The degree to which Google shakes down advertisers would make Al Capone blush. With the announcement that video action campaigns are being rolled into demand gen, it's worth sharing a piece I wrote a year and a half ago on how Google robs advertisers. Demand gen has minimal adoption because it's a half-baked product with mediocre at best performance. Video action campaigns (YT performance) are great. We spend over $1mm/mo on them. As Google as done with PMax and hiding search queries, they are doing with YouTube ads and that is making them less effective for advertisers so that Google itself can make more money. It's another important reminder that Google does NOT have advertiser's best interests at heart and if you're working with an agency that trusts Google implicitly you're getting absolutely fleeced. https://lnkd.in/gWVuJfbE
Not even halfway through and I paused comment because…someone chose violence today
I saw the news this morning too, wild stuff. More reason to prioritize TikTok over YouTube as a second channel instead now.
Well if that's not a good hook, I don't know what is Collin Slattery 🤣
Are we finally talking about Google out loud now?
Here's an issue I've been fighting. I have two campaigns for a SaaS company, both set for US & Canada only. The Google Ad console shows 100% of traffic from those Geos. But I have Dr. Augustine Fou 's tracker and a 2nd non-Google tracker on the Hubspot landing pages. Only 39% of traffic was actually coming from US & Canada. The reset from such SaaS hotspots as Ethiopia, Syria, Mogadishu, Iran, Yemen, Sri Lanka, Eastern Congo, and Honduras. After changing the hidden default Location settings to "Presence Only", that upped my US/CAN traffic to 63%. I've had to add 113 Country Exclusions in to finally get traffic up to 94%. And Google keeps sending traffic even from countries on the exclusion list! And they're fabricating and showing 100% fraudulent data on the Google Ad Location console to HIDE what they're doing with the out-of-geo traffic. Do No Evil 👿
It seems the business model is to become as big of a black box as possible, and find new and innovative ways to force you to buy the rubbish inventory but dress it up that you're getting a good deal (e.g. by rolling in aggressive retargeting and brand advertising in PMax). If I look at something as basic as the extent to which match types have changed over time, it's extraordinary. Broad match is 'as-wide-as-the-universe' match, phrase match is broad match, and even exact match now I'm finding in some circumstances is inferior to what even the deprecated broad match modified option used to be (in terms of relevance of search terms to the inputted keyword). It's so extreme it would be like McDonalds selling you a Big Mac combo then giving you a Filet-o-Fish with salad instead as a substitute (no hate if that's your order btw)
Yes the rot started from those times when tools like Google adplanner got killed (circa 2014 if I rem right), followed by many useful free tools (even stuff like exact match, keyword digger etc) that the "new" Google saw as "detrimental" to their bloodsucking $ greed. It is amazing how much they are capable of taking away to satiate that greed.
Senior Digital Marketing Specialist @ Kneat Solutions | Marketing Leader | Driving ROI Through Data-driven Marketing | Network Cork Businesswoman Award Winner 2023 | Marketing Insitute Ireland Cork Committee Member
3moOOHH really? When is this happening? I was looking at doing some Video Ads soon on Google. We tried the Demand Gen ads, and they were just not great for producing high quality leads and were expensive for those leads at that.