O.J. Simpson Had 'Very Strong Ego' — and It 'Clouded a Lot of His Reactions,' Says Attorney (Exclusive)

Speaking with PEOPLE in the wake of Simpson's death, his defense attorneys reflect on the "Trial of the Century"

O. J. Simpson sits in Superior Court in Los Angeles 08 December 1994 during an open court session where Judge Lance Ito denied a media attorney's request to open court transcripts from a 07 December private meeting involving prospective jurors.
O. J. Simpson sits in Superior Court in Los Angeles 08 December 1994 during an open court session where Judge Lance Ito denied a media attorney's request to open court transcripts from a 07 December private meeting involving prospective jurors. . Photo:

POOL/AFP via Getty

Former attorneys for O.J. Simpson are speaking out about the “Trial of the Century” following Simpson's death from cancer on April 10.

Simpson was arrested in 1994 in connection with the deaths of his ex-wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and 25-year-old waiter Ron Goldman. The victims were brutally stabbed to death outside her Los Angeles home on June 12, 1994. 

“This is just a reminder for us of how long Ron has been gone, how long we have missed him and nothing more than that," Fred Goldman, Ron's father, tells PEOPLE. "That is the only thing that is important today. It is the pain from then until now. There is nothing today that is more important than the loss of my son and the loss of Nicole. Nothing is more important than that."

Simpson had nine attorneys on his defense team — Robert Blasier, Alan Dershowitz, Carl Douglas, Johnnie Cochran, Robert Shapiro, F. Lee Bailey, Barry Scheck, Robert Kardashian, Peter Neufeld, Gerald F. Uelmen, and Shawn Holley. Blasier, Dershowitz, and Douglas exclusively share their recollections of Simpson’s trial with PEOPLE.

“He will always have a mixed legacy,” Dershowitz, 85, tells PEOPLE. "But, he'll always be remembered as the defendant in the very important trial of 1995.”

Murder defendant OJ Simpson (2nd L) stands with his attorneys Robert Blasier (L), Johnnie Cochran Jr (2nd from R) and Robert Shapiro (R) as the jury enters the courtroom 26 April in the OJ Simpson murder trial. Jurors in the OJ Simpson saw for the first time 26 April the gold-framed prescription glasses that prosecutors say led Ronald Goldman to his death.
Murder defendant OJ Simpson (2nd L) stands with his attorneys Robert Blasier (L), Johnnie Cochran Jr (2nd from R) and Robert Shapiro (R) on April 26.

VINCE BUCCI / POOL / AFP

“He was very smart. He didn't always listen to his lawyer's advice,” explains Dershowitz, adding that he “told [Simpson] once he got acquitted to assume a low profile,” but “[he] did not.”

“He did some foolish things writing a book [If I Did It: Confessions of the Killer] or he went on a lot of television shows,” says Dershowitz. “[He] did not do himself very much good.”

Dershowitz continues that although Simpson has “a mixed legacy,” he notes that Simpson and his trial “had a big impact on the American justice system, on media coverage of trials, on corruption.”

“He had a big impact on racial divisions," Dershowitz says, adding that “he left a mark,” and notes the significance of Simpson’s trial being the first that was “tried live on television.”

O.J. Simpson defense attorney Alan Dershowitz (standing) gestures during a motion to Judge Lance Ito 16 June in which he said that the standard of juror dismissals must be changed.
Alan Dershowitz (standing), while prosecutors remain seated. (L-R) prosecutor Marcia Clark and Scott Gordon.

POO/AFP via Getty 

“Obviously, it was a huge case in everybody's past,” Blasier, 76, tells PEOPLE. “And it was remarkable. The whole case was just remarkable, both the civil and the criminal case.”

Blaiser reveals to PEOPLE that he and his ex-wife lived with Simpson during the civil trials. Brown and Goldman’s families pursued a wrongful death lawsuit against Simpson in civil court in 1996. The next year, Simpson was found liable for the two victims’ deaths. He was subsequently ordered to pay $33.5 million in damages.

“I lived down there with him and got to know him very well,” shares Blaiser. “It was a wonderful experience for me and getting to know him was special for me.” 

He notes how his client “had a very strong ego, as you can probably understand,” adding “that kind of clouded a lot of his reactions.” 

Double murder defendant O.J. Simpson (R) and defense attorney Carl Douglas (L) listen as Judge Lance Ito announces that the jury in the Simpson trial had reached a verdict 02 October in Los Angeles.
O.J. Simpson (R) and defense attorney Carl Douglas (L) on Oct. 2, 1995.

MYUNG J. CHUN/AFP via Getty

Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for PEOPLE's free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.

“O.J. just loved the affection of the adoring public, and he always hoped that he would be able to recapture that adoration after this trial,” Douglas, 68, tells PEOPLE. “He relished that positive attention.”  

This 21 June 1995 file photo shows former US football player and actor O.J. Simpson looking at a new pair of Aris extra-large gloves that prosecutors had him put on during his double-murder trial in Los Angeles.

VINCE BUCCI/AFP via Getty

“There could be three people out of a hundred who were saying things positive and he would only remember the three that were positive and care less about the others and what they thought about him,” explains Douglas.

Douglas adds that Simpson’s “legacy is a complicated one.” 

Related Articles