Precedent Case Study
Precedent Case Study
Precedent Case Study
Project name: Unite dhabitation Architect:Le Corbusier City / Location:Marseille, France Year Designed / Built:1947 /1952 Area: 386,130sq ft Floors: 12 Units: 366 DESCRIPTION After World War II, the need for housing was at an unprecedented high. The Unite d Habitation in Marseille, France was the first large scale project for the famed architect, Le Corbusier. In 1947, Europe was still feeling the effects of the Second World War, when Le Corbusier was commissioned to design a multifamily residential housing project for the people of Marseille that were dislocated after the bombings on France. Completed in 1952, the Unite d Habitation was the first of a new housing project series for Le Corbusier that focused on communal living for all the inhabitants to shop, play, live, and come together in a vertical garden city. ington Park, the role of the block becomes more evident. Further, zooming into diagrams of the details of s
CASE STATEMENT The Unite d Habitation was a first, both for Le Corbusier and the ways in which to approach such a large complex to accommodate roughly 1,600 residents. Especially since Le Corbusier did not have many buildings of such a substantial scale when compared to the villas. When designing for such a significant number of inhabitants natural instinct is to design horizontally spreading out over the landscape, rather Le Corbusier designed the community that one would encounter in a neighborhood within a mixed use, modernist, residential high rise. Le Corbusiers idea of the vertical garden city was based
on bringing the villa within a larger volume that allowed for the inhabitants to have their own private spaces, but outside of that private sector they would shop, eat, exercise, and gather together. With nearly 1,600 residents divided among eighteen floors, the design requires an innovative approach toward spatial organization to accommodate the living spaces, as well as the public, communal spaces. Interestingly enough, the majority of the communal aspects do not occur within the building; rather they are placed on the roof. The roof becomes a garden terrace that has a running track, a club, a 1
, a kindergarten, a gym, and a shallow pool. Beside the roof, there are shops, medical facilities, and even a small hotel distributed throughout the interior of the building. The Unite d Habitation is essentially a city within a city that is spatially, as well as, functionally optimized for the residents.
Unite d Habitation has since been the example for public housing across the world; however, no venture has been as successful as the Unite d Habitation simply because the Modular proportions that Corbusier established during the project. Nonetheless, Le Corbusiers first large scale project has proved to be one of his most significant and inspiring.
Project Name: Simmons Hall Architects: Steven Holl Architects Location: Cambridge, Massachusetts Local Architect: Perry Dean Rogers & Partners Project Year: 1999-2002 Structural Engineer: Simpson Gumpertz & Heger
DESCRIPTION Simmons Hall, designed by Steven Holl and architects, is an undergraduate dorm that holds 350 students. In addition, it also contains a night cafe, street level dining, and an 125-seat theater. The building is 382 feet long and ten stories tall. Each single room or the dorm contains a grided pattern of nine operable windows. The depth of these windows 18 into the wall provides shade from the hot summers sun and allows ample heat gain in the winter.5 One explanation for the different colors coated on the head and jamb of the windows is to denote the different houses within the building.7 Another deals with stress which will be discussed along with structure. The colors are very visible from some angles and not as visible from others.
CASE STATEMENT Holls design solution was that the building would metaphorically work as a sponge. It would be a porous structure that would soak up light through a series of large openings that would cut into the building so that light would filter through in section. These breaks in section would then become main interactive spaces for the students, providing views onto different levels. In his original drawings, Holl referred to these breaks as the buildings lungs as they would bring natural light down while circulating air up. The model at the bottom was an early model depicting the sponge or porous concept idea behind Simmons Halls design. The porous parts of the building serve as atria to allow ventilation to flow up through the building and to serve as a common area for students to gather. Shown here are two atria within the building. 3
Much of Holls idea for Simmons Hall can be traced to a single word - porosity. The idea was supposedly inspired by the sponge he was bathing with one morning. The Sponge concept allows for the transformation of the building into a series of programmatic and biotechnical functions. Sculptural fluid spaces within the building connect residential houses vertically and promote student interaction. These large porous sections also serve as lungs for the building by allowing light to enter and serving as a means of vertical ventilation. You can see through the floor plans that similar holes begin to link floors together vertically within the different houses in the building. You can also begin to see how systems work together as a whole. 4
DESCRIPTION Simply by stacking small communities on top of each other you maintain the proximity to green free space and get the benefit from living in a tower such as view, light and urban density. The result is a threedimensional checkerboard where each 15x15x15meter box overlaps enough for an elevator to reach the highest floors. CASE STATEMENT Throughout the thirty floors, five large gardens allow the residents to play, swim and relax. The five gardens each have a unique appearance to accommodate all the needs of a modern community; a green forest where you can enjoy the spectacular view of the city, a Japanese stone garden for relaxation and immersion, a wooden pool garden where you can go for a swim, a playground for the kids and finally a rooftop terrace on the 25th floor.
for: opportunities for local employment through mixture of use, both on ground and upper levels A healthy mix of residents within the same building. Through vertical zoning, resident types are grouped according to accommodation preferences (single units, family units, luxury apartments), yet common facilities (e.g. parks, shopping streets etc.) are shared. close proximity to basic amenities, such as the local grocery store, postal boxes, chemist etc. These are all located within the ground development and/or within the tower. a healthy landscaped environment, with spatial progressions of public open spaces (parks in the sky) to semi-private (entrance courts) to private open spaces (balconies).
CASE STATEMENT The design seeks to re-create conditions on the ground up-inthe-sky, with features such as an entrance lobby, light wells and balconies for every unit and shared secondary and tertiary landscaped open spaces and sky pods within groups of housing in the form of sky courts and communal pods.