Selection of Ball Screws 1
Selection of Ball Screws 1
Selection of Ball Screws 1
Basic ball screw selection procedure and required evaluation items are shown below.
Determine the application parameters
Moving mass, feed speed, motion pattern, screw shaft rotational speed, stroke,
mounting orientation (horizontal or vertical), life, positioning accuracy
Axial clearance does not affect positioning accuracy if the feed is unidirectional, but will generate backlash and negatively affect on positioning accuracy if the
direction or the axial load is reversed.
QTable 4. Axial Clearances of Rolled Ball Screws
Types
P.3483 3484
8
10
12
P.3485
Standard Nut
Accuracy Grade C7
15
BSST
25
Life
Confirm that the ball screw satisfies the life requirement.
NG
20
P.3487
If higher positioning accuracy and/or improved responsiveness is needed, below parameters need to be evaluated.
Screw shaft rigidity
P.3488
Effects of temperature variation on life
P.3488
10
12
14
Ball screw lead accuracy is defined by JIS Standards property parameters (ep, vu, v300, v2).
Parameter definitions and allowable values are shown below.
In general, a ball screw lead accuracy grade is selected by evaluating if the Actual Mean Travel Error of a candidate is within the allowable positioning error.
Standard Nut
Accuracy Grade C10
QTable 1. Positioning Screw (C Class) Actual Mean Travel Error (ep) and Variation (u) allowances
Effective Thread Length ( lu )
over
0
0
V300
Travel Error
ep
Vu
V2
300mm
or less
315
400
500
630
800
1000
1250
1600
315
400
500
630
800
1000
1250
Unit : m
Accuracy Grade
C3
C5
Actual Mean
Actual Mean
Variation
Variation
Travel Error
Travel Error
12
8
23
18
13
10
25
20
15
10
27
20
16
12
30
23
18
13
35
25
21
15
40
27
24
16
46
30
29
18
54
35
Accuracy Grade
C3
Symbols
Meaning
ep
Variation
vu
v
v
300
2
Specified
Travel
ls
Specified
Travel Target
Value
Actual Travel
la
Actual Mean
Travel
lm
The maximum difference of the actual travel contained between two lines drawn
parallel to the actual mean travel, and is defined by three parameters below.
Variation for the effective thread length of screw shaft.
Variation for an arbitrarily taken length of 300mm within the effective thread length of screw shaft.
Variation for an arbitrary one revolution (2rad) taken within the effective thread length of screw shaft.
Axial travel compensated for temperature rise and loading
conditions, in relation to the Nominal Travel (Lead).
A value that is Nominal Travel subtracted from Specified Travel, over the effective thread length.
This value is set to compensate for possible screw shaft expansion and contraction due to
temperature changes and applied loads. The value is to be determined based on experiments
or experiences.
Actually measured travel distance
A straight line representing the actual travel trend.
A straight line obtained by the least-squares method or other
approximation methods from the curve representing the actual
travel.
25
28
32
8
10
12
Compact Nut
Accuracy Grade C10
BSSC
V300
V2
V300
V2
Standard Values
18
Accuracy Grade
Ct7
Ct10
V300
52
210
EActual Mean Travel Error (ep) for Transfer Screws (Ct Class) is calculated as ep=2Lu/300V300
15
20
C5
Parameters
15
20
QTable 2. Positioning Screws (C Class) variation per 300mm (300) Variation per rotation (2) standard values Unit : m
QTable 3. Transfer Screw (Ct Class) variation per 300mm (300) Standards Unit : m
Terms
BSSZ
BSSR
Block Nut
Accuracy Grade C10
BSBR
25
15
20
25
15
20
25
Lead
2
4
4
5
10
20
5
10
20
5
10
2
4
2
4
10
4
10
5
5
10
20
5
10
20
5
10
25
6
10
32
2
2
4
5
10
5
10
5
Types
0.03 or less
Standard Nut
Accuracy Grade C3
BSX
10
12
15
8
0.05 or less
0.03 or less
10
0.07 or less
12
0.05 or less
Standard Nut
Accuracy Grade C5
BSS
(BSL)
15
0.10 or less
20
0.15 or less
25
0.10 or less
0.20 or less
0.12 or less
0.10 or less
0.20 or less
0.15 or less
0.05 or less
8
10
12
Standard Nut
Accuracy Grade C7
BSSE
0.10 or less
15
20
25
Lead
1
1
2
2
2
5
5
2
2
4
10
2
4
5
10
5
10
20
40
5
10
20
40
5
10
20
2
2
4
2
5
10
5
10
20
5
10
20
10
20
Axial Clearance
(mm)
0
(Preloaded)
0.005 or less
0.010 or less
0.005 or less
0.030 or less
5
0.10 or less
10
<Requirements>
Ball screw diameter 15, lead 20.
Stroke 720mm
Positioning accuracy 0.05mm/720mm
<Requirements>
Ball screw diameter 15, lead 5.
Allowable backlash 0.01mm
<Selection Details>
Select an appropriate lead accuracy grade based on the application requirements.
<Selection Details>
From Table 5., it can be determined that C5 grade with 0.005mm or less axial clearance
satisfies the allowable backlash amount of 0.01mm for the 15 group.
3483
3484
[Technical Data]
Allowable Axial Load is a load with a safety margin built-in against a shaft bucking load.
Axial load that applies to a ball screw needs to be less than Allowable Maximum Axial Load.
Allowable Axial Load can be obtained by the following formula.
Additionally, approximate Allowable Axial Load can be obtained from Table 1. Allowable Axial Load Graph.
Ball screw rotational speed is determined by required feed speed and the given screw lead, and needs to be less than the Allowable Maximum Rotational Speed.
Ball screw rotational speed is evaluated based on the shaft's critical speed and ball recirculation speed limitation DmN value.
P=
n 2EI
2
d4
10 4(N)
2
=m
Where:
P: Allowable Axial Load (N)
: Distance between Points of Buckling Load (mm)
E: Young's Modulus (2.06105N/mm2)
I: Min. Geometrical Moment of Inertia of Across Root Thread Area (mm4)
I=
d4
64
<How to use>
Thread shaft diameter 15, Lead 5
Mounting method Fixed - Support
Distance between Points of Buckling Load 1 820mm
Screw Shaft Root Diameter d 12.5
<Calculations>
g=15.1 since the mounting method is Fixed-Supported,
the Allowable Rotational Speed (Nc) is,
n
1
2
4
0.25
P= m
m
5
10
19.9
1.2
12.5 4
d 4
10 4 = 10
10 4 = 3630(N)
820 2
2
N c =fa
60 2
2 2
Table.1
A=
d2
4
g, : Coefficient Determined by Method of Screw Support
1.5
1.5
10
8
Lead (N)
10
8
6
5
4
3
2
1.5
3
10
8
6
5
4
3
1.5
5
10
8
1.5
1.5
4
10
8
6
5
4
10
8
32
6
5
4
6
5
4
3
6
5
4
10
<Calculations>
(1) Find the intersection between a distance of 500mm between
load acting points and the axial load of 10000daN(from the
fixed-support graduation).[Figure 1]
25
20
(2) Read the shaft diameter of the diagonal line nearest to the
intersection on the outside. The shaft diameter can be a min.
15mm.
15
2
1.5
10
10
3
2
1.5
10 3
8
6
5
4
3
2
1.5
2
10000N 6
10
8
6
5
4
6
5
4
1.5
10
3
2
1.5
10
1.5
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1.5
d
12.5
Nc= g 2 10 7(min -1) = 15.1
10 7(min -1) = 3024(min -1)
790 2
l
g
9.7
15.1
21.9
3.4
3.927
4.73
1.875
<Requirements>
Distance between Points of Buckling Load 500mm
Mounting method Fixed - Support
the max. axial load 10000N
1.5
<Calculations>
g=15.1 since the mounting method is Fixed-Supported,
the Allowable Rotational Speed (Nc) is,
6
5
4
<How to use>
Thread shaft diameter 15, Lead 5
Mounting method Fixed - Support
Distance between Points of Buckling Load 1 790mm
Where:
: Distance of Supports (mm)
fa: Safety Factor (0.8)
E: Young's Modulus (2.06105N/mm2)
I: Min. Geometrical Moment of Inertia of Across Root Thread Area (mm4)
I=
d4
64
d: Thread Root Diameter (mm)
: Specific Gravity (7.8106kg/mm3)
EI10 3
d
= g 2 10 7 (min 1)
5 6 7
10
8
Fixed-Free
2
1.5
10
1.5
10
8
6
5
4
10
6
5
4
8
6
5
4
3
3
2
1.5
10 3
8
10 3
8
6
5
4
1.5
6
5
4
3
2
1.5
10 2
8
6
5
Fixed-Fixed
6
5
4
15
20
25
32
<Calculations>
(1) From Table 2., find a intersection of a vertical line from Supported Span Distance
1500mm and Screw Shaft O.D. 20 line.
(2) The value 1076min-1 on the Fixed-Supported scale (Y-Axis) that corresponds to the
intersection of (1) above is the Allowable Maximum Speed.
Screw Shaft Dia. Calculation Example
<Requirements>
Distance of Supports 2000mm
Maximum Revolution Frequency 1000min-1
the max. axial load Fixed - Fixed
3
2
3
2
<Requirements>
Thread outer diameter 20
Distance of Supports 1500mm
Mounting method Fixed - Support
1.5
10 3
8
10
1.5
1.5
10 2
8
10 2
8
6
5
4
6
5
4
<Calculations>
(1) From Table 2., find a intersection of a vertical line from Supported Span Distance
2000mm and a horizontal line from Fixed-Fixed max. speed scale (Y-Axis) at
1000min-1.
(2) A line that reaches down to the intersection in (1) is the 25 ball screw that
satisfies the required speed of 1000min-1.
3
2 2
10 1.5 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 103 1.5 2
4 5 6 7
3485
Ball Dia.
1.5875
2.3812
3.175
4.7625
6.35
A Value
0.3
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.8
3486
[Technical Data]
Ball screw's life is defined as: Total number of rotations, time, or distance where either the ball rolling surfaces or the balls begin to exhibit repetitive stress caused
flaking. Ball screw's life can be calculated based on Basic Dynamic Load Rating with the following formula.
6-1. Life Hours (Lh)
L h=
10 6
60N m
) (hrs)
C
P mf w
Where:
Lh: Life Span Hours (hrs)
C: Basic Dynamic Load Rating (N)
Pm: Mean Axial Load (N)
Nm: Mean Revolution Frequency (min1)
fw: Work Factor
Impactless Run
fw = 1.0~1.2
Normal Run
fw = 1.2~1.5
Run with Impact
fw = 1.5~2.0
Fixed
BSS1520(15 Lead 5)
250N
2118 (min-1)
1.2
<Calculations>
Since Basic Dynamic Load Rating C for BSS1520 is 4400N,
4400
Fixed
Supported
= 24824(hr)
Fixed
Fixed
Fixed
Fixed
K=
(N/m)
Where:
P: Axial Loads Applied on Feed Screw System (daN)
: Elastic Deformation of Feed Screw System (m)
Additionally, the following relationship exists between the feed screw system rigidity
and other various construction element rigidity.
1
1
1
1
1
=
+
+
+
Kn
Kb
Kh
K
K
Where:
K: Screw Shaft Compressive/Tensile Rigidity
Kn: Nut Rigidity
Kb: Support Bearing Rigidity
Kh: Nut and Bearing Mount Rigidity
Screw Shaft Compressive/Tensile Rigidity : K
Fixed
K =
*The basic dynamic load rating that satisfies the set life span hours is expressed by
the following formula.
60L h N m
10 6
Medium Speeds
High Accuracy
F or Support Units,
Standard Type BRW is
selected.
*Setting life span hours longer than what is actually necessary not only requires a
larger ball screw, but also increases the price.
In general, the following standards are used for life span hours:
Machine Tools:20,000hrs
Automatic Control Equipment:15,000hrs
Industrial Machinery:10,000hrs
Measuring Instruments:15,000hrs
C=
Typical method
Medium ~ High Speeds
Medium ~High Accuracy
For Support Units,
Standard Type BRW /
BUR is selected.
2501.2
Application Example
<Requirements>
Ball Screw Model
Mean Axial Load Pm
Mean Revolution Frequency Nm
Work Factor fw
106
Lh =
602118
9. Rigidity
Free
Low Speeds
For Short Screw Shafts
Medium Accuracy
For Support Units,
Economy Type BRWE
is selected
(N/m)
Where:
P: Axial Load (N)
: Screw Shaft Expansion/Contraction (m)
The expansion and contraction are expressed in the following formula. The expansion
and contraction will directly appear as ball screw backlash.
(1) Fixed-Free Arrangement
P m f w (N)
Fixed
C=ftC(N)
C 0 =ft'C 0 (N)
125
150
175
200
225
250
350
ft
1.0
0.95
0.90
0.85
0.75
0.65
0.60
0.50
ft'
1.0
0.93
0.85
0.78
0.65
0.52
0.46
0.35
4P
10 3(m)
Ed 2
Where:
P: Axial Load (N)
5
2
E: Young's Modulus (2.06x10
Fixed N/mm )
d: Screw Shaft Root Diameter (mm)
: Load Applicable Span Distance (mm)
(2) Fixed-Fixed Arrangement
ENormal usage range is -20~80C. For application in high temperature, use of heat
resistant grease as well as heat resistivity of other components should be evaluated.
6-3. Formulae for Average Axial Load and Average Rotational Speed
Average Axial Load and Average Rotational Speed are calculated based on
proportions of motion profiles.
Average Axial Load and Average Rotational Speed for Motion profiles in Table 1.
can be calculated with the formula 2.
[Table 1. Motion Profile]
P1N
P2N
P3N
A
B
C
t1%
t2%
t3%
P 1 3N 1 t 1 +P 2 3N 2 t 2 +P 3 3N 3 t 3
P m=
N 1 t 1 +N 2 t 2 +N 3 t 3
(N)
N 1 t 1 +N 2 t 2 +N 3 t 3
N m=
(min 1)
t 1 +t 2 +t 3
For case of a machine tool application, Max. Load (P1) would be for the heaviest
cutting cycles, Regular Load (P2) is for the general cutting conditions, and Minimum
Load (P3) is for the non-cutting rapid feeds during positioning moves.
3487
Axial Load
Rotational
Speed
Hours
Ratio
A
B
C
343N
10N
324N
1500min
3000min
1500min
29.4%
41.2%
29.4%
Where:
P: Axial Load(N)
E: Young's Modulus (2.06x105N/mm2)
d: Screw Shaft Root Diameter (mm)
,: Load Applicable Span Distance (mm)
L: Mounting Span Distance (mm)
<Calculations>
(1) Average Axial Load
Pm =
15000.294+30000.412+15000.294
15000.294+30000.412+15000.294
0.294+0.412+0.294
= 250(N)
PL
10 3
Ed 2
L
2
Therefore, the max. shaft expansion and contraction will be 1/4 of Fixed-Free
arrangement.
,
4P
10 3(m)
Ed 2L
<Requirements>
Motion
Profile
Fixed
Hours Ratio
N1min-1
N2min-1
N3min-1
(t1+t2+t3=100%)
Fixed
Fixed
Motion
Profile
Free
= 2118(min-1)
3488
[Technical Data]
T 1=
1 tan
1+/tan
1/tan
1+ tan
PL
+T P
2
Z 1
Z 2
Work Piece
F
W
10 (N cm)
2
PL
(3P LP)
+T P
2
3P L
Z1
2 N
+J M
10 3(Ncm)
Z2
60t
Where:
TM: Total Torque Exerted on the Motor Output Thread (Ncm)
T1: Driving Torque at Constant Speed (Ncm)
T2: Driving Torque at In Acceleration (Ncm)
Once you have temporarily found the type of motor you need, check
1. effective torque,
Ball Screw J3
3489
3. motor overload properties and heat tolerance during repeated starting, stopping.
Gear J2
Z2
Pinion J1
Z1
720mm
0.15
0.57
0.15 0.53
0.9
0.93=2.7
Couplings
Start-up Motor
1000mm/s
s
Distance between Load Acting Points (Buckling Load:Fixed-Fixed) 1
1.4
Set lead based on maximum motor revolutions and threading speed. Use the following formula.
Table
J=
D 4 (kg cm 2)
32
Where:
D: Cylinder Outer Diameter (cm)
: Cylinder Length (cm)
: Material Specific Gravity
3
3
=7.810
)
(kg/cm
L 2
J 5=M 2 (kg cm2)
T M= T 1+T 2=
Work
W=50(kg)
Smax.=720(mm)
Vmax.=1000(mm/s)
t=0.15(s)
0.1/720(mm)
0.01(mm)
Lh=30000Hours
=0.02
Nmax.=3000(min1)
4.1(1Cycle)
Condition of Use
Work & Table Mass
Maximum Strokes
Threading Speed
Acceleration Constant
Positioning Precision
Repeat Accuracy
Life Span
Direct Acting Guide Coefficient of Friction
Driving Motor
Duty Cycle Model Diagram
240mm(Stroke)
V
mm/s
(N cm)
Where: P 3PL
T1: Driving Torque at Constant Speed (Ncm)
P: External Axial Load (N)
P=F+Mg
F: Thrust Reaction Produced in Cutting Force (N)
M: Masses of Table and Work Piece (kg)
: Coefficient of Friction on Sliding Surfaces
g: Gravitational Acceleration (9.8m/s2)
L: Ball Screw Lead (cm)
: Mechanical Efficiency of Ball Screw or Gear
TP: Friction Torque Caused by Preloading (Ncm) Referto Formula 10-2-(3)
PL: Preload (N)
Z1: Number of Pinion's Teeth
Z2: No. of Gear's Teeth
T 2= J M = J M
(3P LP)
3P L
Vmax60
100060
=
= 20
Nmax
3000
3. Accuracy Evaluation
2. Nut selection
* The Margin is provided as a countermeasure in case overruns, and the amount is typically set as
1.5~2 times the screw lead.
Lead 201.52(Ends)=60
(3) Summary of Axial Loads, Rotational Speeds, and Operation Time for Each Motion Profile
Operating Pattern
In Acceleration
At Constant Speed
Axial Load
343N
10N
Revolutions Frequency
Operating Time Ratio
1500min
29.4%
In Deceleration
324N
3000min
41.2%
1500min1
29.4%
(4) Calculating the Average Axial Load with a formula in P.3487, 6-3.
Mean Axial Load(Pm)=
P 1 3N 1 t 1 +P 2 3N 2 t 2 +P 3 3N 3 t 3
N 1 t 1 +N 2 t 2 +N 3 t 3
N 1 t 1 +N 2 t 2 +N 3 t 3
Mean Turns (Nm)=
=2118(min-1)
t 1 +t 2 +t 3
(6) Calculation of the required basic dynamic load rating
(1) Calculating Continuous Operational Life (Lho)
A Continuous Operational Life which is derived by subtracting Resting time from Desired Life
while a motion profile of 4.01s with a moving time of 2.04s can be calculated as follows.
2.04
Lho=Desired Life (Lh)
=14927 (Hours)
4.1
(2) Calculating Required Basic Dynamic Load Rating
P.3487 6-1. contains a formula for calculating a Basic Dynamic Load Rating for
continuous operational life.
60L hoN m
60149272118
C=
P mf w=
2501.2=3700(N)
10 6
10 6
d4
2
104=10
12.54
820 2
104=3660N
The above formula produces an Axial Load value of 343N which is well within the Allowable Max.
Axial Load 3660N, and suitability is confirmed.
=250(N)
P=m
Nc=g
d
2
107=15.1
12.5
7902
107=3024min-1
The max. speed requirement of 3000min-1 is within the Critical Speed of 3024min-1, and the
suitability is confirmed.
Additionally, the DmN value can be evaluated with the formula in P.3486, "5-2. DmN Value" as...
DmN=(Shaft O.D.+A value)Max Rotational Speed=15.83000=4740070000
and the suitability is confirmed.
5. Selection Result
From the above, it is determined that a suitable ball screw model is BSS1520-914.
Motors
3490