Entertainment Sports Football 8 Throwback Photos of Brothers Peyton Manning and Eli Manning In honor of Thanksgiving's other big draw — football! — look back on some of the NFL star brothers' earlier moments By Kate Hogan Kate Hogan Kate Hogan is Director of Digital Specials and Features at PEOPLE, as well as the editor of Stories to Make You Smile. She has been working at PEOPLE since 2008. People Editorial Guidelines Published on November 23, 2023 12:00PM EST Eli Manning and Peyton Manning in 2005. Photo: Jemal Countess/Getty Ah, Thanksgiving. A time for turkey, stuffing and ... football! Yes, once the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade has aired and the dishes are stacked in the kitchen sink, many Americans hit the couch for the holiday's other grand tradition, courtesy of the NFL. And fewer people are as associated with the sport than retired quarterback brothers, Peyton Manning and Eli Manning. The siblings played for 18 and 16 seasons, respectively, each earning two Super Bowl titles with their teams along the way. Though they've since left the field, they're still very closely aligned with the NFL thanks to their popular ESPN show ManningCast, a take on Monday Night Football that offers up their commentary, some celebrity guests and a healthy dose of their long-running sibling rivalry. But before all that, they were just two guys looking to follow in their famous dad Archie Manning's footsteps. Here, take a look at eight throwback photos of Peyton and Eli Manning. 01 of 08 Big Moment The Manning Family in 1998. Focus on Sport/Getty Peyton was the center of attention during the NFL Draft in 1998, joining the Indianapolis Colts with his parents Archie and Olivia and brother Eli by his side. 02 of 08 Double Trouble Peyton Manning and Eli Manning in 2004. Bill McCay/Getty They're both winners! The brothers each scooped up an award — Peyton the Bert Bell Award for Professional Player of the Year, and Eli the Maxwell Award for College Player of the Year — at the 2004 Maxwell Football Club Awards. 03 of 08 Family Photos Archie Manning, Peyton Manning and Eli Manning in 2004. Sporting News via Getty The brothers joined dad Archie — himself a former quarterback, too — for a 2004 photo shoot. 04 of 08 Take Two Archie Manning, Peyton Manning and Eli Manning in 2004. Sporting News via Getty Another pose for good measure. 05 of 08 Game Recognizes Game Eli Manning and Peyton Manning in 2006. Travis Lindquist/Getty After Eli's New York Giants lost to Peyton's Indianapolis Colts in September of 2006, the guys shared a moment on the field in East Rutherford, New Jersey. 06 of 08 Seat Yourself Peyton Manning and Eli Manning in 2004. M. Caulfield/WireImage The brothers stayed close at the 2004 ESPY Awards in Hollywood. 07 of 08 Twice as Nice Eli Manning and Peyton Manning in 2005. Jemal Countess/Getty The Mannings were all about the game at the 2005 Fantasy Football Training camp in N.Y.C. 08 of 08 Huddle Up Eli Manning, Archie Manning and Peyton Manning in 2006. Ezra Shaw/Getty Another day, another shoot with Dad, this one for Reebok in 2006. Close