Cheapest home and auto insurance bundle in New York

Cheapest home and auto bundles in New York

The total cost of a home and auto bundle depends on the base prices for the underlying home and auto insurance coverages. The discount is applied to each policy. The table below shows the average rates for home and auto insurance, as well as the total premium with and without the bundle discount.

In New York, the least expensive car and home bundles are offered by State Farm, followed next by NYCM Insurance.

Company	Home premium	Auto premium	Bundle premium	Without bundle premium
State Farm	$1,309	$2,935	$3,450	$4,244
NYCM Insurance	$1,437	$3,927	$4,121	$5,364
Allstate	$1,904	$3,707	$4,629	$5,611
Travelers	$2,094	$4,008	$5,387	$6,102
Chubb Ltd	$2,398	$5,349	$7,013	$7,747

The company offering the cheapest home and auto bundle in New York

State Farm

Our take: State Farm topped the list of auto insurance companies in a recent ranking, with customers giving it extremely high satisfaction scores. The company is also the top pick for home insurance, with customers giving it high marks for customer satisfaction, ease of service and for its various policy offerings. State Farm is the biggest property and casualty insurance company in the nation.

Biggest home and auto bundle discounts in New York

With an average of 23%, the largest discount for bundling home and auto insurance can be found at NYCM Insurance. On the other hand, at only 9%, the smallest multi-policy discount of the companies analyzed belongs to Chubb Ltd.

Company	Home and auto bundle discount
NYCM Insurance	23%
State Farm	19%
Allstate	18%
Travelers	12%
Chubb Ltd	9%

How do home and auto bundles affect car insurance rates in New York?

The table below displays New York auto insurance rates both before and after a bundling discount is applied. The cheapest price after the multi-policy discount belongs to State Farm at $2,451. The most significant discount on auto is offered by NYCM Insurance at 20%.

Company	Auto premium before bundling	Auto premium after bundling	$ difference after bundling	% difference after bundling
State Farm	$2,935	$2,451	$483	16%
NYCM Insurance	$3,927	$3,109	$818	20%
Allstate	$3,707	$3,251	$456	12%
Travelers	$4,008	$3,608	$400	10%
Chubb Ltd	$5,349	$4,866	$483	9%

What are the best home and auto insurance companies in New York?

When shopping for the right company for your home and auto insurance, it’s important to consider more than just bundling. You want a company that has a solid reputation as well as great rates. Below are the best home and auto insurance companies in New York overall based on our analysis of rates, financial stability and customer complaints.

Best home insurance companies in New York
Company	AM Best	NAIC	Average annual premium	Insurance.com score
Chubb Ltd	A++	0.18	$1,987	5.00
NYCM Insurance	A	0.21	$1,108	4.71
AIG	A	0.09	$1,564	4.65
American Family	A	0.37	$914	4.58
Travelers	A++	0.54	$1,606	4.12
State Farm	A++	0.95	$1,264	3.70
Nationwide	A+	0.87	$1,540	3.59
Allstate	A+	0.90	$1,876	3.37
Farmers	A	0.54	$3,330	3.06

Best car insurance companies in New York
Company	AM Best	JD Power by state	NAIC	Average annual premium	Insurance.com score
NYCM Insurance	A	842	0.22	$1,300	3.54
Erie Insurance	A	845	0.61	$1,814	3.04
Progressive	A+	818	0.65	$1,020	2.90
State Farm	A++	826	0.70	$1,951	2.75
Geico	A++	821	0.91	$1,736	2.73
The Hanover	A	835	0.60	$2,262	2.67
Allstate	A+	819	0.65	$2,056	2.45
Travelers	A++	821	0.49	$2,677	2.39

How does bundling home and car insurance work?

The concept of bundling is pretty straightforward. You buy more than one type of insurance from the same company and, in exchange for the increased business, the insurance company gives you a discount. And there’s an additional benefit for the insurer for offering bundles: Customers who bundle are more likely to renew their policies.

You typically get discounts on both car insurance and home insurance when you bundle coverage. The discount isn’t equal for both policies. Each insurer has its own discount formulas. Companies may offer a greater discount on one than the other.

The pros and cons of home and auto insurance bundles

The biggest benefit of bundling your home and auto insurance is a decreased premium.

But keep in mind that you won't always save money bundling. You could find a provider with a low price on one of the two policies, which could result in better savings than a bundle. Here’s how that works:

If you currently pay $1,000 for car insurance from one insurer and $1,200 for home insurance from another, that's a total of $2,200.
But let's say you decide to buy your home insurance from your auto insurer. The cost for the new home insurance policy is $1,500, or $300 more than your current cost.
Your total rate under the bundle would be $2,500, a $300 increase.
That means you'd need a bundle discount of at least $400 or so to lower the total bundle rate enough to save money compared to the price you currently pay for separate policies.

That's why you should compare home and auto insurance bundle quotes to what you're paying for separate policies. Rates on bundles aren't always lower.

Should you bundle home and auto insurance in New York?

Prior to signing up for an auto and home bundle, it’s important to shop around. Bundling your car and homeowners insurance has many advantages; you only have to deal with a single company and with a single bill, and you typically get a discount on both policies. Yet bundling isn’t always the best deal.

Some companies have cheap car insurance rates but less competitive home insurance rates, and vice versa. You might pay less overall by choosing two different companies for your insurance.

Shop around and evaluate New York car insurance rates on an individual basis and with a bundling discount to make sure you’re getting the best deal before you buy.

Methodology

In the spring of 2023, Insurance.com analyzed rate and discount data from Quadrant Data Services. The rates, from 2022, are the most recent available to Insurance.com and are based on a 40-year-old male driver with a 12-mile daily commute, good credit and a clean driving history. Rates were fielded for a full-coverage policy (100/300/100 with a $500 collision and comprehensive deductible). Homeowners insurance rates are based on $300,000 in dwelling coverage with $300,000 in liability and a $1,000 deductible.

FAQs: Home and auto insurance bundling

Below are answers to common questions about bundling home and auto bundles and other multi-policy discounts that can save you money on your insurance.

What information do you need to bundle your policies?

To bundle your policies you will need all of the details for both the cars and the home you want to insure. That includes VINs, driver information and details about the home. Your current home and auto policies will list this information for easy reference.

Which insurance companies bundle home and auto insurance?

Almost every insurance company offers a bundling discount, often called a multi-policy discount. Multi-policy discounts aren't just for auto and home. They often include other home insurance policies like renters and condo, as well as motorcycle insurance and in some cases life, RV, boat, and others.

What type of insurance policies can I bundle?

Multi-policy discounts can also apply to other types of insurance policies that you buy from the same insurance company. Depending upon the insurer, you may also be able to bundle these types of insurance policies:

Condo
Renters
Motorcycle
RV
Life

Some auto insurance companies don't write homeowners insurance, but some may align themselves with a home insurer to offer a discount. Ask your agent or customer service representative to see if you can bundle multiple insurance policies.

Helpful auto insurance tools and calculators