Wakatū Incorporation reposted this
Recently, the Crown lodged an appeal against the High Court’s decision in Stafford v Attorney-General. While this is deeply disappointing for us, it’s not a huge surprise. The Crown has fought us at every turn. Now, the Crown has appealed the High Court’s decision on almost every point, even arguments that we believe have no factual or legal defence, that have already been determined by the Supreme Court. Here’s an example. In the High Court the Crown argued that its fiduciary duties to reserve the Tenths and exclude the Occupation Lands did not require it to actually achieve those outcomes, just to act with loyalty and good faith even if they didn’t reserve what they were legally required to. This is despite the Supreme Court in 2017 finding that the Crown had a duty to “reserve 15,100 acres for the benefit of the customary owners and, in addition, to exclude their pā, urupā and cultivations from the land obtained by the Crown following the 1845 Spain award.” The High Court dismissed this argument, but the Crown has resurrected it on appeal. #tehereānuku #makingthetenthswhole