Iran, Russia, and China—and where Israel fits into this complex equation—are the focus of David Goldman's conversation with Caroline Glick of the Jewish News Syndicate. David, a long-time member of SIGNAL Group’s Board of Advisors, has accompanied our delegations from Israel on several China briefing trips prior to the COVID pandemic. During those trips, we had numerous discussions centered on terrorism and its roots, where there was considerable agreement between the parties. However, times have changed. David emphasizes that China’s concerns about the Muslim populations to its south—particularly in Malaysia, Indonesia, and Central Asia—create a common interest with Israel. It is true that China has long been concerned with these areas. However, since the 2014 car bombing in Tiananmen Square, Beijing has developed a strict approach to eliminating terrorism within its borders, while adopting a more moderate, sometimes even conciliatory stance toward Islamic fundamentalism outside of China. Consequently, China’s domestic concerns over terrorism are not what they once were.
I beg to differ with David's claim that Beijing views preventing terrorism as a shared interest with Israel. Since the Gaza war in May 2021, China has taken a firm position of criticizing Israel and supporting Hamas, presenting itself as a defender of Muslim interests. Beijing seems to believe that this approach will shield it from Islamic fundamentalism and the influence of the Muslim Brotherhood. However, this position is shortsighted, as it could be interpreted as implicit support for Hamas’ terrorist activities. Moreover, several Muslim-majority nations have signaled a clear desire to see an end to Hamas and other branches of the Muslim Brotherhood. These countries, by refraining from taking steps to intervene in Israel’s actions against Hamas and Hezbollah, have shown where they stand.
That said, I do agree with David's perspective on China’s stance toward Iran. The relationship between the two is far from comfortable. Both sides have significant issues with one another, and based on my discussions with Chinese policy experts, Beijing is resolute in its opposition to Iran developing nuclear military capabilities. David is also right about China's position on energy; a smooth flow of energy from the Middle East is critical to its economic stability.
China cannot afford for the region to erupt into chaos—for both energy security and its massive investments, not to mention the million Chinese workers currently employed across the Middle East.
Perhaps this is why we are now seeing subtle shifts in Beijing’s position towards Israel. Recently, for the first time since October 7, the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs publicly recognized Israel’s security concerns. If Israel continues to grow in significance, as David noted, through demographic and economic trends, China will be compelled to reassess its approach to the Jewish state.
Is Israel the West’s outpost in a shifting world order? In his interview with Caroline Glick, of Jewish News Syndicate, SIGNAL Group Advisory Board Member David Goldman dives deep into the growing alliance between China, Russia, and Iran—the 'new axis' reshaping the Middle East. Goldman’s expert analysis explores how Israel is navigating the Sino-American power struggle and its critical role in this evolving geopolitical landscape.
Read the full transcript here: https://lnkd.in/d5j-Ddzm
Israel Is Not an Outpost of the West
https://sino-israel.org
Founder @ NewsWhip | Predictive Media Insight
2wLink to the paper: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/19401612241271074