Earlier in my career, I struggled with receiving feedback. I would brace myself, get defensive, and sometimes make excuses. Over time, a few things changed my perspective and helped me improve how I handle feedback: Pat Wadors would remind me "feedback is a gift". The act of giving feedback is an act of courage and care. When someone takes the time to give me feedback, it means they care about my growth, and they have the courage to start a potentially difficult conversation. Not all feedback might feel like a gift in the moment. There is a Buddhist saying that stuck with me: "What do you do when someone gives you a gift you don't want? You say 'thank you.'" Now when someone gives me feedback, the most important response from me is simple: "thank you." I feel grateful for their gift, and then can decide how to act on it separately. But starting with a posture of gratitude shifts the conversation for everyone.
I was once given the perspective of feedback is a gift though you may not always like the wrapping paper. This has really stuck with me in taking the step back from how it was communicated or shared and to take the step to still evaluate the feedback for the glimmers of insights it may have.
My favorite "version" of this was how Andrew Luck handled getting sacked: https://youtu.be/Buvo_-3x9dA?feature=shared. It's no annual review, but was quite the (unexpected) response to everyone who received it.
My mantra for feedback is “every piece of feedback gives you something to learn, and no piece of feedback ever tells the whole story.” So our job when we get it is to contextualize it, learn as much as we can from the instance, and do the work to put together the whole story for ourselves over time. Once we see the throughlines, we can decide what we’re ok with and not, and then take charge of the change that helps us grow in the most important ways for our own stories and goals.
Wonderful advice Brian. Also, for feedback givers, please ensure that it is really feedback. How do you know if you're giving feedback or giving criticism? IMHO, feedback has heart and intention of help. It's delivered with care and encourages the receiver without tearing them down. Criticism, oftentimes triggers the fight of flight part of our brains and leads to reduced motivation or self preservation rather than learning and growing.
I very much like your words "feedback is an act of courage and care". Feedforward, a concept promoted by Marshall Goldsmith even more. You can't change what has been, the behaviors you had, the performance you delivered, the past exchanges . But you can commit for the future. And as a feedforward giver your attention should be on the future as well.
this sounds like its a hallmark version of the truth !
I love this. Many of us struggled with receiving feedback earlier in our career and the concept of continuous improvement helped me tremendously.
I love this! Meta had a big feedback culture and Sheryl Sandberg made me laugh by saying “feedback is a gift and every day feels like Christmas”
The advice that changed forever my stance on (difficult) feedback: find the 2% of truth in the feedback, even if you reject all rest. And act on that 2%. Complete mindset shift that enabled me to use that feedback for growth.