Travis Kelce Stops by Go-to Pizza Spot During Cleveland Visit — Find Out What Slices He Ordered!

Travis Kelce is a man of many titles: three-time Super Bowl champion, Taylor Swift’s boyfriend and — perhaps, most importantly — pizza connoisseur.

While visiting his home state of Ohio on Saturday, the Kansas City Chiefs tight end, who grew up in Cleveland suburb Westlake, made sure to stop by one of his favorite restaurants for some fresh slices.

The NFL star, 34, popped by Geraci’s Slice Shop, a retro-inspired spot in downtown Cleveland, where he opted for a classic slice, as well as one with a bit more spice.

According to a manager who was working when he stopped in, Kelce ordered both a pepperoni slice and the restaurant’s popular “Hot Tito” slice, a pepperoni and sausage slice drizzled with hot honey.

During his visit, Travis was dressed “kind of inconspicuous” — he wore sunglasses, a baseball cap and sweatshirt — and kept a low-key profile, the manager tells PEOPLE.

“He was just here with a few of his buddies, but nobody in-house really recognized him,” they add.

Still, the shop’s owner recognized him and snapped a photo of the athlete for Geraci’s Instagram account.

In the shot, Travis smiled and posed in front of one of the shop’s several neon signs, which reads, “Talk pizza to me.”

In the caption, the restaurant joked that during his next visit, the star should bring along girlfriend Swift, 34, for a slice of her own.

“When NFL star and Heights legend @killatrav swings by Geraci’s Slice Shop, you know it’s going to be a touchdown-worthy slice!” the caption reads. “Next time bring Taylor 😉 🏈🍕.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Kelce previously shared his fondness for Geraci’s during an episode of New Heights, his podcast with brother Jason Kelce.

While the brothers discussed some of their favorite Cleveland spots last December, the Chiefs star shouted out the restaurant.

"Geraci’s Pizza is also a very good spot hidden over in University Heights,” he said.

At the time, the restaurant shared the clip on Instagram, writing, “Travis knows what’s up!”