Olivia Rodrigo Wears 28-Year-Old Versace Dress to 2024 Grammys That Is Older Than She Is

Olivia Rodrigo's 2024 Grammys look is anything but a bad idea, right?

The three-time Grammy winner stepped out on the red carpet Sunday night wearing a vintage Versace gown that originally debuted in 1995 on Linda Evangelista. The dreamy white dress had thin straps and was dotted with delicate red and white beads. She accessorized with earrings and a bold red lip and sharp winged eyeliner. She wore her long brown hair down and parted to the side.

Rodrigo, 20, is nominated for another six awards at this year's show: record of the year, album of the year, song of the year, best pop solo performance, best pop vocal album and best rock song, all for her 2023 album Guts, which she released last September.

Speaking exclusively to PEOPLE at the Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes premiere in Los Angeles in January, the artist said it is “such an honor” to receive six nominations for this year's ceremony.

“Yeah. So insane. It's just such an honor and such a pleasure to be recognized by the music community in such an incredible way,” Rodrigo told PEOPLE. “I'm very grateful.”

She took home trophies two years ago for her debut album Sour. Rodrigo won best pop vocal album, best pop solo performance and best new artist.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up to date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

For her first trip to the Grammys in 2022, Rodrigo opted for a very Y2K look. The then-19-year-old walked the red carpet in a corseted, off-the-shoulder black dress with pink-and-black, body-outlining crystal detail by Vivienne Westwood. She accessorized the dress with black opera-length gloves and layered choker necklaces. On the beauty front, she wore smoky eye makeup, pink lip gloss and long, shiny waves (courtesy of Clayton Hawkins for Dove Hair).

"We wanted to do something fun and young but also we're at the Grammys. It's glamorous, it's classy," Rodrigo said of the look on E! Live from the Red Carpet.

For her next trip to the awards show, Rodrigo may not have been nominated — she didn't have an album out, calm down! — but she still showed out on the carpet. The "Vampire" singer stuck with her retro theme yet again, this time throwing it back even farther and choosing a '90s-esque dress for the big night.

She wore a slinky sheer Miu Miu slip dress with a sculptural Tiffany & Co. choker on the red carpet and later on stage as she presented the best new artist Grammy to Samara Joy.

See PEOPLE's full coverage of the 66th annual Grammy Awards as they're broadcasting live on CBS and Paramount+ on Feb. 4 from the Crypto.com Arena in Los Angeles.