Report On Just in Time and Lean Manufacuring
Report On Just in Time and Lean Manufacuring
Report On Just in Time and Lean Manufacuring
INTRODUCTION
Just in time (JIT) is a management philosophy that strives to eliminate sources of manufacturing waste by producing the right part in the right place at the right time. Waste results from any activity, which adds cost without adding value, such as moving and storing. JIT (also known as stockless production) should improve profits and return on investment by reducing inventory levels (increasing the inventory turnover rate), improving product quality, reducing production and delivery lead times, and reducing other costs (such as those associated with machine setup and equipment breakdown). The idea of producing the necessary units in the necessary quantities at the necessary time is described by the short term Just-in-time. Just-in-time means, for example, that in the process of assembling the parts to build a car, the necessary kind of sub-assemblies of the preceding processes should arrive at the product line at the time needed in the necessary quantities. If Just-in-time is realized in the entire firm, then unnecessary inventories in the factory will be completely eliminated, making stores or warehouses unnecessary. The inventory carrying costs will be diminished, and the ratio of capital turnover will be increased. The implementation of this management philosophy in industries like the automobile industry can bring about a see saw change in both quality & quantity since in a JIT system, underutilized (excess) capacity is used instead of buffer inventories to hedge against problems that may arise. JIT applies primarily to repetitive manufacturing processes in which the same products and components are produced over and over again. The general idea is to establish flow processes (even when the facility uses a jobbing or batch process layout) by linking work centers so that there is an even, balanced flow of materials throughout the entire production process, similar to that found in an assembly line. To accomplish this, an attempt is made to reach the goals of driving all queues toward zero and achieving the ideal lot size of one unit. This new trend in engineering production, which originally refers to the production of goods to meet customer demand exactly, in time, quality and quantity, reduces wastage by nearly 55-75%. "Waste" in this context is taken in its most general sense and includes time and resources as well as goods. This concept can really change the phase of industrial production of goods like car & other important utilities.
Lean Manufacturing can be defined as a systematic approach to identifying and eliminating waste (non-value-added activities) through continuous improvement by flowing the product at the pull of the customer in pursuit of perfection. The term lean manufacturing is a more generic term and refers to the general principles and further developments of becoming lean. The term lean is very apt because in lean manufacturing the emphasis is on cutting out FAT or wastes in manufacturing process. Waste is defined as anything that does not add any value to the product. It could be defined as anything the customer is not willing to pay for. Manufacturing philosophy is pivoted on designing a manufacturing system that perfectly blends together the fundamentals of minimizing costs and maximizing profit. These fundamentals are Man (labour), Materials and Machines (equipments) called the 3 Ms of manufacturing. A well-balanced 3M is resulted through lean manufacturing.
CHAPTER 2
HISTORY
It is a popular fact that JIT system started in the initial years after the World War II in Japan for the Toyota automobile system. Toyoda family in Japan decided to change their automatic loom manufacturing business to the automobile business. But they had few problems to overcome. They could not compete with the giants like Ford in the foreign markets. Therefore Toyota had to depend upon the small local markets. They also had to bring down the raw materials from outside. Also they had to produce in small batches. They havent had much of capital to work with. Therefore capital was very important. With these constrains Taiichi Ohno took over the challenge of achieving the impossible. With his right hand man Dr. Sheigo Shingo for next three decades he built the Toyota production system or the Just In Time system. ( Figure: 2.1 )
( Taiichi Ohno ) Although the concept was mastered in Japan for the Toyota production system, the roots of this concept goes into the sixteenth century. Eli Whitneys concept of interchangeable parts said to be the very initial beginning of this concept. But first or at least famous implementation of something similar to JIT happened a century later in manufacturing of Ford Model T (in 1910) automobile design. Manufacturing was based on line assembly. Every part moved without interruptions to the next value adding point. Parts are manufactured and assembled in a continuous flow. Even Henry Ford may not have understood the basics behind his system. But it saved lots of money and made Henry Ford a richest on the planet at that
3
time. Although very successful in the initial years, Ford system had it drawbacks. One of the major drawbacks was that its inability to the change. This was due to the push strategy implemented in the Fords system. They relied on keeping machine busy without thinking about the final outcome. They had huge stocks in the form of finished goods and in the form of Work In Progress. This led to the inflexibility of the system. Also this wasted money unnoticed. Another major drawback of the system was the poor handling of the human resource. This led to have a less motivated set of people in the organization. But in Japan, they studied the system very well and saw the problems that Ford system had. But the core concept of the Ford system was obeyed. This is the continuous flow of value system. Anything distracting it treated as a waste. Various pioneered work from people like Deming and Juran in the field of quality improvement was used in the system. This bought built in quality to the system. More importantly Ohno and Shingo understood the drawbacks in the push system and understood the role played by the inventory. This led to Pull system rather than the push system, where the parts are produced only when they are pulled by the process before that. This is similar to the concepts in the super markets. When the shells are being emptied (that is when people buy the product), they are refilled with new ones. This system developed in Toyota from 1949 to 1975 virtually unnoticed by the others even within Japan. But in the oil crisis in 1973 Japan economy suffered and most of the industries had losses. But Toyota overcame these problems. They stood out from the rest. This was the eye opener for other Japanese firms to implement this system. But this system got popular in the western world with the book The machine that change the world written by James Womack in 1990. This book was aimed to give the history of the automobile with the plant details of some of these manufacturers. He gave the name Lean Manufacturing to this system. This was the eye opener for the western world about this system. Thereafter the concepts were practiced all over the world. Experiences and knowledge vastly improved the system. But there were many people who just tried to use the tools in lean manufacturing without understanding the meaning of them. They eventually failed. But there are number of places this system is working well. The complete elimination waste is the target of the system. This concept is vitally important today since in todays highly competitive world there is nothing we can waste.
CHAPTER 3
MANUFACTURING WASTE
Waste is defined as anything that does not add value to the final product. The wastes are everywhere in many different forms. Every organization wastes majority of their resources. Therefore it is worthier to have a closer look at these wastes. For the ease of understanding these and due to many other similarities, these wastes are categorized in to seven categories. In some instances one extra category is added to make the total of eight waste categories. Since I feel this eighth category is very important I will go by this categorization. Every waste you will come across in your organization or even in day-to-day life will fall into one of these categories. Following are these waste categories. Over production Waiting Work In Progress (WIP) Transportation Inappropriate processing Excess motion or ergonomic problems Defected products Underutilization of employees Although in deferent groups, each one of these is interconnected. Therefore one change will affect the total system. You will see later in this chapter how closely these are interconnected to make the mesh of wastes in every organization.
stimulation with huge advertising campaigns etc. this is known as the push strategy. Still you will not have the guaranty that this will be able to sell the products without wastages. In the much smaller picture, the word over production might mean producing a part of a product before it is required by the assembly line or the process after that. For an example there is no point of making more receivers than the phones intended to be produced. The extra amount will be a lost. Over production accounts for many loses. One is the waste due to unnecessary parts. This also will make the WIP higher. Flow will not be smoother. This obviously leads to low quality products and defects as quality problems are hidden in the WIP maintained due to over production.
3.2. Waiting
In conventional batch processing, some studies show that 90% of the time goods are waiting to be processed. Some even say this is higher as 99%. Even a single minute lost in waiting cannot be recovered in the process there after. Think carefully. Analyze how long the products are waiting against the time used for processing them. I am sure you will be shocked. This is one big contributory factor for the higher lead times. This simply means you take 100 hours or more to complete work which is worthier only 10 hours. Ninety hours or more is lost and added to the lead time. No waiting means you can deliver the goods within 10 days which actually took 100 days earlier. Think about the flexibility you will get with this. If you can do this, you are there to compete with the changing markets and react to the changes very fast, even before your competitors think about it. This will also reduce the WIP and tons of related problems. Also considerable savings on the production space and reduction in work in capital can be achieved. Among the cause of this problem is due to the high volume machinery, unawareness of the people, and conventional thinking of the people play leading roles.
done. Higher WIP also requires larger floor space. This will also affect the appearance of the work place badly. Therefore if you want to be perfect, just target for a system where there is no requirement for WIP.
3.4. Transportation
No matter how well you do transporting. It does not add value to the end product. Therefore simply transportation is one of the wastes that have to be eliminated from the production system. This accounts for the quality defects, maintenance of a higher WIP, and additional cost of transporting the goods. Transportation often caused by poor work place organization. Inflexibility of the layout plays a big role here. This can be avoided with careful re designing of the layouts.
people poor conditions are not good for the health of the worker obviously. Also this will waste large amounts of time. Workplaces will become very untidy. Workers will get tired easily. The reason for this is poor workplace organization. To overcome this problem, a detailed study has to be carried out about working conditions. Then they have to be re arranged to eliminate these problems. Even some simple equipment change like from normal chairs to movable and adjustable chairs will solve some problems. But some problems will need very good workplace engineering to overcome.
full use of the human resource is a waste. Wasting this without using to fight against the wastes is the biggest loss for the organization. Most of the times the human talents are deteriorated because they are not identified by the decision makers. Decision makers do not have the mind set of managing human resource productively. Also most of the organizations do not have a proper system to use the talents of the people. They also do not have a good motivation and rewarding system for the talents. If people are not being rewarded, they will not come out with their full potential. Overcoming this problem is a very long termed task. But even some simple techniques can give you good results. You can simply keep a suggestion box and ask people to put their ideas into it to regarding the productivity improvement. Motivate them with some cash or with recognition. See the results. You will have a potential of saving lot of money. More than that people will get motivated and will have a chain effect. Human brains and hearts are valuable even than the most expensive machinery in the world.
CHAPTER 4
Lean manufacturing is based on continuous finding and removal of the wastes. Value is defined from the customers point of view. Therefore all the tools in lean manufacturing aim to identify and remove wastes from the system continuously. There are four steps in implementing lean manufacturing. They are; 1. Identifying the fact that there are wastes to be removed 2. Analyzing the wastes and finding the root causes for these wastes 3. Finding the solution for these root causes 4. Application of these solutions and achieving the objective When this is done go back to the stage 1 and continue this loop over and over again. To become lean it is very necessary to understand the fact that wastes are there. You must also be able to find out where these wastes do exist. Then you will be able to find out the root causes for these problems and then come up with a way to solve it. To find out where in the process these wastes exist there is a very powerful and simple tool. This well known tool is process mapping. Process map simply maps all the processes and the activities which are carried out in bringing a specific product or a service in to a reality. Irrelevant of the value they add to the final product or the service, the process map includes all the activities from the point of development or order inquiry to making and shipping the goods and up to the point where customer collects the goods. By sticking to a single product or a service you will find it very easy to make the process map. This also makes it easy to understand the process when someone refers to the process map. Or another way you can create a map which is simpler and easy to understand is by creating a overall map with all the departments and their interconnectivity, and then map the processes within the departments separately. This way you will get a good map which is simpler to understand and much more conclusive. You can use the standard symbols used in the process mapping to create a process map which can be understand by all the people easily. When you map the process, you will start to see the; 1. Value added and 2. Non value added activities You will also have better idea of what are the avoidable, non value added activities and what are the non values added unavoidable activities.
10
After understanding these clearly, you have to create the process map for the future. This will include only the value added activities and the non value added but unavoidable activities. The process changes and the lay out changes etc are also possible in creating this ideal layout. This is so important since there after your aim is to get this ideal position. This will be the aim for your future. By now you have clearly understand the wastes that you have to remove from the system. But what should be given the priority. Finding the order of the problems that should be according to the priority of talking is one of the very important issues to be addressed correctly. One tool which is very important in this is the Pareto Analysis or the Pareto Curve. This will give you the importance of each problem to the system. Then you will be able to tackle the problems easily according to their importance. Refer to the chat below. ( Figure: 4.1 )
( Pareto Curve ) After finding out the order of talking of the problems, you have to find out the root causes for these problems in order to avoid these problems. For an example if you have frequent machine breakdowns, you will find the cause for this problem is untrained workers, poor maintenance, poor quality machinery used etc. then you will be able to analyze these causes again find out the causes for them as well. For an example why the staff is not trained
11
properly is because most of them are new and have not had enough time to be trained. Then you will be able to come up with a way of training people when they just join in so that you will avoid this problem. It is generally advised that not to go than three steps down the line in finding root causes. One tool which is extremely important in understanding the root causes of the problems is brain storming. Also various data collection techniques and analyzing techniques will help in finding out these root causes. Representing these root causes and their relevance to the immediate problem can be achieved with a cause effect diagram or a Ishikawa Diagram. ( Figure: 4.2 )
( Ishikawa Diagram )
Lean manufacturing offers few readymade and well proven solutions for any industry. But always you have to customize these solutions to suit your organization. Always keep in mind, lean manufacturing does not start with the tools, it starts with lean thinking. Now here below discuss lean manufacturing tool in details.
JIT is one key way to get read of most of the wastes which we have already discussed in the early chapters. JIT concepts are based on the pull demand model. Everything is done when they are actually needed. JIT has three main areas. JIT Purchasing JIT Production JIT Distribution
13
Achieving JIT manufacturing is again not an easy task. Most of the time this requires a radical change in the organization. Work will change from the conventional departmental thinking to the new team thinking. Manufacturing will change from the line system to the module or work cell based manufacturing. Every problem will cause the system to stop since there is no WIP to work with. All the problems hidden in the WIP will be revealed. Some people might not like the system. In short there will be tons of problems to be solved. This requires some courage and temperament. It is true to say that most of the problems in achieving JIT manufacturing is has to deal with the human side of the problem. People do not like to change if there is no motivation to do so. People will fear about their jobs. They can bring lots of negative thoughts to this. Of cause negative thoughts are important. Why I am saying this is these negative thoughts might bring some real problems which we have never addressed before. You will have to deal with these problems very carefully. One thing that you have to do first of all is driving out the fear with this change. Specially regarding their jobs. You have to take their participation in the process and let them to understand themselves that this is not something that should be feared about. You have to motivate people by continuous education about the new system. One smart idea may be to use the same names which they are familiar before for the new systems. For an example use the word bin card instead of a kanban card. People will feel immensely comfortable with the names they have been using before. You also will not lose anything, as far as you are applying the kanban techniques in your production.
14
Company, who will take care of JIT distribution. On time, uninterrupted data exchange is very vital in this. Therefore it is advisable of using a electronic way of data interchange. It is also very much necessary to automate this data transfer function to avoid any delays and mistakes in duplication.
( Work cells )
15
16
It can be done today Everyone can participate Waste is made visible Has a wide area of impact
o o o o o
Improves set up times Improves quality Improves safety Improves morale Improves productivity
There is an order and logic to how 5S is carried out. It doesnt make sense to start by arranging things neatly, if most of those things are not needed. The five S words below are the steps of 5S.
4.5.1. Sort
It is about removing all items that are not required or are unnecessary within a period ahead. Such items are waste, or lead to waste. They take up space, lead to extra walking around, and lead to waste of time whilst searching for needed items buried under piles of less important material.
4.5.2. Straighten
It is about having things easy to hand, labeled, classified and easily visible. Shadow boards may be used for tools, books arranged by topic, shelves not too high, wheels on carts, heavy low and light high, colour coded connections and pipes. It has a direct impact on productivity-Searching for lost papers and tools should be eliminated. And time wasted should be cut by careful location of tools and materials.
17
4.5.4. Standardize
It refers to engendering the habits of workplace procedures. It is about the establishment and maintenance of standards. The first standard is to ensure that the previous 3Ss are in place and maintained. Standards should be kept line side and be diagrammatic o r written, but never verbal. Standard procedures can be color coded to match the product, which carries a label of matching colour. When an engineering change occurs, a number on the product should match the number on the standard sheet. Any standard should cover not only what to do when things are normal, but also what to do if things go wrong.
life cycle. The goal of TPM is to minimize downtime due to maintenance, and maximize machine uptime. One of the key elements of TPM is autonomous maintenance where the operators are responsible for maintaining their own equipment. TPM stages are break down maintenance, preventive maintenance, productive maintenance, and total productive maintenance. ( Figure: 4.4 )
( The Relationship b/w TPM, Productive Maintenance & Preventive Maintenance ) TPM = Productive Maintenance + Small Group Activities MP = Maintenance Prevention PM = Preventive Maintenance MI = Maintainability Improvement TPM capitalizes on proactive and progressive maintenance methodologies and calls upon the knowledge and cooperation of operators, equipment vendors, engineering, and support personnel to optimize machine performance. Results of this optimized performance include; elimination of breakdowns, reduction of unscheduled and scheduled downtime, improved utilization, higher throughput, and better product quality. Bottom-line results include; lower operating costs, longer equipment life, and lower overall maintenance costs
both material and information flows are depicted. It is used to provide a snapshot of the "Present State" of your manufacturing process. Producing this present state flow diagram will help identify all of the value adding and non-value adding steps within your process. Once this present state map is completed, a company will clearly see where the opportunities are for eliminating the non-value adding steps. The "Future State" Map of a process is then created showing the improved, streamlined flow. Using this method will allow a company to look at the "Big Picture" of a manufacturing process. Value Stream Mapping doesn't require any special software tools; everything should be drawn by hand and in pencil.
carrying costs, but also production lead-time or cycle time is approximately directly proportional to the amount of WIP. Therefore, smaller batch sizes shorten the overall production cycle, enabling companies to deliver more quickly and to invoice sooner (for improved Cash flow). Shorter production cycles increases inventory turns and allows the company to operate profitably at lower margins, which enables price reductions, which increases sales and market share.
CHAPTER 5
5.1. Malty skilled workforce
CHARACTERISTICS
In order to have smoothed production, it is necessary that the worker be skilled in a number of functions. The use of mono skilled and mono-function worker in industry, leads to much underutilization of labour/machinery. Small fluctuations in the demand can be taken care of by lean production, through use of an elongated shift working and deployment of skilled workers. If the demand is slightly lower, the work is finished early and the rest of the period is used for either workers rest, or activity such as practicing set-ups, preventive maintenance etc.
22
23
CHAPTER 6
The benefits of implementing Lean [2] can be broken down into three broad categories; Operational, Administrative, and Strategic Improvements. Even to this day, most organizations that implement Lean do so the operational improvements, primarily because of the perception that Lean only applies to the operations side of the business. However, from our experiences, Leans administrative and strategic benefits are equally impressive. Some of Leans benefits are summarized below.
25
CHAPTER 7
For years manufacturers have created products in anticipation of having a market for them. Operations have traditionally been driven by sales forecasts and firms tended to stockpile inventories in case they were needed. A key difference in JIT & Lean Manufacturing is that it is based on the concept that production can and should be driven by real customer demand. Instead of producing what you hope to sell; JIT & Lean Manufacturing can produce what your customer wants with shorter lead times. Instead of pushing product to market, it's pulled there through a system that's set up to quickly respond to customer demand. JIT & Lean organizations are capable of producing high-quality products economically in lower volumes and bringing them to market faster than mass producers. JIT & lean organization can make twice as much product with twice the quality and half the time and space, at half the cost, with a fraction of the normal work-in-process inventory. JIT & Lean management is about operating the most efficient and effective organization possible, with the least cost and zero waste.
26
Organization
Hierarchical structures that encourage following orders and discourage the flow of vital
Flat structures that encourage initiative and encourage the flow of vital information that highlights
information that highlights defects, defects, operator errors, equipment operator errors, equipment abnormalities, and organizational deficiencies. External Relations Information Management Based on price Information-weak management based on abstract reports Based on long-term relationships Information-rich management based on visual control systems maintained by all employees Cultural Culture of loyalty and obedience, subculture of alienation and labor strife Production Large-scale machines, functional layout, minimal skills, long production runs, massive inventories Operational capability Dumb tools that assume an extreme Smart tools that assume division of labor, the following of orders, and no problem solving skills Maintenance Maintenance by maintenance specialists standardized work, strength in problem identification, hypothesis generation, and experimentation Equipment management by production, maintenance and engineering Engineering "Isolated genius" model, with little input from customers and little respect for production realities. Team-based model, with high input from customers and concurrent development of product and production process design Harmonious culture of involvement based on long-term development of human resources Human-scale machines, cell-type layout, multi-skilling, one-piece flow, zero inventories abnormalities, and organizational deficiencies.
27
pushed through the facility through the facility Replenish finished goods inventory Weeks/months Fill customer orders (immediate shipments) Hours/days
Low difficult to handle High easy to adjust to and and adjust to implement
28
CHAPTER 8
CONCLUSION
From this study, it is understood that, in this modern competitive world, where only those industries, which provide maximum customer satisfaction at attracting prices can succeed, the JIT & Lean manufacturing system plays an important role, as it reduces the manufacturing time & wastage, during production. Thus it increases the amount of goods produced and decreases the cost of production of these goods. This seminar stresses the need to implement JIT & Lean manufacturing technique in Automobile industries & other modern industries where large-scale production takes place.
29
REFERENCES
1. Just in Time - by David Hutchins, Productivity press (India) Pri. Ltd. 2. Study of Toyota production system - by Shigeo Shingo 3. Toyota Production System - by Yasuhiro Monden 4. Just in Time for Today and Tomorrow - by Taiichi Ohno, Setsuo Mito 5. Management Guide to Quality and Productivity - John Bicheno, M.R.Gopalan, Wheeler Publishers. 6. Lean Production-An Innovation Management - by S.Ilangovan, N.Saravanan 7. www.leanmanufacturingconcepts.com 8. www.mep.org. 9. www.ddiworld.com 10. www.advancedmanufacturing.com
30