Learn the key differences between ASIC, FPGA, and SoC architectures, their advantages and disadvantages, and their common use cases.

Key differences between ASIC, FPGA, and SoC architectures are – SoC (System on a Chip): Integrates all components of a computer or other electronic system onto a single chip May include CPU, GPU, memory, I/O ports, and more Designed for specific applications but more general-purpose than ASICs ASIC (Application-Specific Integrated Circuit): Custom designed for a specific application or task Non-reprogrammable post-fabrication High performance and energy efficiency FPGA (Field-Programmable Gate Array): Reconfigurable integrated circuit Programmed post-manufacturing using a hardware description language Lower performance compared to ASICs

IMO (25 yrs ASIC & FPGA design) the details above are spot on, but whilst the information is correct, I'd say that inclusion of SoC in the comparison is misleading. SoC is a design-type where multiple functions, usually with the elements above (CPU, memory etc.) are put into 1 chip. The chip itself may be an FPGA or ASIC - the choice depends on required speed, flexibility etc. as stated above. Topical analogy: it's like comparing air-fryers, microwaves & fries (ironically, chips if in UK like me). Each method has pros & cons but fries/chips are a tasty product that can be made by either. It's also common to prototype an SoC on 1 or more FPGAs before committing to an ASIC (lower power, higher speed). But that's a whole other topic....

ASIC (Application-Specific Integrated Circuit) is a customized silicon chip designed for a specific function, offering exceptional performance and tailored circuits. FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array) provides flexibility and rapid prototyping through reconfigurable logic gates and programming capabilities. SoC (System-on-Chip) integrates various functions onto a single chip, similar to ASICs, emphasizing custom system consolidation and product miniaturization.

SoC is a comprehensive integration concept that can utilize both ASIC and FPGA technologies, depending on the application’s needs. Consequently, it’s not entirely appropriate to compare SoC directly with FPGA and ASIC, as SoC operates on a broader level and can make use of both the technologies.

What are the key differences between ASIC, FPGA, and SoC architectures?

If you are interested in designing or developing electronic systems, you may have come across the terms ASIC, FPGA, and SoC. These are different types of architectures that can be used to implement various functions and applications on a chip. But what are the key differences between them, and how do they affect the performance, cost, and flexibility of your system? In this article, we will explain the basics of each architecture, compare their advantages and disadvantages, and give some examples of common use cases.

1 ASIC: Application-Specific Integrated Circuit

An ASIC is a custom-made chip that is designed for a specific purpose or application. It can have any logic, memory, or analog components that are required to perform the desired function. An ASIC is optimized for speed, power, and size, and can offer the best performance and efficiency for a given task. However, an ASIC is also expensive and time-consuming to design and manufacture, and it cannot be reprogrammed or modified once it is fabricated. An ASIC is suitable for high-volume, low-variation, and stable applications, such as digital signal processing, graphics processing, or encryption.

Add your perspective

2 FPGA: Field-Programmable Gate Array

An FPGA is a chip that consists of an array of programmable logic blocks that can be configured to implement any logic function. An FPGA can also have memory, input/output, and other resources that can be used to interface with external devices. An FPGA is flexible and adaptable, and it can be reprogrammed or updated at any time. However, an FPGA is also less efficient and more expensive than an ASIC, and it has lower performance and higher power consumption for complex functions. An FPGA is suitable for low-volume, high-variation, and dynamic applications, such as prototyping, testing, or research and development.

Add your perspective

3 SoC: System on a Chip

An SoC is a chip that integrates multiple components and subsystems on a single die. An SoC can have a processor, memory, peripherals, and other functions that are typically found on a board or a system. An SoC can also have an ASIC or an FPGA as part of its architecture, depending on the needs and specifications of the system. An SoC is compact and versatile, and it can offer a high level of integration and functionality for a system. However, an SoC is also complex and challenging to design and verify, and it may have compatibility or scalability issues with different components or standards. An SoC is suitable for diverse, multifunctional, and advanced applications, such as smartphones, tablets, or wearable devices.

Add your perspective

Cmdr (Dr.⁹) Reji Kurien Thomas , FRSA, MLE℠

I Empower Sectors as a Global Tech & Business Transformation Leader| Stephen Hawking Award 2024| Harvard Leader | UK House of Lord's Awardee | Fellow Royal Society | CyberSec | CCISO CISM CCNP-S CEH
Report contribution
Key differences between ASIC, FPGA, and SoC architectures are – SoC (System on a Chip): Integrates all components of a computer or other electronic system onto a single chip May include CPU, GPU, memory, I/O ports, and more Designed for specific applications but more general-purpose than ASICs ASIC (Application-Specific Integrated Circuit): Custom designed for a specific application or task Non-reprogrammable post-fabrication High performance and energy efficiency FPGA (Field-Programmable Gate Array): Reconfigurable integrated circuit Programmed post-manufacturing using a hardware description language Lower performance compared to ASICs

Like
James Ferris

Verification Consultant for Rejak Ltd
Report contribution
IMO (25 yrs ASIC & FPGA design) the details above are spot on, but whilst the information is correct, I'd say that inclusion of SoC in the comparison is misleading. SoC is a design-type where multiple functions, usually with the elements above (CPU, memory etc.) are put into 1 chip. The chip itself may be an FPGA or ASIC - the choice depends on required speed, flexibility etc. as stated above. Topical analogy: it's like comparing air-fryers, microwaves & fries (ironically, chips if in UK like me). Each method has pros & cons but fries/chips are a tasty product that can be made by either. It's also common to prototype an SoC on 1 or more FPGAs before committing to an ASIC (lower power, higher speed). But that's a whole other topic....

Like
Swarupa Kolli
Report contribution
ASIC (Application-Specific Integrated Circuit) is a customized silicon chip designed for a specific function, offering exceptional performance and tailored circuits. FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array) provides flexibility and rapid prototyping through reconfigurable logic gates and programming capabilities. SoC (System-on-Chip) integrates various functions onto a single chip, similar to ASICs, emphasizing custom system consolidation and product miniaturization.

Like
Reda Belkadi

Procurement Consultant Global Category Manager Electronics/ Mechanical/ Software/Saas/ sustainable Procurement/ Semiconductor specialist
Report contribution
Soc is very useful and practical for compact product application that needs maximum integration like small IOT (sensors, smart watches, Trackers, phones etc..)

Like

4 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

Mehfooz A.

ASIC Design Engineer II at Sensata Technologies
Report contribution
SoC is a comprehensive integration concept that can utilize both ASIC and FPGA technologies, depending on the application’s needs. Consequently, it’s not entirely appropriate to compare SoC directly with FPGA and ASIC, as SoC operates on a broader level and can make use of both the technologies.

Like
Charles Revelle

Principal Engineer at National Instruments
(edited)
Report contribution
Agree that SoC is a bit misleading when talking about ASIC vs FPGA costing and tradeoffs. Is a required volume of 400k still the run of thumb from moving from a FPGA to a ASIC design still the norm? Big concern is the Supply chain esp with a CMOS vs a Compound Semi Design. Will you use a design partner or leverage the Wafer design tools from the foundry.. Great Discussion

Like

What are the key differences between ASIC, FPGA, and SoC architectures?

1

2

3

4

1 ASIC: Application-Specific Integrated Circuit

2 FPGA: Field-Programmable Gate Array

3 SoC: System on a Chip

4 Here’s what else to consider

System on a Chip (SoC)

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on System on a Chip (SoC)

More relevant reading