Great reporting from Alice Dreger at Local News Blues about the Medill Local News Map. Great analysis from Ashley Woods Branch. Mapping the local news landscape in the United States is not easy. This is a teachable moment for the whole local news ecosystem in the U.S. and an opportunity to develop data collection and reporting systems that are more equitable and accurate for every community. How can we work together to help make sure local news data is right and news outlets are not omitted from local news maps, especially ethnic news sources that cover communities? A Few Ideas ✅ Talk to NAHJ (National Association of Hispanic Journalists), National Association of Black Journalists (NABJ), Asian American Journalists Association (AAJA), Indigenous Journalists Association and other national professional news organizations to verify data. ✅ Crowdsource data and provide a public way to gather information from communities themselves across the local news landscape. ✅ Create an editing and fact-check process that enables more diverse view of data. Make sure there are not blind spots. In the words of Nancy West, Executive Editor of InDepthNH.org, “This map is misleading at a time when major funders and investors may be relying on it to make decisions about the future of local news. Unacceptable.” It is hard to get perfect data, but with some creative thinking, innovation, cooperation, and collaboration, the journalism community can get closer to 100 percent, in terms of accuracy and inclusion and representation. This will ensure every community is counted and recognized, and we are telling the whole local news story. #journalism #localnews #community
I'm glad to see Alice Dreger reporting out some apparent issues with the Medill Local News Map, which aims to "provide a detailed look at the state of local news today." Obviously, a lot of good work has been done through this project, but as Alice has found, publications serving people of color continue to be undercounted. And that's not OK. There is an obvious thru line between decreased visibility and decreased opportunity. Publishers of color are doing incredibly important work -- with less resources and support than their mainstream counterparts. Problems like these could be avoided if researchers initiated consistent relationships with associations like the National Association of Hispanic Publishers and the National Newspaper Publisher Association, who are serving the very publishers they struggle to recognize. We can do better -- and publishers deserve better. Either we need accurate and robustly-maintained maps and databases that include ALL local news publishers working to serve their communities, or we need to talk about why projects like these continue to be funded.