largely dependent on it. The energy that is
radiated by the Sun is generated by nuclear fusion.
Every second 4,27 billion kilogram mass in the Sun turns into energy.
Nuclear fusion on Earth may also play a large role in energy generation.
Calculation of the amount of energy radiated by the Sun in 1 second
~ the distance between the Earth and the Sun is 150 million kilometres
~ outside the atmosphere and at perpendicular irradiation the power of
the Sun is 1,36 kilowatt per square metre. (that is the solar constant)
~ the total radiation power from the Sun is: the solar constant multiplied
with the surface of a sphere with a radius of 150 million kilometres
~ the radius of the sphere r = 150 109 metres
~ the surface of the sphere = 4 r2
= 4 1502 1018 square metres
~ the total amount of energy emitted from the Sun in 1 second
= 1,36 4 1502 1018 1 kilowatt-seconds
~ 1 kilogram mass = 25 109 3600 kilowatt-seconds
~ the energy radiated by the Sun in 1 second is equivalent:
to: (1,36 4 1502 1018 1) / (25 109 3600)
= 4,27 billion kilogram mass
In 2013 the electricity consumption in the Netherlands was 115 billion
kilowatt-hours. That is equivalent to 4,6 kilogram-mass. The amount
of energy the Sun radiates in 1 second is almost 1 billion times as
much as the total use of electricity in 1 year in the Netherlands
The total amount of solar energy irradiated on the Earth
~ the total amount of irradiated energy is equal to what falls
perpendicular on a circular plane with the radius of the Earth
(the radius r = 6400 kilometres).
~ the surface of that circular area is:
r2 = 3,14 40 1012 square metres.
~ at the height of the Earth's surface the solar radiation has
a power of 1 kilowatt per square metre.
~ per square metre per year the irradiated energy will be
1 kilowatt x 8760 hours = 8760 kilowatt-hours
~ so annually the total amount of irradiated solar energy
on the circular plane will be
3,14 40 1012 8760 = 11000 1014 kilowatt-hours
~ in 2013 the world consumption of primary energy was
1,57 1014 kilowatt-hours
67
So annually the total amount of irradiated solar energy will be 7000 times as
much as the world consumption of primary energy.
Some people conclude from this that an energy problem
doesn't exist. However, one must bear in mind the following:
~ a large part of the irradiated solar energy is
stopped by the clouds
~ for the generation of solar energy gigantic
surfaces are needed
~ there is no efficient large-scale system for
the storage of solar energy
~ 71% of the Earth's surface consists of water,
so the irradiation on the remaining 29% is
0,29 x 7000 = 2000 times the world
consumption of primary energy
~ the efficiency of the conversion of solar
energy to electricity is low
Distribution of the solid surface of the Earth
68
69
26
119
159
58
70
The Leopoldhove
The Leopoldhove in Zoetermeer, is a healthcare facility with associated
properties. On the roofs of the complex is a large number of solar panels.
In the hall of the main building, one can read the energy yield of those
panels on a display
Some data of the Leopoldhove
~ 606 panels with a total area of 770 square metres
~ the annual yield is 64 000 kilowatt-hours
~ the annual yield per square metre is 83 kilowatt-hours
~ the average daily yield is 175 kilowatt-hours
Overview of the monthly energy yield of the Leopoldhove (2010)
kilowatt-hours
percentage
January
1040
1,6
February
1582
2,5
March
5244
8,2
April
8454
13,3
May
11216
17,6
June
10301
16,2
July
9544
14,9
August
6801
10,7
September
4933
7,7
October
3357
5,3
November
959
1,5
December
348
0,5
63779
100,0
total
520 kilowatt-hours
cloudy
11 June
27 November
63 kilowatt-hours
3 kilowatt-hours
In Summer at a cloudless sky the daily production was more than 8 times
as much as at a cloudy sky. In Winter the ratio was a factor 34 and during
a year 173
71
Daylight in the Netherlands (hours per day, from sunrise until sunset)
20 March
H = 37,8 degrees
D = 12 hours 09 min.
21 June
H = 61,4 degrees
D = 16 hours 44 min.
23 September
H = 37,9 degrees
D = 12 hours 10 min.
2016
day length
22 July
10 August
26 August
11 September
26 September
11 October
26 October
12 November
04 December
21 May
02 May
16 April
01 April
17 March
02 March
16 February
30 January
08 January
16 hours
15 hours
14 hours
13 hours
12 hours
11 hours
10 hours
09 hours
08 hours
72
22 December
H = 14,5 degrees
D = 07 hours 43 min.
Wind energy
Everyone is in favour of wind energy, until a windmill will be placed in the
neighbourhood. NIMBY
One experiences or expects the following problems:
~ noise
~ at a particular position of the Sun the rotating blades can interrupt
the sunlight in an annoying way (a few hours per year)
~ the rotating blades may sometimes cause interference with radio
transmissions, in the reception of terrestrial television stations and
(ships)radar
~ horizon pollution
(endless residential areas on the horizon are no problem)
~ birds getting killed against the blades
~ offshore wind farms will cause degradation of flora and fauna on
the seabed
~ large offshore wind farms will cause less rain and wind, while also
the height of the waves will be reduced.
73
74
oxygen
carbon dioxide
water
1 kilogram of carbon
2,67
3,67
---
1 kilogram of methane
4,00
2,75
2,25
1 kilogram of petrol
3,51
3,09
1,42
3,47
3,12
1,35
1 kilogram of hydrogen
8,00
---
9,00
energy-content
(kilowatt-hours)
kilograms CO2
(per kilowatt-hour)
1 kilogram of coal
2,6
8,1
0,32
1,8
8,8
0,20
1 litre of petrol
2,4
9,1
0,26
2,7
10,0
0,27
kilograms CO2
(carbon dioxide)
energy-content
(kilowatt-hours)
kilograms CO2
(per kilowatt-hour)
1 kilogram of coal
3,1
8,1
0,38
2,2
8,8
0,25
1 litre of petrol
3,1
9,1
0,34
3,5
10,0
0,35
fuel
75
76
77
Light sources
Comparison of various light sources
watts
lumen
light efficiency
incandescent lamp
75
930
12
5%
23
1550
67
29%
Led lamp
13
1000
76
34%
fluorescent tube
51
4800
94
41%
Led lamps
At Ikea a 13 watt Led lamp is for sale. The luminous flux is 1000 lumens,
which is 76 lumens per watt. The colour temperature is 2700 kelvin.
So the light efficiency is 34% and thus higher than at an energy saving lamp.
The light is radiated evenly in all directions
So finally it starts to be something with Led lighting (2014)
78
79
Aircraft
number of
passengers
blank
weight
fuel
weight
max.
take-off
flight range
kilometres
km / litre /
passenger
Boeing 747
524
396 tonnes
13 445
32,5
Airbus 380
840
540 tonnes
14 450
37,2
80
81
Electric train
~ the basic implementation of the Double Decker consists of 4 wagons
~ the gross power is 1890 kilowatts, at an efficiency of 85%
~ nowadays the voltage on the overhead contact line is 1800 volts.
~ at full power this train will consume more than 1000 amperes and
will represent an electrical resistance of about 2 ohms.
~ the direct current, submitted by a power station is fed to the train
through the overhead line, while the rails are the return circuit.
~ the total resistance of 10 kilometres of overhead line + rails is
about 0,2 ohms.
~ the distance between 2 power stations is up to 20 kilometres.
Therefore the distance between the train and the power station is
never more than 10 kilometres.
On busy tracks the average distance between the train and a power station
will be less. The total copper cross-section of the overhead contact lines on
a double track is 10 square centimetres. This is being obtained by switching
in parallel all 8 wires above the rails
(per rail: 1 reinforcing cable, 1 carrying cable and 2 overhead contact wires)
The energy losses in the overhead line of a train
~ Electric trains are driving at 1800 volt direct current in
the Netherlands. (rated 1500 volts).
~ The energy consumption of a train = voltage current time
~ For example: a 5 times higher voltage will result in a current
that is 5 times smaller (at the same energy consumption),
~ The energy losses in the overhead line are proportional to
the square of the current.
~ So the energy losses will be 25 times smaller.
Nevertheless, it seems unlikely for the Dutch Railways to apply a higher
supply voltage at any time. Only on the tracks of the "Betuwe line" and
the "High Speed Line" 25 kilovolts alternating current has been applied.
82
Cycling
Power and energy when cycling on a flat road, sitting upright and
without wind
A = the power necessary for overcoming the mechanical resistance
B = the power necessary for overcoming the air resistance
C = the total required power
D = the energy per kilometre
speed
10 km/hour
8 watts
20 km/hour
7 watts
15 watts
1,5 watt-hours
18 watts
56 watts
74 watts
3,7 watt-hours
30 km/hour
32 watts
189 watts
221 watts
7,4 watt-hours
40 km/hour
52 watts
448 watts
500 watts
12,5 watt-hours
83
Energy used for overcoming the air resistance on the same distance
is proportional to the 2nd power of the speed of a vehicle
~ the air resistance of a vehicle is proportional
to the 2nd power of the speed.
~ energy = air resistance distance travelled
For example:
A car driving at a speed of 120 kilometres per hour, uses 1,5 2 = 2,25 times
more energy than a car driving at a speed of 80 kilometres per hour over
the same distance
Wind during cycling is always detrimental if one returns to the place
of departure
calculation example:
~ suppose a distance of 30 kilometres there and back.
~ no wind, a cycling speed of 20 kilometres per hour
then the cyclist will be cycling for 3 hours.
~ backwind or headwind of 10 kilometres per hour
the cyclist experiences the same air resistance when the speed
relative to the wind is the same. With backwind the cycling speed
will be 30 kilometres per hour and with headwind 10 kilometres
per hour. Now the cyclist will be cycling 1+ 3 = 4 hours
So the amount of supplied energy will be 4/3 = 1,33 times as
much as when there is no wind.
Also when there is crosswind a cyclist has to deliver more energy
than when there is no wind
Source: the book "Hoor je beter in het donker?" ("Do you hear better
in the dark?") author: Jo Hermans, professor at Leiden University
calculation example:
~ suppose the crosswind is just as strong as the headwind
~ then the airspeed of the resultant of the crosswind and the headwind
is 2 times as large as the air speed in the cycling direction
~ the resultant makes an angle of 45 degrees with the cycling direction
~ the air resistance is proportional to the 2nd power of the air speed
~ therefore the air resistance of the resultant is 2 times larger than the
air resistance in the cycling direction when there is no wind
~ the resultant can be dissolved in the air resistance in the cycling
direction and perpendicular to the cycling direction
~ the result is that due to the crosswind, the air resistance in the
cycling direction is 2 = 1,41 times greater than at no wind.
~ so (in this example) it costs 1,41 times more energy to cycle
the same distance than at no crosswind
84
or headwind
bicycle power
0%
0,0 km/hour
75 watts
1%
7,9 km/hour
129 watts
2%
13,7 km/hour
184 watts
3%
19,1 km/hour
238 watts
4%
23,4 km/hour
292 watts
5%
27,4 km/hour
346 watts
6%
31,3 km/hour
400 watts
85
Electric bicycles
~ an upright seated cyclist must deliver a power of 180 watts at
a speed of 20 kilometres per hour and a headwind of 4 metres
per second (wind force 3).
~ that corresponds with an amount of energy of 9 watt-hours
per kilometre
~ therefore 4,5 watt-hours of mechanical energy per kilometre
is needed for 50% support by an electric bicycle.
~ the efficiency of the electric motor with associated energy
control is about 90%
~ therefore at 50% support the battery of an electric bicycle has
to deliver approximately 4,5 / 0,9 = 5 watt-hours per kilometre
That is a minimum value, because one uses the support especially at (strong)
headwind. The (average) action radius of an electric bicycle at 50% support
is easy to calculate.
action radius (kilometres) =
energy-content of the battery (watt-hours) / 5 (watt-hours per kilometre)
An example shows, that this is correct. The Trek LM500 has a battery with
an energy content of 400 watt-hours. Therefore the action radius should be
400 / 5 = 80 kilometres. This corresponds to the data of Bosch.
As long as one cycles on a flat road with a constant speed, the weight of the
bicycle will have hardly any affect on the action radius. (Newtons 1st Law)
There are 3 implementing forms of electric bicycles:
~ drive by means of an electric motor in the front wheel
~ drive by means of an electric motor attached to the
bottom bracket
~ drive by means of an electric motor in the rear wheel
Some examples:
The Antec Vela
~ a lithium-ion battery (removable)
36 volt at 10,5 ampere-hours
~ so the energy content is 378 watt-hours
~ the support can be adjusted continuously between
10% and 90%
~ equipped with a 7-speed hub gear
~ the motor is in the front wheel
~ at 50% support the action radius will be 60 kilometres.
86
87
watt-hours
per kilometre
action radius
turbo
8,0
50 km
sport
6,7
60 km
tour
5,0
80 km
eco
3,0
135 km
88
rolling resistance
2,6 newtons
2,9 newtons
2,9 newtons
air resistance
9,6 newtons
9,6 newtons
28,5 newtons
mechanical resistance
0,6 newtons
0,6 newtons
1,6 newtons
12,8 newtons
13,1 newtons
33,0 newtons
3,55 watt-hours
3,64 watt-hours
9,17 watt-hours
89
90
Power plants
Fuel and power of some power plants in the Netherlands
location and name
fuel
power
Borssele
nuclear plant
uranium
449 megawatts
Amsterdam
Hemweg 8
Hemweg 9
coal
natural gas
830 megawatts
435 megawatts
coal +
biomass
620 megawatts
620 megawatts
natural gas
natural gas
640 megawatts
640 megawatts
Geertruidenberg
Amercentrale 8
Amercentrale 9
Maasbracht
Clauscentrale 1
Clauscentrale 2
91
92
600
4,200
27
80,0
449
3,700
31
94,1
240
0,540
213
26,0
150
0,495
232
37,6
120
0,420
273
40,1
52
0,052
2212
11,4
In 2013 the energy consumption in the Netherlands was 115 billion kilowatt-hours
A 600 megawatts power plant produces 4,2 billion kilowatt-hours per year
~ at a production factor of 80% the annual energy yield will be:
600 megawatts 8760 hours 0,80 = 4,2 billion kilowatt-hours
~ in 6 years such a power plant produces an amount of energy,
equivalent to 1 kilogram mass
The Waldpolenz Solar Park is a large Sun-voltaic power plant in Germany
This power plant includes 550 000 solar panels on a surface of 1,2 square
kilometre. 2212 of these power plants will be needed to fulfil the need for
electricity in the Netherlands. That amounts to 2212 550 000 =
1,2 billion panels on a surface of 2654 square kilometres. An area of more
than 50 at 50 kilometres. Solar-energy, a realistic perspective?
Note, this only concerns the generation of electrical energy.
The total consumption of primary energy in the Netherlands is 3,4 times
as much. That also should ever be excited "green" ?
We "conveniently" ignore the problem, that Sun-voltaic plants will not deliver
energy when the sky is cloudy and during the night. In addition, the energy
yield during the winter months is 6 times less than in summer.
93
94
Electric cars
~ in 2005 there were 7 million cars in the Netherlands.
~ per car on average 17400 kilometres was driven per year.
~ that is a total distance of 120 billion kilometres per year
(800 times the distance Earth-Sun).
~ on average an electric car consumes 150 watt-hours per kilometre
If all cars in the Netherlands would drive electrically, then would be needed:
120 150 = 18000 billion watt-hours = 18 billion kilowatt-hours per year.
For the generation of this amount of energy 5 more 600 megawatts power
plants would be needed. The electricity consumption of all households in
the Netherlands is 25 billion kilowatt-hours per year. So the capacity of the
entire electricity infrastructure (power lines, cables, transformers etc.)
should therefore be increased substantially
Recently more and more articles appear in the press about very fast
rechargeable batteries and super capacitors. Will they be a solution for
the energy supply in electric cars? No, not really.
For example:
~ the action radius of an electric car is 200 kilometres
~ the energy consumption is 150 watt-hours per kilometre
~ then the battery should have an energy content of
30 kilowatt-hours
~ at a charging time of 6 minutes (= 0,1 hours) one arrives
at a power of 300 kilowatts
~ at a 230 / 400 volt 3 phase network this requires a
current of 435 amperes per phase
That doesn't appear to be a realistic solution.
Press release on 29 December 2008:
"The electric car is not yet ready for a rapid advance. The boss of Bosch,
the largest car-supplier in the world, calls the expectations about electric
cars overly euphoric. Cars with an internal combustion engine will certainly
dominate the streetscape another twenty years"
95
range
batt
power
acc
top
prim
km / l
130
200
26
100
130
450
20
Tesla Roadster
165
340
56
215
200
567
16
Tesla model S
177
480
85
270
200
610
15
Toyota Prius
124
1000
----
73 / 60
10
180
364
25
~ The General Motors EV1 was far ahead of its time. With regard to the energy
consumption per kilometre, it was the best electric car ever made
~ The Tesla model S is equipped with a battery, which can be recharged in
40 minutes. With this car it would also be possible, to replace an empty battery
by a full copy, within 5 minutes. (but in practice that will not work of course)
According to the manufacturer the loading speed will be 62 miles per hour
~ The most fuel-efficient car is the Prius. This luxury 5-seater car has an range
of 1000 kilometres. Worldwide there are already more than 3 million units
on the road. (2013)
~ The petrol consumption of the Prius is 4 litres per 100 kilometres. That is 364
watt-hours per kilometre. The efficiency of the Atkinson petrol engine is 34%
So the net energy consumption of this engine is 124 watt-hours per kilometre
96
range
batt
power
acc
top
prim
km / l
Nissan Leaf
150
250 - 200
30
80
12
144
500
18
Citron C-zero
125
150 - 128
16
49
16
130
417
22
Mitsubishi i-MiEV
125
160 - 128
16
49
16
130
417
22
Renault Kangoo ZE
155
170 - 142
22
44
20
130
517
18
147
195 - 150
22
65
14
135
490
19
Renault Fluence ZE
176
185 - 125
22
70
13
135
587
16
Volkswagen e-up
117
160 - 160
19
60
12
130
390
23
BMW i3
129
190 - 147
19
125
150
430
21
97
98
hybrid
car
petrol
car
diesel
car
fuel cell
car
150 watt-hours
150 watt-hours
150 watt-hours
150 watt-hours
150 watt-hours
77%
34%
25%
35%
45%
energy supplied
(per km)
195 watt-hours
from the mains
441 watt-hours
from petrol
600 watt-hours
from petrol
429 watt-hours
from diesel oil
333 watt-hours
from hydrogen
CO2-emissions
(per km)
148 grams by
the power plant
150 grams
by the car
204 grams
by the car
150 grams
by the car
258 grams by
the power plant
primary energy
(rounded)
195 / 0,33 =
591 watt-hours
441 watt-hours
600 watt-hours
429 watt-hours
333 / 0,32 =
1040 watt-hours
1 litre per
15,4 km
1 litre per
20,6 km
1 litre per
15,2 km
1 litre per
21,2 km
1 litre per
8,8 km
propulsion
energy (per km)
efficiency
of the car
energy in litres
petrol-equivalent
1,0
9,1
10,0
33,6
electric car
~ the electric motor never needs to warm up
~ there is no gearbox and so there are no
transmission losses
~ during braking and speed reduction energy
is returned to the battery
~ on site the car causes no CO2 emission,
but on the other hand the power plant does
hybrid car
~ the cold petrol engine must be warmed up,
that takes a lot of energy
~ the continuously variable gear works with a
very high efficiency
~ during braking and speed reduction energy
is returned to the battery.
~ the petrol engine is always running under
circumstances when the efficiency is high,
~ the petrol engine is never running idle
petrol or diesel car
~ the cold engine must be warmed up, that
takes a lot of energy
~ there are relatively large energy losses in
the gearbox
~ regenerating of energy is not possible
~ in a petrol engine the efficiency strongly
depends on the speed and torque
~ the petrol engine is often running idle
99
100
101
30
36
50
60
80
100
walking
108
158
469
cycling
540
electric bicycle
545
recumbent
1235
3315
102
103
104
105
Bio fuel
~ the efficiency of the transposition of solar energy to chemical
energy through photosynthesis is much less than 1%
~ the annual irradiation of solar energy in the Netherlands is
1000 kilowatt-hours, measured on a horizontal plane of
1 square metre
~ the annual yield of rapeseed oil is approximately 1700 litres
per hectare.
~ 1 hectare = 10 000 square metres
~ therefore the annual yield will be 0,17 litres per square metre
~ the primary energy content is 1,7 kilowatt-hours
~ if the by-products are also charged (press cake and straw)
one arrives at 3 kilowatt-hours, which is only 0,3% of the
amount of irradiated solar energy
~ after transposition into electric energy only 1,2 kilowatt-hours
remain, at an efficiency of 40%
~ the annual yield of an electric solar panel of 1 square metre
is 150 kilowatt-hours
~ so at the same surface and during the same time, an electric
solar panel will produce 125 times more electrical energy
than rapeseed oil.
A better solution seems to be the production of bio-ethanol. That is
derived from sugar beet, sugar cane or maize, after fermentation.
The yield is 0,57 litres per square metre, with a primary energy content
of 3,5 kilowatt-hours. That is 2 times as much as of rapeseed oil.
Since September 2005 the oil companies are obliged to mix petrol and
diesel oil with 2% bio fuel in the Netherlands. One strives to 10% in 2020.
Press release on 9 October 2008:
"The Government will limit the use of bio fuels in petrol and diesel oil. It
was the intention that 4,5% of the oil next year should consist of rapeseed
and palms. That has been adjusted to 3,75%. The target for 2010 will also
be reduced, because it seems that the promotion of bio fuels will be
detrimental to the food production in poor countries.
It is immoral and criminal to use precious agricultural land for (large-scale)
production of bio fuel to be able to drive our cars here, while in large parts
of the world famine is increasing. In addition, the effective emissions of
CO2 will hardly be reduced by the use of bio fuels.
106
107
108
109
110
111
Africa
North
South
America America
Asia and
Oceania
Eastern
Europe
West
Europe
6,9
37,3
3,1
35,4
6,1
11,2
oil
62,1
6,3
7,4
7,9
3,8
9,8
2,7
natural gas
32,5
6,4
5,5
3,9
9,3
37,3
5,2
112
Some units
Watt peak
Watt peak is the electrical power of a solar panel, at an perpendicular
irradiation of 1000 watts per square metre and a panel temperature of
25 degrees celsius
For example:
~ a solar panel has a surface of 1 square metre
~ the efficiency is 15% (current state of the art)
~ then the electrical power will be 1 1000 15% = 150 watt peak.
The theoretical annual yield of 1 watt peak is 1 x 8760 = 8760 watt-hours.
In the Netherlands the actual annual yield of 1 watt peak is approximately
850 watt-hours. This is caused by the following circumstances:
~ the production factor of solar energy in the Netherlands is 11,4%
~ the efficiency of a solar panel depends on the irradiated power
and on the panel temperature. (the warmer the worse).
~ a solar panel will be subject to aging and pollution.
~ in addition, losses can be experienced in the "inverter"
The inverter is a circuitry that converts the low direct voltage
from the solar panel into an alternating voltage of 230 volts
This enables feed back of the solar energy into the grid.
~ a fixed solar panel almost never is mounted under the ideal
angle of 36 degrees and is rarely exactly facing South.
So in the Netherlands the annual yield of a 150 watt peak solar panel
will be 150 x 850 watt-hours = 127 500 watt-hours.
On average that will be 127 500 / 365 = 350 watt-hours a day
1 household = 3650 kilowatt-hours a year = 10 kilowatt-hours a day
(that is a continuous power of 417 watts)
1 household is the average consumption of electrical energy per household
per year in the Netherlands. Of course that is not the same each year, but
this (rounded) value is often used to indicate the yield of solar or wind energy.
For example:
The wind farm at IJmuiden generates 422 000 megawatt-hours per year.
So that will be sufficient for 422 000 000 / 3650 = 115 600 households
1 kilocalorie = 427 kilogram-metres = 1,16 watt-hours
1 kilocalorie is the amount of energy required to raise the temperature
of 1 kilogram of water with 1 degree celsius
~ melting down 1 kilogram of ice of 0 degrees celsius costs
80 kilocalories
~ bringing to the boil 1 kilogram of water of 0 degrees costs
100 kilocalories
~ fully evaporating 1 kilogram of water of 100 degrees costs
540 kilocalories That is (coincidentally?) 3 times as much
as needed for melting + bringing to the boil
113
114
31,1%
coal
28,9%
natural gas
21,4%
bio fuel
10,2%
nuclear energy
4,8%
hydro power
2,4%
1,2%
total world
100,0%
39,2%
China
22,3%
12,2%
8,5%
Africa
5,5%
Middle East
5,1%
4,6%
Bunkers
2,6%
total world
100,0%
115
OECD
5 300
1 261
4,20
1 156
341
3,39
689
218
3,17
3 023
1 367
2,21
619
472
1,31
1 655
2 348
0,71
747
1 111
0,67
13 541
7 118
1,90
Middle East
China
Non OECD Americas
Asia (without China)
Africa
total World
2013
49
691
1 410%
China
427
3 020
707%
336
1 652
492%
Africa
207
745
360%
214
623
291%
3 739
5 308
142%
946
1 151
122%
6 100
13 541
222%
Middle East
OECD
Non OECD Europe and Eurasia
total World
116
increase
The total primary energy production and the electricity consumption in 2013
(per country and in billion kilowatt-hours)
total primary
energy production
electricity
consumption
Netherlands
911
115
Middle East
8 013
841
China
35 157
5 165
19 248
2 155
Africa
8 688
649
7 199
1 011
OECD
61 639
10 179
13 444
1 538
153 388
21 538
World
The total primary energy production and the electricity consumption in 2013
(per inhabitant and in kilowatt-hours)
total primary
energy production
electricity
consumption
Netherlands
53 614
6 823
Middle East
36 867
3 863
China
25 702
3 778
8 257
918
Africa
7 792
584
15 235
2 142
OECD
48 846
8 072
39 426
4 510
World
22 097
3 026
117
40%
households
23%
services
30%
agricultures
total
7%
100%
Overview of the energy sources foe generating electricity in some countries (2009)
(billion kilowatt-hours)
nuclear
energy
hydro
energy
4,2
0,1
4,6
0,05
7,8
96,9
113,5
Belgium
47,2
1,8
1,0
0,17
5,3
35,7
91,2
Germany
134,9
24,7
38,6
6,58
41,9
345,7
592,5
69,1
8,9
9,3
0,02
12,4
275,9
375,7
409,7
61,9
7,9
0,17
6,1
55,9
542,2
27,7
37,5
0,0
0,05
2,4
0,8
68,5
0,0
53,4
6,5
0,67
10,0
216,6
292,6
Spain
52,8
29,2
37,8
6,04
4,5
163,6
293,8
Sweden
52,2
66,0
2,5
0,00
12,2
3,9
136,7
Norway
0,0
127,1
1,0
0,00
0,4
4,4
132,8
Denmark
0,0
0,0
6,7
0,00
4,0
25,6
36,4
Russia
163,6
176,1
0,0
0,00
3,1
649,2
992,0
Africa
12,8
101,3
1,7
0,03
2,2
514,9
632,8
Japan
279,8
82,1
3,0
2,80
24,3
656,0
1047,9
China
70,1
615,6
26,9
0,32
2,4
3019,2
3734,7
0,0
12,3
3,8
0,27
2,8
241,8
260,9
USA
830,2
298,4
74,2
2,50
72,9
2892,9
4188,2
World
2696,8
3329,2
273,2
21,00
298,2
13447,2
20132,2
Netherlands
United Kingdom
France
Switzerland
Italy
Australia
wind
energy
solar
energy
118
geothermal
biomass
coal, oil,
natural gas
total
Overview of the energy sources foe generating electricity in some countries (2009)
(percentages)
nuclear
energy
hydro
energy
wind
energy
solar
energy
geothermal
biomass
coal, oil,
natural gas
total
3,7
0,1
4,1
0,04
6,9
85,3
100
Belgium
51,8
1,9
1,1
0,18
5,9
39,2
100
Germany
22,8
4,2
6,5
1,11
7,1
58,4
100
United Kingdom
18,4
2,4
2,5
0,01
3,3
73,4
100
France
75,6
11,5
1,5
0,03
1,1
10,3
100
Switzerland
40,5
54,8
0,0
0,07
3,5
1,1
100
0,0
18,3
2,2
0,23
5,2
74,0
100
Spain
18,0
9,9
12,9
2,06
1,5
55,7
100
Sweden
38,2
48,3
1,8
0,00
8,9
2,8
100
Norway
0,0
95,7
0,7
0,00
0,3
3,3
100
Denmark
0,0
0,1
18,5
0,01
11,1
70,4
100
Russia
16,5
17,8
0,0
0,00
0,3
65,4
100
Africa
2,0
16,0
0,3
0,00
0,1
81,4
100
Japan
26,7
7,8
0,3
0,26
2,3
62,6
100
China
1,9
16,5
0,7
0,01
0,1
80,8
100
Australia
0,0
4,7
1,5
0,10
1,1
92,7
100
USA
19,8
7,1
1,8
0,06
1,7
69,1
100
World
13,4
16,5
1,4
0,10
1,5
66,8
100
Netherlands
Italy
119
solar energy
4,6
0,05
Germany
38,6
6,58
Spain
37,8
6,04
China
26,9
0,32
USA
74,2
2,50
World
273,2
21,00
Compared to other countries very little solar energy is generated in the Netherlands.
Germany generates 31% of the world production of solar-energy. This is 132 times
as much as the Netherlands. Spain is second best with 29% of the world production.
percentage
140,9
27,0
coal
99,0
19,0
Uranium
91,8
17,6
biomass
53,9
10,3
wind
51,4
9,9
Sun
32,8
6,3
natural gas
33,2
6,4
hydro power
18,5
3,6
521,5
100,0
brown coal
total
120
Solar radiation warms the air located under a low circular, translucent collector.
This collector is open at the border. The translucent roof of this collector
together with the ground is a storage space for the heated air. A tower is stated
in the centre of the round roof. The heated air rises in this tower. As a result
new cold air enters on the edge of the storage space. At night also there is a
continuous flow of warm air to the tower, because the entire ground surface
consists of tubes filled with water. At daytime these tubes are being heated
and at night they release their heat again. In the air flow to the tower a number
of wind turbines are placed. The associated generators generate electricity.
It is possible that such a tower might be built in Australia.
Some data: (rounded)
~ the temperature of the air under the collector rises 30 degrees
~ the speed of the airflow at the foot of the tower is 60 kilometres
per hour
~ the power is 200 megawatts
~ the annual production is 680 000 megawatt-hours
~ a 600 megawatts power plant produces 6 times as much
energy in 1 year
~ the tower is 1 kilometre high and the diameter is 130 metres
~ the diameter of the round collector is 5 kilometres
(so the radius r = 2500 metres)
~ at the foot of the tower there are 32 turbines of 6,5 megawatts
121
122
Ladder Mill
The ladder mill consists of a system worn by the wind. There are a large number
of wings that are bound to a strong rope that forms a loop. One end of the loop
gives power to a dynamo on the ground. The wings are set as blades in such a way
that along one side of the loop the wings move upward under the influence of the
wind. Beyond the top high in the air, the wings along the other side of the loop
move down again. This is achieved by altering the state of the wings, by which
they suffer an upward or downward pressure. This creates a spinning movement
of the loop. The energy yield of the ladder mill is said to be at least 50 times
more than of an ordinary windmill with a capacity of 1 megawatt.
This doesn't seem to be very realistic.
The Maglev wind turbine
Maglev is the abbreviation of magnetic levitation. The Maglev wind turbine has
a vertical axis. The axis and the blades are resting on a magnetic bearing.
A magnetic bearing is virtually frictionless. (but does consume energy). Due
to the very low friction, this wind turbine already provides a useful amount of
energy at an air speed of 3 metres per second. Very high wind speeds do not
constitute a problem, the mill can continue to run. Therefore, according to the
Chinese inventors, this type of wind turbine may provide 20% more energy in
comparison with a conventional wind turbine of the same power. One has to
guess how the magnetic bearing works. It is unclear how it should be built
with permanent magnets and the use of no electrical energy for the levitation.
Therefore this seems to be a very unlikely story. The friction of the bearings
normally consumes only a few percents of the energy that is generated by a
wind turbine. Therefore very little profit can be achieved. Interesting is the
vertical axis, causing this mill to be insensitive for the direction of the wind,
while very large constructions are possible. The wind energy is exited over
the entire height of the mill. This kind of constructions has already been
known many years (centuries). The mill would have monstrous dimensions,
(like 600 metres high, with a diameter of 400 metres) and then generates just
as much energy as 1000 ordinary windmills.
123
Wave energy
Wave energy is energy won from the rapidly changing water height at sea by
the presence of waves. Although theoretically (very much) energy can be won,
until now it has not been done on a large scale because the costs usually
exceed the benefits. Off the coast of Portugal the first commercial wave
plant will be build. A plant that converts energy from ocean waves into
electrical energy. The system will generate enough electricity for (only)
1500 households.
124
Free energy
Nikola Tesla
Tesla was able to transport energy wireless over great distances. It was stated
that he left lamps burning wireless at a distance of several hundred metres. He
also would have converted an electric car, that could drive for a week without
charging the battery. This would also be made possible by the wireless transfer
of energy.
The wireless transmission of energy in itself is nothing special. Virtually all the
energy we use on Earth is transferred wirelessly from the Sun to the Earth.
It is much stranger actually that large amounts of electrical energy can be
transported through a few copper wires. For example, from a power plant
to a big city
An electric 2-seater sports car was named "Tesla Roadster". This car is
powered by a 3-phase alternating current induction motor. The principle of
this motor was invented by Tesla in 1888.
125
Storage of Energy
Some forms of storage of energy
1. Electrical energy in super capacitors
2. Chemical energy in batteries and hydrogen
3. Thermal energy in materials with a large heat capacity
4. Kinetic energy in flywheels
5. Potential energy by moving mass against gravity
to a higher level or by compressing air
1. Electrical energy
Electrical energy may be stored in the form of electric charge in a super
capacitor. Super capacitors can be charged and discharged very fast
with high peak currents. In hybrid and electric cars super capacitors can
be used for saving the brake energy quickly and effectively, while that
energy then is available again quickly in acceleration. The energy content
of a super capacitor is relatively small, while the tension rapidly declines
during the discharge. However, recent developments are promising.
An example is the k2 super capacitor made by Maxwell
~ the cell voltage is 2,85 volts
~ the capacity of one cell is 3400 farad
~ the energy content of one cell is 4 watt-hours
~ the lifetime is more than 1 000 000 load cycles
~ the power is 18 kilowatts per kilogram
the energy-content (joule) of a capacitor = CV2
C = the capacity (farad) and V = the voltage (volts)
There are already modules with super capacitors on the market, which
have an energy content of 282 watt-hours at a capacity of 17,8 farad and
a voltage of 390 volts. Also there are plans for a super capacitor with an
energy content of 52 kilowatt-hours. In the long term the super capacitor
might replace the battery in certain applications. The lifetime is virtually
unlimited, while the efficiency of the charging cycle is very high, about 97%.
Recently the graphene super capacitor is announced. In this capacitor
20 times as much energy could be saved as in a regular super capacitor
2. Chemical energy
In batteries and accumulators, but also at the production of hydrogen gas,
electrical energy is stored in the form of chemical energy.
2.1. Batteries
Batteries are relatively cheap and reliable. The efficiency of the charging
cycle is quite high, approximately 85%. On the other hand, batteries are
overweight and they need much room, while the capacity is limited. Also
the long charging time or the huge charging current often consist a problem.
An interesting possibility seems the application of the vanadium redox
battery
126
season
storage
consumption
of a household
March
to August
in hydrogen
E
1825
September
to February
from hydrogen
(0,40 x E)
1825
127
128
4. Kinetic energy
Kinetic energy can be stored in a flywheel. The storage capacity is pretty small.
A flywheel can be used for slowing down a vehicle. Then the kinetic energy is
stored in the flywheel. The energy will be used again for acceleration. This is
applied in some city buses
5. Potential energy
Potential energy can be obtained by moving mass to a higher level. For example by
pumping water to a higher located reservoir. This often happens at hydroelectric
plants. For pumping, the excess energy is used that is available in the valley hours.
In times of drought, the potential energy, which is stored in the reservoir, can be
converted again in electrical energy by the hydroelectric plant The efficiency of this
form of energy storage is quite high, approximately 80%.
5.1. Potential energy in a pressurised vessel
Another form of potential energy arises, if air is compressed. Compressing
air is accompanied by a bad return. Compressed air can be used to power
tools and even cars.
~ A cylinder with a diameter of 50 centimetres and a
length of 2 metres has a content of 0,4 cubic metres
~ If this cylinder is filled with compressed air of
200 atmospheres, the potential energy will be almost
as much as the energy content of 1 litre of petrol
(= 9,1 kilowatt-hours)
~ the weight of the compressed air is 100 kilograms
5.2. Potential energy of compressed air
There are 2 possibilities:
1. Compressing air in a fixed volume.
The pressure is determined by the amount of air.
2. Compressing air in an adjustable volume.
The pressure may remain constant.
5.2.1. Compressing air in a fixed volume
For compressing air in a fixed volume one often makes use of underground
spaces such as salt domes and caves. When compressing air heat is created,
while when expanding air it cools. As a result the returns are often bad.
Two forms of compression are possible:
1. Adiabatic compression
There will be no heat exchange with the surroundings
Temperature rises during compression and decreases
at expansion
2. Isothermal compression
Heat exchange does take place with the surroundings
Temperature remains (more or less) constant during
compression and expansion
129
watt-hours
per litre
efficiency of the
storage cycle
12 600
9 100
---
33 600
600
40%
200
300
99%
20
25
80%
80%
130
Energy saving
The largest profits in energy saving can be achieved in the insulation and heating of
the home and in the use of hot water. Followed by the car and finally lighting.
Insulation of the house
Annually an average of 2150 cubic metres of natural gas will be required to heat a
poorly insulated house. A good insulated house does not need more than 700 cubic
metres. So insulation really helps a lot.
Heating of the house
The principle of Combined Heat and Power (CHP) can also be applied in the
heating of a dwelling. A good example of this is the Hee boiler (high efficiency
electric). This boiler contains a hot-air engine that generates electricity. The excess
electricity is delivered back to the grid. The total efficiency is more than 90%. If all
homes should be equipped with such a boiler, then perhaps less electric power
plants would be needed. Because the efficiency of a conventional power plant is
only 40%, large scale application of the Hee boiler might save a significant amount
of energy. Thus a reduction of CO2 emissions might be achieved. A problem
however is, that in summer this system will not work (only for the heating of
water), because then one usually wants cooling rather than heating.
The total installed capacity of electric power plants will therefore probably not be
much smaller. Calculated over the entire year the energy supply of the plants
might be less.
Hot water
The (pre)heating of water can take place using high efficiency (65%) solar
collectors. When showering one can restrict the consumption of hot water a little
by using a water-saving showerhead. Taking a bath once costs 120 litres of water
Showering once takes half as much. (7,5 litres of water per minute, for 8 minutes).
A water saving showerhead consumes 7,5 litres of water per minute, an ordinary
showerhead 8,2 litres. Much saving in energy can be achieved by placing the water
boiler as close as possible near the tap, as well in the kitchen as in the shower. In
many homes a combo boiler is in the attic. That is the worst place imaginable. When
hot water is needed, the long branch to the kitchen or bathroom must be warmed
up before the water on the consumable place gets the desired temperature. After
closing the tap the water cools in the water pipe again, what means pure energy
losses. It also costs a lot of water.
131
Car
One can achieve a considerable saving in fuel by driving a hybrid car. This can save
up to 25%. Of course the only real saving is the abolition of the car. Unfortunately,
public transport is of such poor quality, that this is a difficult step to take. Only an
extreme increase in the petrol price, for example up to 5,- per litre, will have any
effect on the long term, but most people are addicted to their car.
The most fuel-efficient 4-seater car with a petrol engine, and a speed of
100 kilometres per hour can never reach a more economical rate than 1 litre per
40 kilometres. One can calculate this on the basis of the lowest conceivable air
and rolling resistance, combined with the highest conceivable efficiency of a petrol
engine. Consumption of 1 litre per 40 kilometres has been announced for the new
plug-in Prius, which will be launched in 2012. (Apparently one is forgotten that
part of the time this car runs on electricity)
For comparison:
The vehicle on solar energy that won the "World Solar Challenge" in 2007
had a consumption (converted to petrol-equivalent) of 1 litre per 70 kilometres.
This vehicle only has room for 1 person in half reclining posture.
Lighting
Although lighting consumes very little energy, one can save a bit by the consistent
use of energy saving lamps. In the near future also Led lamps will play a role in
energy savings
132
Civilization as we know it today will soon come to an end, because we will run out
of oil. That is a scientifically based conclusion. The oil will not suddenly be gone,
because its production follows a bell-shaped curve. On the ascending side of the
curve cheap oil is available in increasing extent. On the descending side there is less
oil, which is becoming increasingly more expensive. The top of the production
coincides with the point, where half of the oil has been consumed. After the peak,
the production takes off and the costs increase because it is harder to win the oil.
Moreover scarcity has a very strong effect in rising the price. Yet this year (2007)
the world oil consumption will exceed 1000 barrels per second. That equals
86 million barrels per day. (1 barrel = 159 litres)
Suppose that the top of the production has been achieved in the year 2000, Then
as much oil as in 1980 will be produced in 2020. In the meanwhile, the world's
population has been doubled and is furthermore becoming increasingly dependent
on oil. The result is, that the worldwide demand for oil in 2020 will exceed its
production by large. The oil price then will explode to about 400 dollars per barrel.
Oil-dependent economies will collapse and probably wars will break out
The price development of the crude oil
year
1973
3 - 12
1998
10 - 15
2000
24 - 37
2002
20 - 28
2004
30 - 51
2006
58 - 80
2007
53 - 99
2008
32 - 146
2009
32 - 81
2010
67 - 92
2011
75 - 115
2012
77 - 110
2013
86 - 108
2014
53 - 107
2015
34 - 62
2016
26 - 50
133
Meanwhile (2014) the situation on the oil and gas market has changed
completely. The oil price drops
~ In America large stocks of shale gas and oil are
discovered
~ In 2005 America imported 60% of its need for oil.
Now that has fallen to 30% and in time, America
will even export oil
~ It appears that also in Russia, Europe and Asia very
much shale gas and oil will be found
~ The global recession reduces the need for oil
134
135
Green Energy
Green energy obtained from wind, solar, biomass etc. will be of little meaning
provisionally. It is believed this will be up to 14% (in the Netherlands) of (only)
the electricity in 2020. Wind energy is still in an initial state in some countries.
Solar energy is still negligible. One should think of no more than a few thousandths
of the total electricity generation. In 2009, the world production of solar energy
was only 0,1%
Bio Fuel
Large-scale production of bio diesel etc. comes at the expense of the long-term
food production. In addition, it will cost much fossil fuel. This is not a real option.
The conversion of solar energy into bio fuel is accompanied with an extremely low
efficiency, in the order of 1%
Nuclear Energy
Nuclear energy at the current consumption can last for the next 75 years. Before
Uranium has been run out, a solution might be to apply breeder reactors. Then we
would have enough Uranium to carry on for 5000 years. (only for the electricity
generation) If the Uranium has run out, probably one can continue with Thorium.
Thorium can be "burned" completely in simple reactors. This is in contrast to
Uranium, of which only 0,7% can be used. (the isotope U235). In India already
some Thorium reactors are operational. In future Thorium will probably be the
most important nuclear fuel. The amount of Thorium on Earth is 3 times as large
as the amount of Uranium.
Nuclear Fusion
We may expect the first practical results of nuclear fusion around 2050. Then
mankind can have an infinite amount of "clean" energy. The total development time
then has seized about 100 years. One might wonder whether one will ever succeed
in generating very large quantities of energy by means of controlled nuclear fusion.
Until now a technical development has never taken so long. For example,
electricity, radio, (satellite)television, airplane, computer, aerospace, laser, nuclear
energy, hydrogen bomb etc. have all been achieved in a period of some decades,
from an idea to a product that can be used
Hydrogen
Hydrogen can be produced using nuclear energy via a thermo-chemical process or
by electrolysis of water. The necessary electricity for the electrolysis of water must
be generated by nuclear fusion, or by "green" energy. But that is still a long way to
go. Hydrogen is an "unruly" fuel, for which no infrastructure exists. The fuel cell is
still far too expensive and requires much development yet. Hydrogen is not an
energy source, but an energy carrier. Producing hydrogen by electrolysis of water
costs 1,25 times more energy than it delivers
So hydrogen is not a solution to the energy problem
136
137
138
139
Urgenda
Urgenda is a Dutch organisation that aims to make the Netherlands
sustainable faster. On 24 June 2015 the Foundation won a court case
against the Dutch State about the rural climate policy. Through the court
it was enforced that the Dutch state must have reduced greenhouse gas
emissions by the end of 2020. The reduction should be at least 25%
compared to 1990
140
141
Water Example
The water example is often used to make clear what the properties of
electricity are. Suppose the water pipe is capable of supplying (maximum)
10 litres of water per minute through a tap in a bucket.
Then the "power" of the water pipe is 10 litres of water per minute
This power is also present when the tap is closed.
Power is a property
As soon as the tap is fully open, every minute 10 litres of water is flowing into
the bucket. For example, after 5 minutes 50 litres of water have flowed from
the tap. Then the "energy" supplied is 50 litres of water
Energy always generates something, in this example it is water
Energy = power x time
The longer the tap is open, the more "energy" is flowing from it. If one closes
the tap, the "energy supply" stops but the power to provide energy remains.
There cannot be more water in the bucket, than its content permits. The shape
of the bucket is not important. A low bucket with a large diameter may contain
as much water as a high bucket with a small diameter. One can compare a battery
with the bucket. There can be no more energy in the battery than the energy
content permits. Which type is not important. A battery with a low voltage and
high ampere-hours can contain as much energy as a battery with a high voltage
and low ampere-hours.
power
energy
litres
joules
142
143
power
10 watts
5 hours
50 watt-hours
0,01
750 watts
12 minutes
150 watt-hours
0,03
2000 watts
6 minutes
200 watt-hours
0,04
electric blanket
25 watts
8 hours
200 watt-hours
0,04
incandescent lamp
50 watts
5 hours
250 watt-hours
0,05
10 minutes
250 watt-hours
0,05
vacuum cleaner
1500 watts
internet router
12 watts
24 hours
288 watt-hours
0,06
electric bicycle
100 watts
3 hours
300 watt-hours
0,06
flat screen TV
100 watts
3 hours
300 watt-hours
0,06
computer
100 watts
4 hours
400 watt-hours
0,08
steam iron
1000 watts
30 minutes
500 watt-hours
0,10
25 watts
24 hours
600 watt-hours
0,12
180 watts
5 hours
900 watt-hours
0,18
washing machine
1000 watts
1 hour
1000 watt-hours
0,20
dryer
2000 watts
90 minutes
3000 watt-hours
0,60
3000 watts
90 minutes
4500 watt-hours
0,90
air conditioner
1000 watts
12 hours
12000 watt-hours
2,40
hidden consumption
refrigerator
144
Anecdote
During a birthday party I entered into conversation with a middle-aged lady The
conversation soon went to trains and cars. "Did You come here by train?"
she asked with an expression of disbelief and horror on her face. When I said that
in the long term, we will run out of petrol, she suddenly became very aggressive.
Her reaction was: "but you cannot suppose that I will stop driving my car?"
(so even if the petrol has gone !?)
The most horrible stories about public transport are always told by people who
never use it.
145
A book on energy
"Sustainable Energy without the hot air
This book gives a complete overview of the (imp)possibilities of sustainable energy
Author: David MacKay, professor at the University of Cambridge. Read especially
chapter 19: "Every BIG helps"
Some quotes from the book:
~ if everyone does a little, we'll achieve only a little
~ is the population of the Earth six times too big?
~ any sane discussion of sustainable energy requires numbers
This book also mentions an interview with Tony Blair (4 children) in response to
his position in 2006 on the energy problematic
Tony Blair:
"Unless we act now, not in some distant time, but now these consequences,
disastrous as they are, will be irreversible. So there is nothing more serious,
more urgent or more demanding of leadership."
Interviewer:
Have you thought or perhaps not flying to Barbados for a holiday and not using
all those air miles?
Tony Blair:
I would, frankly, be reluctant to give up my holidays abroad
Interviewer:
It would send out a clear message though wouldn't it, if we didn't see that great
big air journey off to the sunshine? a holiday closer to home?
Tony Blair:
Yeah but I personally think these things are a bit impractical to actually
expect people to do that. I think that what we need to do is to look at how you
make air travel more energy efficient, how you develop the new fuels that will
allow us to burn less energy and emit less. How for example in the new frames
for the aircraft, they are far more energy efficient. I know everyone always people
probably think the Prime Minister shouldn't go on holiday at all, but I think if
what we do in this area is set people unrealistic targets, you know if we say to
people we're going to cancel all the cheap air travel - You know, I'm still waiting
for the first politician who's actually running for office who's going to come out
and say it and they're not.
146