The document describes research on designing and analyzing a riser for a sand casting to eliminate shrinkage cavities. It discusses parameters for optimal riser design using Caine's method and analyzes the designed casting and riser model using ANSYS simulation software. The simulation identifies the hot spot location inside the casting and determines that increasing the riser diameter shifts the hot spot into the riser, filling the shrinkage cavity and improving casting yield.
The document describes research on designing and analyzing a riser for a sand casting to eliminate shrinkage cavities. It discusses parameters for optimal riser design using Caine's method and analyzes the designed casting and riser model using ANSYS simulation software. The simulation identifies the hot spot location inside the casting and determines that increasing the riser diameter shifts the hot spot into the riser, filling the shrinkage cavity and improving casting yield.
The document describes research on designing and analyzing a riser for a sand casting to eliminate shrinkage cavities. It discusses parameters for optimal riser design using Caine's method and analyzes the designed casting and riser model using ANSYS simulation software. The simulation identifies the hot spot location inside the casting and determines that increasing the riser diameter shifts the hot spot into the riser, filling the shrinkage cavity and improving casting yield.
The document describes research on designing and analyzing a riser for a sand casting to eliminate shrinkage cavities. It discusses parameters for optimal riser design using Caine's method and analyzes the designed casting and riser model using ANSYS simulation software. The simulation identifies the hot spot location inside the casting and determines that increasing the riser diameter shifts the hot spot into the riser, filling the shrinkage cavity and improving casting yield.
International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management
Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 176
DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF RISER FOR SAND CASTING C. M. Choudhari, Nikhil S. Dalal, Akshay P. Ghude 1 , Pratik P. Sankhe, Ashutosh M.Dhotre Mechanical Department, Fr.C.Rodrigues Insitute of Technology, Vashi, Navi Mumbai, India 1 [email protected] Abstract Casting is one of the earliest metals shaping method known to human beings. It is one of the cheapest methods for mass production of any part and can be effectively used to make complex shaped parts which are not easy to manufacture by other production process. Casting process is subjected to many defects and it is necessary to eliminate them. One of the main defects in castings is Shrinkage Cavity, which can be eliminated by attaching a Riser to the casting. This paper describes the parameters to be considered while designing a Riser of an optimum size to get higher Casting Yield. Theoretically designed model has been analyzed thermally in ANSYS 12.0 simulation software to ensure that shrinkage cavity is completely eliminated from casting. I. INTRODUCTION ASTING is a metal shaping process by pouring the molten metal into a mould and allowing it to solidify. The resulting product can virtually have any configuration (pattern) the designer wants. Casting consists of various parts like cope, drag, pattern, sprue, runner, ingates, riser, etc. The process consists of design, solidification, shake out, finishing and heat treatment. Although casting is one of the cheapest methods it is associated with many defects like shrinkage cavity (hot spot), cold shuts, misrun, etc. In order to understand how a shrinkage cavity develops consider a mould of cube. Figure (a) shows a cube which is completely filled with liquid metal. As the time progresses, metal starts loosing heat through all the sides and as a result starts freezing from all the sides, equally trapping the liquid metal inside, as in figure (b). But further solidification and subsequent volumetric shrinkage and metal contraction due to change in temperature causes formation of void, as shown in figure (c). The solidification when complete, finally results in shrinkage cavity, as in figure (d). An optimal design of riser will help in reducing hot spots formation/ void formation/ shrinkage cavity by ensuring that molten metal can readily flow into the casting when the need arises. To eliminate the defect of hot spot riser is used in casting. It helps to fill in the cavity formed inside the casting. C
www.giapj
Whenever fills the ca the riser s The main of heat co its surface II. O The forma to increas of hot spo it is desire The main time as co until solid III. T Initially f rectangula
journals.com r the cavity is avity. In orde solidifies after n parameter th ontent in a sys e area [2] . Cast OBJECTIVE ation of hot s se the yield of ot from the ca ed. objective of ompared to c dification of th THEORETIC for the case ar plate of alu Fig s formed insid er to achieve t r the casting. hat controls th stem is determ ting modulus
spot inside the f the casting i asting. Riser w our project is casting. This he casting is c CAL STUDY study a simp uminium. The International g. 1.Formatio de the casting this, the dime he solidificati mined by its v is a ratio of v e casting is a it is necessary will ensure th s to design a r will ensure th completed. Y ple casting w e size of the p l Journal of St on of shrinka g the molten m ensions of the ion time of a volume & the volume of a c a major defect y to optimize hat the molten riser having h hat metal wil was designed plate is 200mm tudents Resear age cavity [1]. metal from th riser should b casting is the e rate at whic casting to its s t in metals lik riser design n metal will m higher value m ll remain in t with its vari m 200mm rch in Technol Vol 1(2), Ap he riser move be optimum s e casting mod ch it loses hea surface area. ke aluminum which will al move into the modulus that i the molten sta ious parts. C 40 mm as sh logy & Manag ril 2013, pg 17 Pag
es to that spac so that the me dulus. The am at is determin
and steel. In lso ensure rem e casting whe is, of solidific ate inside the asting is a s hown in figur gement 76-191 ge 177 ce and etal in mount ned by order moval enever cation e riser imple re. International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 178
Fig. 2.Geometry of Casting For design of patter following allowances were considered: Shrinkage allowance [3] : For 200 mm: 2.6 mm For 40 mm: 0.52 mm Draft allowance = 1.5 (on vertical sides only) Machining allowance = 2 mm on each side Tolerance = 1 mm
Details regarding the model: Total surface area = 120835.92 mm 2 Total volume = 1848597.301 mm 3
Modulus = 15.29 mm. Solidification time = 14.36 min. Weight of the casting = 4.4089 kg
Design of gating system: Pouring time =17.363 sec Choke area = 98.46 mm 2
Sprue bottom diameter = 12 mm Sprue top diameter = 15 mm Sprue height = 42.5 mm Total area of ingates= 452.38 mm 2 International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 179
The design of riser was done using Caines method [1]. The height of riser was assumed to be 70 mm and the height of riser neck was assumed to be 10 mm. Following formulae were used for finding the dimensions of casting. Volume of the riser = r 2 h Surface area = r 2 +2rh Freezing ratio (X) = (A c / V c ) / (A r / V r ) Where, A c = Area of casting V c = Volume of casting A r = Surface area of riser V r = Volume of riser Y = V r / V c
X = ((a) / (Y-b))-c For aluminium: a=0.1 b=0.03 c=1 The riser diameter by Caines method is 55.244 mm. For actual practice, Riser Diameter, D r = 60 mm. According to a research paper on optimum design of riser [8] , D n = 0.35 D r
Yield of feeder = (V c ) / (V c +V f +V n ) = 90.176 % Yield of casting = (W c )/ (W g + W f ) = 82.18 % Where, W c = weight of casting W g = weight of gating elements W f = weight of feeding elements IV. SIMULATION Simulation of casting was done to serve two main purposes. First, it was used to find the location of hot spot. Second, it was used to find the optimum dimension of riser so that hot spot shifted into the riser [4] . The effect of sleeve and air gap was also studied using simulation. These studies were done using both linear and quadratic elements and both free and mapped mesh was used. The following properties were used for sand during the entire simulation: International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 180
TABLE I PROPERTIES OF SAND Conductivity 0.519 W/m K Specific Heat 1172.304 J/kg K Density 1495 kg/m 3
The following properties were used for aluminium during the entire simulation:
TABLE II PROPERTIES OF ALUMINIUM
A. Identification of Hot Spot The top view of the casting was simulated in ANSYS 12 software. At the end of simulation the last solidifying region was obtained. 1) Simulation using Linear Elements For this study, PLANE 55 was used as the linear element. PLANE55 can be used as a plane element or as an axisymmetric ring element with a 2-D thermal conduction capability. The element has four nodes with a single degree of freedom, temperature, at each node. The top view was modeled for free and mapped mesh as shown in the figure.
Temperature Conductivity [6] Enthalpy [7] 273K 234.43 W/m K 0 J/m 3
820K 216.01 W/m K 1.5533 109 J/m 3
933K 90.975 W/m K 1.7769 109 J/m 3
1043K 94.786 W/m K 2.0574 109 J/m 3
International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 181
Fig. 3.Modeling of Casting with Free Mesh.
Fig. 4.Modeling of Casting with Mapped Mesh. International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 182
Then, the material properties were specified followed by meshing of geometries. The meshed geometries with free and mapped mesh are shown below.
Fig.5 Free Mesh of Casting
Fig. 6 Mapped Mesh of Casting International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 183
After meshing, convective load was applied on the outer boundaries of the casting. The ambient temperature was assumed to be 303 K. The initial temperature of molten aluminium was assumed 1043 K and the initial temperature of sand was assumed to be 303 K. The temperature time plot of various nodes for free and mapped mesh was obtained as shown below:
Fig. 7. Temperature Time Plot for Free Mesh
Fig. 8. Temperature Time Plot for Mapped Mesh
International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 184
The animation was run for 1 hour and the location of hotspot for free and mapped mesh was obtained as shown below:
Fig. 9. Location of Hot Spot in Free Mes
Fig. 10. Location of Hot Spot in Mapped Mesh 2) Simulation using Quadratic Elements For this, study PLANE 77 and PLANE 35 were used as the quadratic elements. Same steps were followed for simulation using quadratic elements. The results obtained after the simulation showed that the minimum temperature in the entire casting drops below ambient temperature. International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 185
Fig. 11. Temperature Time Graph for PLANE 77 element
Fig. 12. Temperature Time Graph for PLANE 35 element
This is not possible as the minimum temperature specified during simulation was ambient temperature. Consequently, these results were not taken into account during further simulations.
International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 186
B. Finding Optimum Riser Dimensions Once, the location of hot spot was identified, the next objective was to find the optimum riser dimensions. For this purpose, following dimensions of riser were considered. TABLE III RISER DIMENSIONS Sr. No. Riser Diameter Riser Height Neck Diameter Neck Height 1 30 mm 70 mm 10.5 mm 10 mm 2 40 mm 70 mm 14 mm 10 mm 3 50 mm 70 mm 17.5 mm 10 mm 4 60 mm 70 mm 21 mm 10 mm
The above risers were first modeled in ANSYS. These models were then meshed using PLANE 55 element and free mesh. The animation of these models yielded the following results.
Fig. 13. Location of Hot Spot for Riser with Diameter 30
Fig. 14. Location of Hot Spot for Riser with Diameter 40 International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 187
Fig. 15. Location of Hot Spot for Riser with Diameter 50
Fig. 16. Location of Hot Spot for Riser with Diameter 60 It is clear from the above figures that the hot spot shifts into the riser for diameter of 60 mm. C.Effect of Sleeve on Riser Diameter An insulating sleeve was used around the riser to slow down the rate of transfer of heat from the riser. A sleeve of 5 mm thickness was used around the riser of 50 mm diameter. The result of this simulation is shown below:
International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 188
Fig. 17. Location of Hot Spot for Riser with Sleeve
As seen from the above figure, sleeve helps in maintaining the riser hot for a longer time. As a result, a riser of diameter 50 mm can be used instead of 60mm. this helps in increasing the casting yield. D. Effect of Air Gap The modeling of air gap in casting was done as follows:
Fig. 18 Modeling of Air Gap After the modeling was completed the casting was meshed using free mesh. An air gap is formed only after aluminium solidifies. As aluminium solidifies at 933 K, the simulation was run from 933 K. The temperature time plot for various nodes was obtained as shown below: International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 189
Fig. 19. Temperature Time Plot for Casting with Air Gap From the above graph, it is seen that the maximum temperature at the end of simulation is 737.711 K. For comparison, a similar model without air gap was made and the simulation was run from 933 K. The temperature time plot for various obtained is as follows:
Fig. 20. Temperature Time Plot for Casting without Air Gap International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 190
From the above graph, it is seen that the maximum temperature at the end of simulation is 716.708 K.
V. ACTUAL TRIALS The values obtained from theoretical calculations for design of pattern, gating system & riser were used to manufacture casting. The casting having riser diameter equal to 60 mm was found to be defect free. Also a defect free casting was obtained when a sleeve of 50mm diameter was used.
Fig. 21 Plate casting VI. CONCLUSION ANSYS is a good tool to carry out solidification simulation. The optimized Riser dimensions were validated by simulation results and actual trials. Using sleeve as a feed aid helped in reducing riser dimensions there by increasing the Casting Yield. Simulation using other Thermal Solid MID-SIDE NODE Elements (Plane-35 & Plane 77) yielded absurd results & thus cannot be used for Transient Thermal Analysis in ANSYS. Results of Simulation of casting solidification with air gap between Sand & Metal prove that air acts as an insulator for heat transfer, but the effect can be neglected as there is no appreciable difference between the simulation results when air gap was not considered. REFERENCES [1] P.N.Rao, Manufacturing Technology, Tata McGraw-Hill Education, New Delhi, 2008. [2] John Campbell and Richard A Harding, Solidification Defects in Casting, IRC in Materials, The University of Birmingham. [3] PSG College of technology, Design Data Book, PSG College of Technology, Coimbatore, 2005. International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management Vol 1(2), April 2013, pg 176-191
www.giapjournals.com Page 191
[4] Dr. Mohammad Al-Tahat, Metal Casting and Foundry, Jordan University, course no. 906412. [5] D. Joshi and B Ravi, Classification and Simulation based Design 3D Junctions in Castings, American Foundry Society, 2008. [6] C.Y. Ho, R.W.Powell and P.E.Liley (1972) , J. Phy. Chem. Ref. Data, vl. [7] B.J. McBride, S. Gordon and M.A.Reno (1993), NASA Technical Paper 3287. [8] T. Nandi, R. Behera, S. Kayal, A. Chanda and G. Sutradhar, Optimization of Riser size of Aluminium alloy (LM6) castings by using conventional method and computer simulation technique, International Journal Of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 2, Issue 11, November-2011