Jeff Lassen’s Post

View profile for Jeff Lassen, graphic

Managing Director at FTI Consulting

Survey results released by the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry showed that regulation (red tape) is have a moderate to major impact on 8 out 10 small business.[1] According to the ABS there are just over 2.6 million businesses in Australia, most of which are small businesses.[2] Against this context, it is easy to imagine important substantial improvements in productivity (not fewer jobs but being able to do more with the same resources). Imagine an improvement to how and where we regulate that provides a small annual increase in profit of $100 per business. This would generate an increase of at least $200 million every year. The moral is that slight changes are worth pursuing. And, on the other side, even seemingly small and innocuous changes to regulation can quietly and quickly reduce productivity. The quality of regulation is part of the cause of Australia’s mired productivity performance[3], although not the sole factor. And it is a factor truly controlled by Australian Government (Federal, State and Local). In my experience, proposers of new regulation understate the costs of regulation, particularly because they tend to focus in on the measurable. Regulation cost reckoners do a decent job of estimating the cost to government of administering regulation and a reasonable job of the additional direct cost to business of complying. Here, think of regulatory returns, compliance audits, legal advice and doing business in a prescribed way. These can be counted but they aren’t the major issue. The full cost includes the indirect cost. I would describe these as the cost of distracting entrepreneurial effort impacting on how a business perceives its market and how it competes. Its also plain exhausting. A common complaint heard from small business is that regulation adds many hours to their working week. Its hard to be innovative when you are exhausted. Echoing this sentiment is a quote in a case study accompanying the ACCI survey stated: ‘The average small business just wants to get on with it, innovate, grow, and contribute to the economy, yet we are suffocated under an increasingly complex regulatory environment and red tape burden.' [4] The above quote neatly summarises the mechanism through which the hidden costs of regulation arise. So, next time you see the estimated cost of regulation in a consultation document for a new regulation, it is likely to be the tip of the iceberg. The view in this post are personal views and do not represent the view of FTI Consulting. [1] Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (2024), ACCI Small Business Survey June 2024. [2] Australian Bureau of Statistics (2024), Counts of Australian Businesses, including Entrances and Exits, August 2024. [3] Productivity Commission (2024), Market sector productivity dashboard. [4] Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ibid, p 2).

Well argued Jeff - productivity enhancement must be a primary commitment of Government.

Like
Reply

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics